Starting a Fireplace Fire: Tips & Techniques

  • Thread starter Thread starter zoobyshoe
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Fire Tips
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around various techniques and personal experiences related to starting a fire in a fireplace. Participants share methods, tips, and anecdotes, covering both traditional and modern approaches, as well as safety considerations and preferences for different types of fuel.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants describe their personal methods for starting a fire, such as using crumpled newspaper and kindling made from twigs or small logs.
  • Others mention the use of firelogs for convenience, highlighting the ease of lighting them compared to traditional methods.
  • A few participants share experiences from their childhood, learning fire-starting techniques from family or scouting, including friction methods and the use of specific wood types.
  • Concerns about safety are raised, particularly regarding starting fires in brush shelters.
  • Some participants express a preference for the sensory experience of a real fire over alternatives like video fireplaces.
  • There are humorous exchanges about the challenges and mishaps associated with fire starting, including anecdotes about cooking failures during scouting trips.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally share a variety of methods and experiences without reaching a consensus on the best approach. There are differing opinions on the use of firelogs versus traditional wood, and safety concerns are not universally agreed upon.

Contextual Notes

Participants' methods and experiences vary widely based on personal history, location, and available materials. Some techniques may depend on specific conditions, such as weather or type of wood, which are not fully explored in the discussion.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in practical fire-starting techniques, those looking for tips on using fireplaces, and people curious about personal experiences related to fire-making may find this discussion valuable.

  • #31
Moonbear said:
Maybe it's my night to be slow, but...what? How do you get from a fireplace in the bedroom to a fire on the dresser?
Probably the tv location.

Evo, on one snowy night, I decided to just pull out the sofabed and turned my living room into the bedroom for the night so I could watch TV in bed by the fire. :biggrin: There was only one thing missing. :wink:
A good single malt scotch?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Evo said:
Probably the tv location.
Oh...as in the video? Yep, I'm definitely slow tonight.

A good single malt scotch?
Nope...a guy! :biggrin:
 
  • #33
Moonbear said:
There was only one thing missing. :wink:

Batteries?

I kid, I kid.

- Warren
 
  • #34
chroot said:
Batteries?

I kid, I kid.

- Warren
:smile: I never run out of batteries! :rolleyes: :blushing: :rolleyes: o:)

...for the remote for the fireplace of course. o:)
 
  • #35
Did everyone read Chroots list, CAREFULLY?
chroot said:
1. Two quarts of water
2. Compass
3. Storm whistle
4. Two sources of cold light (LED headlamp and larger flashlight, plus some glow sticks)
5. Two sources of fire (waterproof matches and lighter)
6. Firestarter material (I use a pouch of lint from my clothes dryer)
7. First-aid kit (basic bandages, ointments, sting kit, gloves, etc.)
8. 6,000 kcal worth of granola bars
9. Change of clothes (polypro)
10. Foldable 3-inch knife.
11. Two trash bags for improvised shelter.
12. Prussik cord for self-belay
13. Tubular webbing for seats, harnesses, shelter, etc.
14. Leather work gloves
15. Lots and lots of batteries!
16. Waterproof paper/pen
17. Flagging tape

- Warren
 
  • #36
The granola bars?
 
  • #37
Oh my! I have a feeling chroot doesn't need batteries. :-p
 
  • #38
Chi Meson said:
Did everyone read Chroots list, CAREFULLY?
:smile: Lots and LOTS of batteries. :smile: Hey, if you're going to be stranded in the wilderness, you have to have your priorities straight. Deer are a lot harder to sneak up on than sheep. :biggrin:
 
  • #39
#4 where he says 2 sources of cold light, but then names 3?

Give us a hint, what kind of thing are we looking for?
 
  • #40
zoobyshoe said:
#4 where he says 2 sources of cold light, but then names 3?

Give us a hint, what kind of thing are we looking for?
GLOW STICKS!
He's trying to tell us that Chroot is a raver!:bugeye:
 
  • #41
I don't know what I said that was so funny either. :frown: Glad I'm entertaining though. :biggrin:

- Warren
 
  • #42
chroot said:
I don't know what I said that was so funny either. :frown: Glad I'm entertaining though. :biggrin:

- Warren
Your survival kit includes lots of batteries and you were picking on me for needing batteries. :smile:
 
  • #43
chroot said:
I don't know what I said that was so funny either. :frown: Glad I'm entertaining though. :biggrin:

- Warren
Item 15 in the quote.


