Tangherlini transformations and absolute simultaneity: a rotor model

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter AlexOsipovich
  • Start date
46 replies · 1K views · last reply
AlexOsipovich said:
Could you please clarify how does the modified Newton’s law affect it?
In the Einstein rest frame of the rotor the path is circular. In the Einstein frame where the rotor is moving the path is a spiral of some sort. Both of these are governed by the force law @Dale quoted. In your Tangherlini rest "frame" I would expect the path to be elliptical but not governed by the law Dale quoted, since that assumes an Einstein frame.
 
Ibix said:
In your Tangherlini rest "frame" I would expect the path to be elliptical
That’s correct, the trajectory will be elliptical, but for what reason will it be elliptical?

(The clocks are synchronized according to Tangherlini not without reason, but because the physical one-way speed of light in the reference frame is anisotropic (since the frame is in motion relative to the ether))

Does the law that Dale shared have any influence on the trajectory?
Or does the trajectory depend on a reconfiguration of the electromagnetic forces within the atomic lattice (Lorentz length contraction)?
 
AlexOsipovich said:
That’s correct, the trajectory will be elliptical, but for what reason will it be elliptical?
If you know it will be elliptical, presumably you've done the math that shows that. What more reason do you need?

AlexOsipovich said:
Does the law that Dale shared have any influence on the trajectory?
This question has been answered. The law that @Dale gave is valid in the Einstein synchronized frame. But the Tangherlini frame is not the same, so you need to transform all of the equations into that frame in order to calculate what things are like in that frame. As above, the fact that you are asserting that the trajectory is elliptical in that frame implies that you've already done all that math, so I'm not clear about why you keep asking what determines the trajectory.

AlexOsipovich said:
Or does the trajectory depend on a reconfiguration of the electromagnetic forces within the atomic lattice (Lorentz length contraction)?
There is no "or" here. The math is what it is. What you are saying here is a physical interpretation of the math, which could just as well be applied in the Einstein frame (the one in which the rotor is moving) as in the Tangherlini frame. Either way it's something over and above the math itself.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
Does the law that Dale shared have any influence on the trajectory?
Not in your Tangherlini coordinates. You could derive an equivalent law if you wanted.
AlexOsipovich said:
Or does the trajectory depend on a reconfiguration of the electromagnetic forces within the atomic lattice (Lorentz length contraction)?
You can model the rotor as a set of point particles connected by EM forces if you want. It seems over complicated to me. But if you really want to go full reductionist on this, yes, the ultimate cause of the rotor rotating rather than disintegrating is the interactions between atoms and electromagnetic fields. The higher level model is to describe the strain field in the material and transform that, which is the line of thought that Dale's force law comes from (but that particular version assumes vanilla SR frames).

I wouldn't describe any of this as a "reconfiguration". You are still describing the same Faraday tensor field and the same worldlines of atoms as in vanilla SR. You're just picking a non-standard way of describing it and thinking of this as "what's really happening according to LET". The mathematical pain you encounter is the price of imposing an ontology that doesn't reflect the symmetries of the mathematical model.
 
PeterDonis said:
This question has been answered. The law that @Dale gave is valid in the Einstein synchronized frame. But the Tangherlini frame is not the same, so you need to transform all of the equations into that frame in order to calculate what things are like in that frame. As above, the fact that you are asserting that the trajectory is elliptical in that frame implies that you've already done all that math, so I'm not clear about why you keep asking what determines the trajectory.
Here is the problem with how I calculated the elliptical trajectory: it doesn't arise from the modified Newton's law.
1794956789996.webp

As far as I understand, this law determines:
1. the speed of the moving point,
2. the mass,
and, as a consequence, the tension force of the string. However, the shape of the trajectory does not depend on this it depends on the contraction of the atoms in the crystal lattice. Right?
 
AlexOsipovich said:
Here is the problem with how I calculated the elliptical trajectory: it doesn't arise from the modified Newton's law.
1794956789996.webp
Correct.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
the shape of the trajectory does not depend on this it depends on the contraction of the atoms in the crystal lattice. Right?
Wrong. In the Einstein frame, the equation you gave relates the force on each atom to the trajectory of that atom. The force on each atom is the sum of the electromagnetic forces exerted on it by other atoms. "The contraction of the atoms" is just another way of describing how the trajectories of the atoms behave under those forces. Again, these are not two different things that could be determining the shape of the trajectory; they're the same thing, just described in two different ways (math vs. physical interpretation).
 
AlexOsipovich said:
how does this law force atoms to end up at the required position on the rotor’s ellipse?
The force law provides a second order differential equation. The solution to that differential equation is the path of the particle.

In order to solve the differential equation you generally will need to use numerical methods. You will also need to provide the initial position and initial velocity of the particle.
 
Dale said:
The force law provides a second order differential equation. The solution to that differential equation is the path of the particle.

In order to solve the differential equation you generally will need to use numerical methods. You will also need to provide the initial position and initial velocity of the particle.

Physically (cause and effect), that elliptical shape comes entirely from the Lorentz-contracted equilibrium length of the string/lattice encoded inside, whereas the relativistic inertia factor governs the variable speed of the particle along that ellipse.

When the string undergoes Lorentz contraction, its tension constrains the particle to an ellipse, so integrating the second-order ODE produces an elliptical trajectory. However, if the string does not contract, integrating the exact same relativistic ODE yields a circle—the relativistic inertia terms alone do not produce the Lorentz-contracted ellipse. please confirm, right?
 
