MHB Unsolvable Simultaneous Equations: A Mathematician's Dilemma

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a challenging system of simultaneous equations involving variables x, y, and z, specifically focusing on the equations z^2 + 2xyz = 1, 3x^2y^2 + 3xy^2 = 1 + x^3y^4, and z + zy^4 + 4y^3 = 4y + 6y^2z. Participants explore methods to eliminate variables and transform the equations, with one user suggesting a trigonometric approach using the tangent function. This leads to a reformulation of the equations that reveals a relationship between the angles, ultimately resulting in a single equation involving sine and cosine functions. The discussion highlights the complexity of solving the equations while providing insights into potential solutions and the use of trigonometric identities.
anemone
Gold Member
MHB
POTW Director
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
115
Hi MHB,

For the first time I found a system of equations where I'm at my wit's end and don't know how to solve it, no matter how hard I tried...

Problem:

Solve

$$z^2+2xyz=1$$

$$3x^2y^2+3xy^2=1+x^3y^4$$

$$z+zy^4+4y^3=4y+6y^2z$$

Attempt:

I tried to eliminate the variable $z$ and obtained another equation in terms of $x$ and $y$ but I think you'll agree with me that I'm headed in the wrong direction after you saw the equation I found...

$$\left(\frac{4y(1-y^2)}{y^4-6y^2+1} \right)^2+2xy\left(\frac{4y(1-y^2)}{y^4-6y^2+1} \right)=1$$I'd appreciate any hints anyone could give me on this problem.

Thanks in advance.:)
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
anemone said:
Hi MHB,

For the first time I found a system of equations where I'm at my wit's end and don't know how to solve it, no matter how hard I tried...

Problem:

Solve

$$z^2+2xyz=1$$

$$3x^2y^2+3xy^2=1+x^3y^4$$

$$z+zy^4+4y^3=4y+6y^2z$$

Attempt:

I tried to eliminate the variable $z$ and obtained another equation in terms of $x$ and $y$ but I think you'll agree with me that I'm headed in the wrong direction after you saw the equation I found...

$$\left(\frac{4y(1-y^2)}{y^4-6y^2+1} \right)^2+2xy\left(\frac{4y(1-y^2)}{y^4-6y^2+1} \right)=1$$I'd appreciate any hints anyone could give me on this problem.

Thanks in advance.:)

Alternatively You can eliminate z using the first equation obtaining...

$\displaystyle z = - x y \pm \sqrt{1+ x^{2} y^{2}}\ (1)$

... insert it in the third equation and then try to solve in x and y...Kind regards $\chi$ $\sigma$
 
chisigma said:
Alternatively You can eliminate z using the first equation obtaining...

$\displaystyle z = - x y \pm \sqrt{1+ x^{2} y^{2}}\ (1)$

... insert it in the third equation and then try to solve in x and y...Kind regards $\chi$ $\sigma$

Thank you for your reply, chisigma...

I should have mentioned earlier that I used the exact same method to arrive to the equation that I showed in my first post...:o.

I'm sorry for not mentioning more clearly how did I end up with that new equation in terms of $x$ and $y$. Sorry!
 
anemone said:
Solve

$$z^2+2xyz=1$$

$$3x^2y^2+3xy^2=1+x^3y^4$$

$$z+zy^4+4y^3=4y+6y^2z$$
I wonder where these equations came from? To me, they smell of trigonometry, specifically the formulae $$\tan(3\theta) = \frac{3\tan\theta - \tan^3\theta}{1-3\tan^2\theta}$$ and $$\tan(4\theta) = \frac{4\tan\theta(1-\tan^2\theta)}{1 - 6\tan^2\theta + \tan^4\theta}.$$

Let $u = xy$. Then the equations become

$$z^2+2uz=1$$,

$$3u^2+3uy=1+u^3y$$,

$$z+zy^4+4y^3=4y+6y^2z$$.

