Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around finding an appropriate synonym for "troupe" to describe a group of children and youths in a pre-historical setting (20,000 BCE) who are fleeing their village. Participants explore various terms that convey the right tone and context for the narrative, considering both the age range and the dynamics of the group.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses difficulty in finding a suitable term, noting that "children" and "youths" are awkward together and that "troupe" feels too modern.
- Another suggests "pack" or "herd" but finds them too predatory, seeking more neutral terms that can stand alone without additional descriptors.
- Several participants propose alternatives such as "band," "gang," "company," and "congregation," but some feel these are too modern for the setting.
- One participant suggests "troop" as a potential fit, clarifying that "troupe" is typically associated with performers.
- Another lists various collective nouns like "community," "collective," and "companionship," emphasizing the tone desired for the group.
- A later reply introduces terms like "cohort," "remnant," "nest," and "fledglings," providing nuanced options that align with the prehistorical context.
- Some participants discuss the implications of using "brood," noting its connotations of familial ties, which may not fit a mixed group.
- There is a suggestion to consider animal-based collective nouns, but participants express concerns about their suitability without additional context.
- One participant reflects on the challenge of naming while maintaining narrative clarity, suggesting a return to using "tribe" despite its modern implications.
- Another participant questions the modernity of "clan," leading to a discussion about the historical context of terms.
- Finally, there is a suggestion to redefine the group's identity based on their situation as refugees or fugitives, emphasizing the need for imagery that resonates with their time.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a range of opinions on suitable terms, with no consensus reached on a single term. Multiple competing views remain regarding the appropriateness of various synonyms.
Contextual Notes
Some terms proposed may carry unintended connotations or may not fit well without additional descriptors. The discussion reflects the challenge of balancing historical accuracy with narrative clarity.
Who May Find This Useful
Writers and storytellers interested in historical or prehistorical narratives, particularly those focusing on group dynamics and collective identities.