MHB Solve the Pigeonhole Principle Problem w/ PHP

  • Thread starter Thread starter magneto1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Principle
magneto1
Messages
100
Reaction score
0
Ran across this problem reading another forum, and wonder if PHP allies here.

Given a set $X$ of 16 positive distinct integers, you can find non-empty, disjoint subsets $A, B \subset X$ such
that $A$ and $B$ have the same number of elements, and $|\alpha - \beta| < 0.0025$, where $\alpha = \sum_{a \in A} \frac 1a$, and $\beta = \sum_{b \in B} \frac 1b$.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
magneto said:
Ran across this problem reading another forum, and wonder if PHP allies here.

Given a set $X$ of 16 positive distinct integers, you can find non-empty, disjoint subsets $A, B \subset X$ such
that $A$ and $B$ have the same number of elements, and $|\alpha - \beta| < 0.0025$, where $\alpha = \sum_{a \in A} \frac 1a$, and $\beta = \sum_{b \in B} \frac 1b$.
Given any subset $S$ of $X$, we have

$$
\sum_{s\in S}\frac{1}{s} \leq \sum_{x\in X} \frac{1}{x} \leq \frac{1}{1}+\frac{1}{2}+ \frac{1}{3}+\cdots +\frac{1}{16} \leq 3.4
$$

Let us denote the set of all the $8$ element subsets of $X$ by $X_8$.
Now there are $\binom{16}{8}=12,870$ distinct members in $X_8$.

Partition the interval $[0,3.4]$ into $12,869$ equal parts. So each part has length no more than $0.00027$.

By pigeon hole principle, some two members of $X_8$ will have their corresponding sums falling in a common partition. Thus we have $|\alpha -\beta|<0.00027$ for some $\alpha = \sum_{a\in A}1/a$ and $\beta = \sum_{b\in B}1/b$, where $A, B\in X_8$.

If $A$ and $B$ are not disjoint, then we consider $A'=A-B$ and $B'=B-A$. Thus we again have $|A'|=|B'|$, and

$$\sum_{a'\in A'}\frac{1}{a'}-\sum_{b'\in B'}\frac{1}{b'} = \alpha -\beta$$

This bound is better than the one the question asks for. May be I made some calculation error. I cannot find any errors.
 
Namaste & G'day Postulate: A strongly-knit team wins on average over a less knit one Fundamentals: - Two teams face off with 4 players each - A polo team consists of players that each have assigned to them a measure of their ability (called a "Handicap" - 10 is highest, -2 lowest) I attempted to measure close-knitness of a team in terms of standard deviation (SD) of handicaps of the players. Failure: It turns out that, more often than, a team with a higher SD wins. In my language, that...
Hi all, I've been a roulette player for more than 10 years (although I took time off here and there) and it's only now that I'm trying to understand the physics of the game. Basically my strategy in roulette is to divide the wheel roughly into two halves (let's call them A and B). My theory is that in roulette there will invariably be variance. In other words, if A comes up 5 times in a row, B will be due to come up soon. However I have been proven wrong many times, and I have seen some...
Back
Top