Now let $u = \tan\theta$. The second equation then says $$y = \frac{1-3u^2}{3u-u^3} = \cot(3\theta) = \tan\bigl(\tfrac\pi2 - 3\theta\bigr)$$. The third equation says that $$z = \frac{4y(1-y^2)}{1-6y^2 + y^4} = \tan(4\arctan y) = \tan(2\pi - 12\theta).$$

The first equation is a quadratic in $z$, with solutions $z = -u \pm\sqrt{1+u^2} = -\tan\theta \pm\sec\theta.$ Comparing the two expressions for $z$, you get $$\boxed{\tan(2\pi - 12\theta) = -\tan\theta \pm\sec\theta}.$$ That at least is an equation in just one unknown, though not one that I would want to have to solve. (A graph shows 23 solutions in the interval $[-\pi,\pi]$.) Once you know $\theta$, you can of course calculate $u,\,y,\,z$ and $x$.
 
Opalg said:
I wonder where these equations came from? To me, they smell of trigonometry, specifically the formulae $$\tan(3\theta) = \frac{3\tan\theta - \tan^3\theta}{1-3\tan^2\theta}$$ and $$\tan(4\theta) = \frac{4\tan\theta(1-\tan^2\theta)}{1 - 6\tan^2\theta + \tan^4\theta}.$$

Let $u = xy$. Then the equations become

$$z^2+2uz=1$$,

$$3u^2+3uy=1+u^3y$$,

$$z+zy^4+4y^3=4y+6y^2z$$.

Now let $u = \tan\theta$. The second equation then says $$y = \frac{1-3u^2}{3u-u^3} = \cot(3\theta) = \tan\bigl(\tfrac\pi2 - 3\theta\bigr)$$. The third equation says that $$z = \frac{4y(1-y^2)}{1-6y^2 + y^4} = \tan(4\arctan y) = \tan(2\pi - 12\theta).$$

The first equation is a quadratic in $z$, with solutions $z = -u \pm\sqrt{1+u^2} = -\tan\theta \pm\sec\theta.$ Comparing the two expressions for $z$, you get $$\boxed{\tan(2\pi - 12\theta) = -\tan\theta \pm\sec\theta}.$$ That at least is an equation in just one unknown, though not one that I would want to have to solve. (A graph shows 23 solutions in the interval $[-\pi,\pi]$.) Once you know $\theta$, you can of course calculate $u,\,y,\,z$ and $x$.

Thank you Opalg for the great reply!

I vaguely remember from where I gotten this problem but I knew it came from AoPS Forum and I did a search on my browsing history and I found it at last! I couldn't believe I didn't see the hint(trigonometric might be of help) given by the OP when I first saw the topic...shame on me!AoPS Forum - Use trigonomatric [2] ? Art of Problem Solving

And thank you for everything, your explanations, the trigonometric formulas for both $$\tan 3 \theta$$ and $$\tan 4 \theta$$, and everything that you said in your post...I truly appreciate it!

I have to admit it took me some time to digest your post and worked it out on my own...I see that if I let

$$xy=\tan k$$, $$y=\tan 3k$$, $$z=\tan 12k$$, $$x=\frac{1-3\tan^2 k}{3-\tan^2 k}$$

I then managed to narrow them down to

$$\sin 13k=\cos 12k$$

and this equation is actually equivalent to yours(the last equation in your post) and I don't think I could solve it too. BUT, wolfram alpha does suggest some neat answers (for the first few angles for $k$).(solve sin13x=cos12x - Wolfram|Alpha)
 
Opalg said:
$$\boxed{\tan(2\pi - 12\theta) = -\tan\theta \pm\sec\theta}.$$ That at least is an equation in just one unknown, though not one that I would want to have to solve. (A graph shows 23 solutions in the interval $[-\pi,\pi]$.)
anemone said:
I see that if I let

$$xy=\tan k$$, $$y=\tan 3k$$, $$z=\tan 12k$$, $$x=\frac{1-3\tan^2 k}{3-\tan^2 k}$$

I then managed to narrow them down to

$$\sin 13k=\cos 12k$$ I seem to get 11k rather than 13k there?
When I derived that boxed equation, I thought it was too hard to solve. But your reply gives me courage to continue (on the assumption that the boxed equation is correct).

