Two rocks launched up/collison (Kinematics)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Moe777
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Kinematics Rocks
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves two rocks launched vertically, with the first rock launched at an initial speed V0 and the second rock launched T seconds later. The goal is to determine the necessary initial velocity for the second rock so that it collides with the first rock when the first rock has a velocity of -V0/2. This falls under the subject area of kinematics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the timing of the launches and the implications of the time interval T. There is confusion regarding the definitions of t1 and t2, with some participants suggesting that clearer labels would aid understanding. Others explore the relationship between the times the rocks are in flight and the conditions for their collision.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants clarifying their understanding of the timing involved in the problem. Some have drawn diagrams to visualize the scenario, while others are questioning the definitions of the variables used. There is no explicit consensus yet, but the conversation is moving towards a clearer interpretation of the problem.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of distinguishing between the times at which the rocks are thrown and the times they are in the air. There is also mention of the need for additional variables to accurately represent the situation.

Moe777
Messages
8
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


This is a quiz question that was given in my AP physics C class. "A rock is launched upward with a speed V0. With what velocity must a second rock be launched from the same initial position at time T later so that it hits the first rock when it has a velocity of -V0/2."

Homework Equations


The only formulas we needed for this question were the basic velocity, displacement, and acceleration formulas (as functions of time) and their variations. (1D kinematics).

The Attempt at a Solution


1) I drew a diagram on an axis with a vertical line (y axis) and the origin being zero (the initial position of the balls).

2) I listed all of the knowns and unknowns given from the question. We know that:
  • Rock1 (first rock) has an initial velocity of V0.
  • Time= T
  • Acceleration= -g= -9.81 m/s2
  • When the second rock hits the first rock, the velocity of the first rock will be -V0/2.
We don't know the velocity that is necessary for rock2 (second rock), which allows the given condition ( When the second rock hits the first rock, the velocity of the first rock will be -V0/2.) to happen. Basically, we don't know the initial velocity of rock2.

I then assumed the conditions for the collision:
When the rocks collide, they will be the same distance from the ground, so d1=d2
and I also assumed the time of travel for both rocks at the collision, which I put as T=T, which is where I'm sure that I made a mistake.

Since this is from a collected quiz, I don't remember exactly what I did. However, I remember doing something similar to this:

(-V0rock1 /2)T- (1/2)gT2=( V0rock2)T- (1/2)gT2
I forgot the process, but my solution was something like V0/2T, which is incorrect because the units come out to be m/s2. I feel that I did something completely off track, and I really need help as to how I should approach these problems and how to think more effectively. I felt as though this question should have been easier for me, which kind of discouraged me after that quiz was collected. This isn't the first time we get a question like this, and help for the question and questions like these would be much appreciated. Thank you in advance.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
You seem to be confused about T. The given T is the interval between launch times. If the first rock is in flight for time t1 before the collision, how long is the second rock in flight until then?
 
Moe777 said:
Time= T
That is not a good idea if more than one time is involved. Labels like t1 and so on make it easier to see what happens when.
 
Oh. I see what's going on. So I drew a graph just to help me visualize, where I assumed arbitrary times, where the first rock is thrown at 1s and the second is thrown at 4s. The time interval between them is 3s. This helped me confirm the equation that T=t2- t1, which means that t2=t1+T
 
Moe777 said:
Oh. I see what's going on. So I drew a graph just to help me visualize, where I assumed arbitrary times, where the first rock is thrown at 1s and the second is thrown at 4s. The time interval between them is 3s. This helped me confirm the equation that T=t2- t1, which means that t2=t1+T
Maybe. It depends how you are defining t1 and t2. Are these times at which the rocks are thrown, or the times they spend in the air?
 
I defined them as the times that the rocks were thrown.
 
Ok. I still assumed that d1=d2.

V01t1+(1/2)gt12= V02(T+t1)+(1/2)g(T+t1)2
 
Now you gave the second object more time of flight than the first one.

Also, your use of t1 doesn't match the definition above, as it seems to be the total flight time of the first object here.
 
Moe777 said:
I defined them as the times that the rocks were thrown.
I'm still unclear what you mean. The times at which they were thrown or for which they were aloft?
If they are the times at which the rocks are thrown, you might as well choose t1=0, making t2=T. But then you need another variable to represent the time of the collision.
If they are the times the rocks spend in the air, which one should be the greater?
 
  • #10
Ok I think it's becoming clearer. I was going off of your first reply that T is the time interval between the launching of the rocks, and may have gotten confused from that. I now understand that T is the time in which they collide. Clearly, Rock1 is in the air longer because it was thrown first. Therefore, t1 is greater than t2. Therefore, the equation, T-t1=t2 must be true.
 
  • #11
Moe777 said:
Ok I think it's becoming clearer. I was going off of your first reply that T is the time interval between the launching of the rocks, and may have gotten confused from that. I now understand that T is the time in which they collide.
No, T is the time interval between launches. Reread the question.
What relationship does that give you between the times they spend in the air, t1 and t2?
 

Similar threads

Questioning the Solution for Elevator vs Rock Problem
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Why Does a Free-Falling Object Not Have Zero Final Velocity Upon Impact?
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
Compare the ratio of two times t1/t2 in this vertical jump
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Irodov 1.23 confusion: Calculate distance traveled and time elapsed for this decelerating particle
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Projectile Motion Kinematics: A catapult launches a rock....
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
Initial Position Discrepancy Involving Fluid Resistance
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Rotational kinematics of a spherical rock upon collision
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
1-dimensional kinematics - final velocity of 2 trains in opposing direction
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Velocity Formulas for Projectile Motion
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
How Long Until the Arrow Hits the Rock in Helm's Deep?
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K