- #1
ajtcal
- 3
- 0
(PREAMBLE: skip to the third paragraph if desired)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am currently a physics student about to begin my graduate studies. I will be attending a top-5 school, so I am quite fortunate in that regard. However, having spent time there doing summer research (QCD), I am fully aware of the high standards that will be imposed on me and the fact that I will be working much harder than ever before.
It is my goal to acquire a deeper understanding of my field than I currently have, and that is the basis of my question. I want to re-learn (so to speak) the physics and math that I already do know so that I can have a better foundation for understanding the deeper topics that I will need later on in my research. Therefore, I am considering a program of study to complete during my first two years. I will have a fellowship and I have a very easy-going adviser, so other than a few classes and further work on research (continuing from my summer term), I should be able to devote a good deal of time to these studies.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------My intention is to solidify the topics I learned during my undergraduate years during the first year, and then approach more involved foundational topics during my second year.
I present a list of the math and physics topics I propose to study, the sequence in which I will study them, and the textbooks I will start with. I plan to spend a month or two on each book and then about a month doing extensive related problems. From previous experience, I think I should be able to manage about 10 pages in about three hours to really mull things over. I guess this translates into about six hours of study per day, so I should have a decent amount of time left over for classes and research. For any upper-level graduate students, postdocs, or higher, could you please comment on whether my sequence is sound and if you have any comments on the books I plan to use?FIRST YEAR
PHYSICS
Classical Mechanics (Mechanics, Landau and Lifschitz) - I did this this summer
Statistical Mechanics (Fundamentals of Statistical and Thermal Physics, Reif)
E&M (Classical Theory of Fields, L&L)
QM (Quantum Mechanics: Non-relativistic Theory, L&L)
Relativity (Gravitation, Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler)
MATH
Real and Complex Analysis (Modern Analysis, Watson and Whittaker)
ODEs (Ordinary Differential Equations, Arnold)
PDEs (I might just reuse my undergrad book unless someone has any good recommendations?)
Algebra (Abstract Algebra, Herstein)
Set Theory & Logic (Recommendations? I only want a brief overview)
Probability and Statistics (Recommendations? Also a brief overview)
Combinatorics (Recommendations? Brief overview)SECOND YEAR
PHYSICS
QFT (Quantum Field Theory, Ryder)
Particle Physics (Recommendations?)
Nuclear Physics (Introductory Nuclear Physics, Krane)
Plasma Physics (Recommendations?)MATH
Topology (Recommendations?)
Tensors (Tensors, Lovelock and Rund)
Lie Algebras (Lie Groups, Lie Algebras, and Some of Their Applications, Gilmore)
Differential Geometry (Manifolds and Differential Geometry, Lee)
Algebraic Geometry (Algebraic Geometry, Hartshorne)--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I realize there are already flaws (differential geometry after relativity), but I have to do my qualification exam at the end of first year. Also, I imagine some people will say that there is no need (nor possibly enough time) to read all of these books. However, unlike most of the beginning students, I will already have a research program well under way, and I was told that, provided it goes reasonably well, I won’t have to take very many classes (maybe just one or two a semester, provided I am enrolled in a research class).
Anyways, my hope is that someone (or someones) could share their thoughts on my plan. Some of the topics (especially second-year math) seem somewhat hodge-podge and arbitrary, and might not be the best order in which I could learn the topics. If I’m missing anything glaringly obvious, or if you have any suggestions for topics to study in my third year and beyond, I would also appreciate that. My primary goal is to learn these topics quite deeply so that I can really know what I’m doing in the second half of my degree.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I just re-read this post and realize it sounds kind of naive/pretentious, but that wasn't my intention! Hopefully you guys will look beyond that and give some good advice.
Cheers,
James
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am currently a physics student about to begin my graduate studies. I will be attending a top-5 school, so I am quite fortunate in that regard. However, having spent time there doing summer research (QCD), I am fully aware of the high standards that will be imposed on me and the fact that I will be working much harder than ever before.
It is my goal to acquire a deeper understanding of my field than I currently have, and that is the basis of my question. I want to re-learn (so to speak) the physics and math that I already do know so that I can have a better foundation for understanding the deeper topics that I will need later on in my research. Therefore, I am considering a program of study to complete during my first two years. I will have a fellowship and I have a very easy-going adviser, so other than a few classes and further work on research (continuing from my summer term), I should be able to devote a good deal of time to these studies.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------My intention is to solidify the topics I learned during my undergraduate years during the first year, and then approach more involved foundational topics during my second year.
I present a list of the math and physics topics I propose to study, the sequence in which I will study them, and the textbooks I will start with. I plan to spend a month or two on each book and then about a month doing extensive related problems. From previous experience, I think I should be able to manage about 10 pages in about three hours to really mull things over. I guess this translates into about six hours of study per day, so I should have a decent amount of time left over for classes and research. For any upper-level graduate students, postdocs, or higher, could you please comment on whether my sequence is sound and if you have any comments on the books I plan to use?FIRST YEAR
PHYSICS
Classical Mechanics (Mechanics, Landau and Lifschitz) - I did this this summer
Statistical Mechanics (Fundamentals of Statistical and Thermal Physics, Reif)
E&M (Classical Theory of Fields, L&L)
QM (Quantum Mechanics: Non-relativistic Theory, L&L)
Relativity (Gravitation, Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler)
MATH
Real and Complex Analysis (Modern Analysis, Watson and Whittaker)
ODEs (Ordinary Differential Equations, Arnold)
PDEs (I might just reuse my undergrad book unless someone has any good recommendations?)
Algebra (Abstract Algebra, Herstein)
Set Theory & Logic (Recommendations? I only want a brief overview)
Probability and Statistics (Recommendations? Also a brief overview)
Combinatorics (Recommendations? Brief overview)SECOND YEAR
PHYSICS
QFT (Quantum Field Theory, Ryder)
Particle Physics (Recommendations?)
Nuclear Physics (Introductory Nuclear Physics, Krane)
Plasma Physics (Recommendations?)MATH
Topology (Recommendations?)
Tensors (Tensors, Lovelock and Rund)
Lie Algebras (Lie Groups, Lie Algebras, and Some of Their Applications, Gilmore)
Differential Geometry (Manifolds and Differential Geometry, Lee)
Algebraic Geometry (Algebraic Geometry, Hartshorne)--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I realize there are already flaws (differential geometry after relativity), but I have to do my qualification exam at the end of first year. Also, I imagine some people will say that there is no need (nor possibly enough time) to read all of these books. However, unlike most of the beginning students, I will already have a research program well under way, and I was told that, provided it goes reasonably well, I won’t have to take very many classes (maybe just one or two a semester, provided I am enrolled in a research class).
Anyways, my hope is that someone (or someones) could share their thoughts on my plan. Some of the topics (especially second-year math) seem somewhat hodge-podge and arbitrary, and might not be the best order in which I could learn the topics. If I’m missing anything glaringly obvious, or if you have any suggestions for topics to study in my third year and beyond, I would also appreciate that. My primary goal is to learn these topics quite deeply so that I can really know what I’m doing in the second half of my degree.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I just re-read this post and realize it sounds kind of naive/pretentious, but that wasn't my intention! Hopefully you guys will look beyond that and give some good advice.
Cheers,
James
Last edited by a moderator: