B Solving Square Root & Quadratic Equations

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the equation 0 = √x - √x, with the original poster questioning the validity of manipulating it to 0 = 2√x. Participants clarify that the two forms of the equation are not equivalent, as the first simplifies to zero while the second implies a different relationship. The conversation also touches on the nature of square roots and the solutions to equations involving them, emphasizing that √x has a single value for nonnegative x. Ultimately, the thread concludes with the original poster expressing frustration over their inability to articulate their question effectively. The thread is subsequently closed.
Einstein's Cat
Messages
182
Reaction score
2
Let's say there's an equation

0 = √x - √x

I intend to make x the subject of the equation; however because it is a square root, there are numerous solutions; however can I just assume that

0= √x - -√x= 2√x

Can I now just rearrange this equation to make x the subject? In other words is the equation above equivalent to the equation below?

0= -√x -√x = -2√x

Would the same be true if there were roots in a quadratic equation?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Do you really expect that a-a=2a in general? Here a=sqrt(x).

What do you know about the solutions to the equation 0=a-a?
 
If something equals 0, you can flip the sign any way you want.
If x = 0, then -x = 0 as well
 
mfb said:
Do you really expect that a-a=2a in general? Here a=sqrt(x).

What do you know about the solutions to the equation 0=a-a?

I think that as this applies to any number; the solutions is any number and therefore the equation is undefined.
 
Einstein's Cat said:
Let's say there's an equation

0 = √x - √x
Do you realize that the right side is equal to zero for any nonnegative real number x?
Einstein's Cat said:
I intend to make x the subject of the equation; however because it is a square root, there are numerous solutions
Not sure what you mean by this. The symbol ##\sqrt{x}## has one value, assuming that ##x \ge 0##.
Einstein's Cat said:
; however can I just assume that

0= √x - -√x= 2√x
?
This is different from the equation you have at the top of your post.
The first equation you show is √x - √x = 0. The equation just above, when simplified is √x + √x = 0. These two equations are not equivalent.
Einstein's Cat said:
Can I now just rearrange this equation to make x the subject? In other words is the equation above equivalent to the equation below?

0= -√x -√x = -2√x

Would the same be true if there were roots in a quadratic equation?
I don't understand what you're asking here.
 
Mark44 said:
Do you realize that the right side is equal to zero for any nonnegative real number x?
Not sure what you mean by this. The symbol ##\sqrt{x}## has one value, assuming that ##x \ge 0##.
?
This is different from the equation you have at the top of your post.
The first equation you show is √x - √x = 0. The equation just above, when simplified is √x + √x = 0. These two equations are not equivalent.

I don't understand what you're asking here.
I apologise for I am unable to express what I mean; this thread serves no purpose
 
Einstein's Cat said:
I apologise for I am unable to express what I mean; this thread serves no purpose
Thread closed.
 
Back
Top