I too kid.
 
  • #44
Our fireplace is ornamental. We have stones in it. And a rollmat shoved up the chimney to stop the draft. In my house we have radiators so there is no need for a fire, but if I were desperate, put some bread in a toaster and turn the knob right up... why do they have settings that burn toast?
 
  • #45
Moonbear said:
Your survival kit includes lots of batteries and you were picking on me for needing batteries. :smile:

My survival kit doesn't include lots of batteries. Chi Meson was just misquoting me for humor value. :frown:

- Warren
 
  • #46
I'm guessing that this is a stupid question but shouldn't your survival kit also include a map and mapcase?

I wouldn't just carry a knife, I'd get the fattest swiss army knife there was. You are bound to use most of the appliances!
 
  • #47
I would take a good-quality folding pocket knife over a Swiss Army knife anyday.

And, of course, maps are integral to search and rescue operations, but you rarely know where you're going to be sent until it's time to go. We generally photocopied USGS maps and headed out moments later.

- Warren
 
  • #48
chroot said:
My survival kit doesn't include lots of batteries. Chi Meson was just misquoting me for humor value. :frown:

- Warren
You're kind for using the word "value."
 
  • #49
chroot said:
I would take a good-quality folding pocket knife over a Swiss Army knife anyday.
Yes, a good quality folding knife with a blade that locks open and a lightweight alloy frame. Big size, but light - I have several.

As a kid, I learned how to make a fire fairly quickly with a friction bow - just carry a piece of rawhide in your pack, cut a hard branch for the shaft another branch for the bow and some softer wood for base and top pivot - drill the sockets with the tip of a knife. That's handy to know, but not as practical as the little kit I kept in my pack for hiking, fishing, and hunting.

It was an aluminum film can packed with some tinder, into which I jammed a short piece of hacksaw blade and a small hardwood stick into which I drilled proper-sized holes and embedded lighter flints. Place a bit of tinder in some combustible materials, hold the stick near the tinder and rake across the flints with the hacksaw blade to make a shower of sparks. You can start a fire very quickly with that set-up, and my parents were comfortable with my carrying that. They would probably not have liked to see a 10 year old with a Zippo, but if you're going to go miles into the Maine woods alone, it's a good idea to have some way to start a fire in case you are injured and can't walk back out.
 
  • #50
chroot said:
My survival kit doesn't include lots of batteries. Chi Meson was just misquoting me for humor value. :frown:

- Warren
I guess you can tell how carefully we read the original list then, huh? :rolleyes:
 
  • #51
:sniffle: :tear:

- Warren
 
  • #52
turbo-1 said:
As a kid, I learned how to make a fire fairly quickly with a friction bow -
OK, you're the one we want to ask. Having all the proper pieces of wood, how long does it take from when you first start bowing till having a fire started?
 
  • #53
zoobyshoe said:
OK, you're the one we want to ask. Having all the proper pieces of wood, how long does it take from when you first start bowing till having a fire started?
Here's the trick: you drill a pocket in your soft base with the tip of your knife, and you shape the tip of the spindle to fit that pocket as close as you can. This gives you a lot of contact area (friction) when you start bowing. You also want to carve a little channel from the pocket in which to place your tinder. If I recall, I've gotten a nice flame in as little as 5 minutes or so. If you've done well (and you're bearing down on the top block as you bow) you will get smoke in just a couple of minutes, but you will not get flames unless you've got good-quality tinder adjacent to the pocket in the bottom block. It helps if your bottom block is soft, dry wood, and can easily deform to the pressure of the spindle, giving you the maximum surface contact and friction. Soft white pine and cedar are really good choices, here.

The optimal choice is VERY hardwood for the spindle, VERY soft wood for the base (where you want to build the fire), a relatively hardwood for the top block (to reduce friction), and the selection of wood for the bow is "whatever". It is very easy to get a fire going with this technique if you have collected some good tinder. Some good tinder might be sun-dried peat, leaf duff, lichens, etc. There is a lot of stuff that can be found for tinder, even when it is cold or very wet - you just have to know how and where to look.
 