Since $$\tan(2\pi - 12\theta) = -\tan(12\theta)$$, we can write the equation as $$\tan(12\theta) = \tan\theta \pm\sec\theta$$, so that $$\frac{\sin(12\theta)}{\cos(12\theta)} - \frac{\sin\theta\pm1}{\cos\theta} = 0,$$$$\sin(12\theta)\cos\theta - \cos(12\theta)\sin\theta \pm\cos(12\theta) = 0,$$ $$\sin(11\theta) = \pm\cos(12\theta),$$ $$\cos(12\theta) = \pm\cos(\tfrac\pi2 - 11\theta),$$ $$12\theta = \pm11\theta \pm\tfrac\pi2 + 2k\pi.$$

If we take the plus sign, for $+11\theta$, then we get $\theta = \pm\frac\pi2+2k\pi$, and then $u = \tan\theta$ is not defined. So we need to take the minus sign, getting $23\theta = \pm\frac\pi2 + 2k\pi$, which is equivalent to $\theta = \dfrac{(2k+1)\pi}{46}\ (0\leqslant k\leqslant 22)$. That gives 23 values for $\tan\theta$, from which you can deduce the 23 solutions to the original equations for $x,\,y,\,z.$
 
By substituting $$xy=\tan k$$, $$z=\tan 12k$$, $$x=\frac{1-3\tan^2 k}{3-\tan^2 k}$$ and $$y=\tan 3k$$ into the equation $z^2+2xyz=1$, we see that

$$z=\frac{-2xy\pm \sqrt{(2xy)^2-4(-1)}}{2}$$

$$z=\frac{-2xy\pm \sqrt{4x^2y^2+4}}{2}$$

$$z=\frac{-2xy\pm 2\sqrt{x^2y^2+1}}{2}$$

$$z=-xy\pm \sqrt{x^2y^2+1}$$

$$\tan 12k=-\tan k\pm \sqrt{\tan ^2k+1}$$

$$\tan 12k=-\tan k\pm \sqrt{\sec ^2k}$$

$$\frac{\sin 12k}{\cos 12k}=-\frac{\sin k}{\cos k}\pm \sec k$$

$$\frac{\sin 12k}{\cos 12k}=-\frac{\sin k}{\cos k}\pm \frac{1}{\cos k}$$

$$\frac{\sin 12k}{\cos 12k}=-\frac{\sin k\mp 1}{\cos k}$$

$$\sin 12k \cos k=-\sin k\cos 12k \mp \cos 12k$$

$$\sin 12k \cos k+\sin k\cos 12k= \mp \cos 12k$$

$$\sin 12k \cos k+\cos 12k \sin k= \mp \cos 12k$$

$$\sin (12k+k)=\mp \cos 12k$$

and hence

$$\sin (13k)=\mp \cos 12k$$...:o. I am not saying I am right though...
Opalg said:
$$ $$\sin(11\theta) = \pm\cos(12\theta),$$ $$\cos(12\theta) = \pm\cos(\tfrac\pi2 - 11\theta),$$ $$12\theta = \pm11\theta \pm\tfrac\pi2 + 2k\pi.$$

I'm stamping my foot now seeing how you magically turned the sine function into the cosine function and am disappointed in myself because really I should have thought of that.
 
anemone said:
By substituting $$xy=\tan k$$, $$z=\tan 12k$$, $$x=\frac{1-3\tan^2 k}{3-\tan^2 k}$$ and $$y=\tan 3k$$ ...
I don't have time to double-check it right now, but I think it was $y=\cot3k$, not $\tan3k$.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top