PeterDonis said:
the equation you gave relates the force on each atom to the trajectory of that atom. The force on each atom is the sum of the electromagnetic forces exerted on it by other atoms. "The contraction of the atoms" is just another way of describing how the trajectories of the atoms behave under those forces.
Taken as a whole, that’s true, but I’m interested in the details the physical cause and effect.
The string contracted, pulling on the point, and the point began to trace an ellipse. Please confirm, right?
 
AlexOsipovich said:
Physically (cause and effect), that elliptical shape comes entirely from the Lorentz-contracted equilibrium length of the string/lattice encoded inside, whereas the relativistic inertia factor governs the variable speed of the particle along that ellipse.
Most physicists using standard SR would not agree with these claims because they are frame-dependent.

For example, "Lorentz contraction" is not a real physical effect on this view, just a change of coordinates, and does not physically change the object at all. For example, you are Lorentz contracted by a very large gamma factor with respect to cosmic rays hitting the Earth right now. Are you physically changed because of this?

"Relativistic inertia" is similar: relative to those cosmic rays, your "relativistic inertia" is huge, many many times your weight. Do you feel sluggish? Is your body harder to move?

There have been physicists who have made arguments for considering frame-dependent things like these to have at least some kind of "physical reality": John Bell's article on "How to Teach Special Relativity" comes to mind as an example. But such viewpoints seem to be a small minority.

AlexOsipovich said:
When the string undergoes Lorentz contraction, its tension constrains the particle to an ellipse
But this implies that the tension is somehow different in the "moving" frame than in the "rest" frame (where the center of mass of the system is at rest). But tension in the string is a direct observable: it can only have one value. So this "explanation" doesn't seem right.
 
PeterDonis said:
Most physicists using standard SR would not agree with these claims because they are frame-dependent.

For example, "Lorentz contraction" is not a real physical effect on this view, just a change of coordinates, and does not physically change the object at all. For example, you are Lorentz contracted by a very large gamma factor with respect to cosmic rays hitting the Earth right now. Are you physically changed because of this?

"Relativistic inertia" is similar: relative to those cosmic rays, your "relativistic inertia" is huge, many many times your weight. Do you feel sluggish? Is your body harder to move?

There have been physicists who have made arguments for considering frame-dependent things like these to have at least some kind of "physical reality": John Bell's article on "How to Teach Special Relativity" comes to mind as an example. But such viewpoints seem to be a small minority.
I completely agree with you

For now, I am specifically looking at LET to see whether it is possible to identify any mathematical differences from special relativity (SR).
 
AlexOsipovich said:
For now, I am specifically looking at LET to see whether it is possible to identify any mathematical differences from special relativity (SR).
As the term "LET" is usually defined, there aren't, by definition. LET is just a different interpretation of the same math as SR. It makes all of the same empirical predictions; it just interprets them differently.

I'm not sure if any of the references that discuss the Tangherlini transformation claim that it is part of LET. But even if it is, as @Dale has already pointed out, it appears to be just one possible way of having a non-standard simultaneity convention in every inertial frame except one. Which is mathematically equivalent to standard SR--again, the non-standard simultaneity convention could be given a different physical interpretation, that it reflects the "true" simultaneity in the frame which is the "true" rest frame. But we can never know experimentally which frame that is, and the predictions for everything we can actually observe and measure are the same.
 
PeterDonis said:
But this implies that the tension is somehow different in the "moving" frame than in the "rest" frame (where the center of mass of the system is at rest). But tension in the string is a direct observable: it can only have one value. So this "explanation" doesn't seem right.
The tension is a single invariant observable—because the strain gauge (dynamometer) itself is made of the same matter and undergoes the exact same electromagnetic contraction (Heaviside ellipsoid field deformation) as the string.
As a result, the co-moving gauge measures the exact same invariant value, and once clocks are Einstein-synchronized, all empirical measurements in LET are completely identical to SR.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
Physically (cause and effect), that elliptical shape comes entirely from the Lorentz-contracted equilibrium length of the string/lattice encoded inside
Well, causes come before effects. Length contraction happens at the same time as the position. So they do not have a cause and effect relationship.


AlexOsipovich said:
the relativistic inertia terms alone do not produce the Lorentz-contracted ellipse. please confirm, right?
I don’t know what “alone” could mean here. Differential equations always include initial conditions. You seem to be looking at the initial conditions as though you could vary those arbitrarily.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
The tension is a single invariant observable—because the strain gauge (dynamometer) itself is made of the same matter and undergoes the exact same electromagnetic contraction (Heaviside ellipsoid field deformation) as the string.
Which means this "contraction" is by definition unobservable. Most physicists would say that means it's not a real physical effect. Again, consider that you, right now, are "contracted" by a very large factor relative to cosmic rays hitting Earth. Does that affect you at all?
 
PeterDonis said:
As the term "LET" is usually defined, there aren't, by definition. LET is just a different interpretation of the same math as SR. It makes all of the same empirical predictions; it just interprets them differently.

I'm not sure if any of the references that discuss the Tangherlini transformation claim that it is part of LET. But even if it is, as @Dale has already pointed out, it appears to be just one possible way of having a non-standard simultaneity convention in every inertial frame except one. Which is mathematically equivalent to standard SR--again, the non-standard simultaneity convention could be given a different physical interpretation, that it reflects the "true" simultaneity in the frame which is the "true" rest frame. But we can never know experimentally which frame that is, and the predictions for everything we can actually observe and measure are the same.
I agree with you. As far as I know historically it started as Lorentz's theory of electrons (1892–1904), LET is indeed empirically indistinguishable from SR—differing only in physical interpretation (a preferred ether frame vs. spacetime geometry).
However, the two theories differ profoundly on an ontological level, which gives grounds to believe that it may still be possible to devise an experiment capable of distinguishing between SR and LET.