Last edited:
  • #54
I would carry a flint.
 
  • #55
Evo said:
I would carry a flint.
That's great, if you remember to bring along something that is hard enough to generate sparks when you abrade the flint, and can find suitable tinder. My little film can "fire kit" was sufficient to ensure that I could build a fire any time that I wanted. Carrying a piece of flint in my pocket would not have ensured this, at least not on a timely basis, especially if I had a broken leg and could not forage for tinder and firewood. The fellow who taught me this was a pretty sharp old guy.
 
  • #56
turbo-1 said:
That's great, if you remember to bring along something that is hard enough to generate sparks when you abrade the flint, and can find suitable tinder. My little film can "fire kit" was sufficient to ensure that I could build a fire any time that I wanted. Carrying a piece of flint in my pocket would not have ensured this, at least not on a timely basis, especially if I had a broken leg and could not forage for tinder and firewood. The fellow who taught me this was a pretty sharp old guy.
Yeah, a flint and striker and some dry tinder. That was a common "fire kit" back in the old days. A lot easier than the bow, although in areas that flint was not available, that was the next best option.
 
  • #57
turbo-1 said:
Here's the trick: you drill a pocket in your soft base with the tip of your knife, and you shape the tip of the spindle to fit that pocket as close as you can. This gives you a lot of contact area (friction) when you start bowing. You also want to carve a little channel from the pocket in which to place your tinder. If I recall, I've gotten a nice flame in as little as 5 minutes or so. If you've done well (and you're bearing down on the top block as you bow) you will get smoke in just a couple of minutes, but you will not get flames unless you've got good-quality tinder adjacent to the pocket in the bottom block. It helps if your bottom block is soft, dry wood, and can easily deform to the pressure of the spindle, giving you the maximum surface contact and friction. Soft white pine and cedar are really good choices, here.

The optimal choice is VERY hardwood for the spindle, VERY soft wood for the base (where you want to build the fire), a relatively hardwood for the top block (to reduce friction), and the selection of wood for the bow is "whatever". It is very easy to get a fire going with this technique if you have collected some good tinder. Some good tinder might be sun-dried peat, leaf duff, lichens, etc. There is a lot of stuff that can be found for tinder, even when it is cold or very wet - you just have to know how and where to look.

These are very much the same details I read in a book on Indian Craft. One additional thing was the reccomendation to grease the spindle where it meets the pressure block. Bear grease was the Indians choice. Otherwise you're sort of starting an ember at that end as well. If you have no bear grease he reccomended rubbing the non-friction end on your face now and then to pick up the oils. (Presumably you've been out in the wilderness without a proper bath for weeks, I guess. Or you're a teenager.)
 
  • #58
Zoobies can do things with brush people
First zoobies, now brush people?
 
  • #59
As a kid, I learned how to make a fire fairly quickly with a friction bow - just carry a piece of rawhide in your pack, cut a hard branch for the shaft another branch for the bow and some softer wood for base and top pivot - drill the sockets with the tip of a knife. That's handy to know, but not as practical as the little kit I kept in my pack for hiking, fishing, and hunting.

It was an aluminum film can packed with some tinder, into which I jammed a short piece of hacksaw blade and a small hardwood stick into which I drilled proper-sized holes and embedded lighter flints. Place a bit of tinder in some combustible materials, hold the stick near the tinder and rake across the flints with the hacksaw blade to make a shower of sparks. You can start a fire very quickly with that set-up, and my parents were comfortable with my carrying that. They would probably not have liked to see a 10 year old with a Zippo, but if you're going to go miles into the Maine woods alone, it's a good idea to have some way to start a fire in case you are injured and can't walk back out.
VERY cool! Flint in holes in a stick! Maybe I should put that in my future emergency kit! Or maybe a magnifying glass or a Fresnel lens would make-do better. But not as cool. :cool:
 
  • #60
It has been a while since I did any off-route packing...

but I still have my Zippo lighter. I'd usually use a disposable Bic lighter, but the Zippo would always spark nicely (unless wet). Starting up the Whisperlight stove, the spark is all you need.

Never, ever rubbed two stick together. I figure, if I got myself in that situation, I didn't deserve any fire.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
6K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
7K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
9K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K