Thermodynamics: Reduction Potential question

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
TytoAlba95
Messages
132
Reaction score
19
Homework Statement
NA
Relevant Equations
NA
Photo of a printed CSIR NET June 2017 exam question 28 on electron acceptors X, Y and Z with redox potentials +0.15V, +0.05 and -0.1V, the reaction B + 2H + 2e- to BH2 with E0' = +0.05V, and answer options a to d.

The answer key says the correct option should be a, but I think it should be b. Because Y has a reduction potential same as the element B.

An element is a good reducing agent only if its reduction potential is negative or less positive.
 
Then why have you chosen the most positive one?

The question seems unclear. What are you being asked to do - reduce B or oxidise BH2? I read it as reducing B, but then you want an electron donor, not an acceptor. Have I misunderstood?
 
I think it is asking which out of the three can oxidize BH2. In that case, I think (b) is the correct option.
Thanks for pointing out, I got confused after reading the question. I really is unclear.

But if they are asking for the oxidant, shouldn't Y element be excluded?