Unsure of career-2nd Bachelor's degree

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the participant's uncertainty regarding their career path after obtaining a B.A. in Biology and pursuing a PhD in Plant Pathology. They express a desire to transition into engineering or mathematics while emphasizing the importance of living in a preferred location, specifically the Twin Cities. The conversation touches on personal preferences, career options, and the implications of choosing a career based on geographical desires.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster (OP) expresses regret about not attending the University of Minnesota and is uncertain about their career direction, considering engineering or mathematics.
  • Some participants question the OP's decision to leave Plant Pathology, suggesting it has valuable career prospects.
  • The OP indicates that job opportunities in Plant Pathology are not aligned with their preferred living locations.
  • Another participant suggests that personal interests should guide career choices rather than geographical preferences.
  • Concerns are raised about the feasibility of finding a job in the desired location with a second degree, as there are no guarantees.
  • The OP emphasizes the importance of living near family and in a large city, citing personal well-being and social connections as significant factors.
  • Some participants propose alternative career paths, such as landscape gardening, which could combine the OP's interests in engineering and plant science.
  • Several participants discuss the implications of living in a city with differing political views and the potential for social isolation.
  • The OP shares that being gay limits their dating opportunities in certain locations, further influencing their desire to live in a larger city where they feel respected.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and disagreement regarding the importance of location versus career satisfaction. While some prioritize personal interests and career opportunities, others emphasize the significance of social connections and living environment. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing views on how to approach the OP's career transition.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various resources for researching job markets and industries in the desired location, but there is no consensus on the best career path or the effectiveness of pursuing a second degree.

MatthewHaas
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
Hi all,

So I graduated from a small liberal arts school in Minnesota with my B.A. in Biology last year (2009). I'm not really sure why, but I decided on Plant Pathology for graduate school, which landed me in a PhD program at NDSU in Fargo, ND.

Now, what I really wanted to do was live in the Twin Cities (Minneapolis/St Paul, MN) So I am back at home with my parents, going to school part time. (I am taking Calculus and Physics-for Science and Engineering-different than the versions of those classes I took during my first undergrad career) and working part-time. *Originally, I was planning on working full-time, but haven't been able to find a job.

Here's what I know: I want to get my next degree from the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities. Nowhere else. I regret not going there in the first place, and I want to remain in the Twin Cities for the rest of my life. (Although I would consider: San Diego, LA, San Fran, Chicago, New York, or Boston...all big cities).

I'm looking at Engineering as a career path, but don't necessarily know what kind of engineering I want to do, or what my options are, let alone what my daily life would be like.

I'm almost certain I wouldn't make a good physics major, but I haven't given up on the idea of Mathematics either which I think might open doors for me, too.

Does anyone have any suggestions?

THANK YOU!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
why do you not want to do plant pathology anymore? its a good subject to study, I think? lots of plant diseases in the world to be treated - the crop ones will make loads of money, and benefit millions of starving people.
 
I left Plant Pathology because most, if not all, of the jobs I would be eligible for are in places I don't want to live.
 
oh, why are you so concerned with where you want to live? There are loads of great places to live! I usually choose what I want to do by what I am interested in, not by where I want to live... that's just me tho.
 
If your primary concern is staying where you are, a second degree might not be a solution as there is no guarantee you can land a job where u want to be.
 
I want to live in near family, and in a large city. Just my personal preference.

Another degree in a more technical field will help land me a job in this area.

EDIT: I thought I would add more to better explain myself:

-Is it worth being alone every night, and every weekend for a career you're not even sure you like? Is it worth eating dinner in solitude? Is it worth going to the store just so you have someone to speak to? Or is it better to live somewhere that you have friends and family to share meals with, spend time with, and live your life-rather than waiting for your life to start?

-There are plenty of nice communities out there, but what if ammenities you enjoy are just not present? (Lakes, beaches, art museums, extensive bike trails, good public transportation, etc) Are you just supposed to suck it up and live for work?

-What if you don't "jive" politically with the locals? What if your neighbor hates you because you're more enlightened than they are? What if your city constantly makes headlines for anti-semitic graffiti being found every other week?
 
Last edited:
MatthewHaas said:
I want to live in near family, and in a large city. Just my personal preference.

Another degree in a more technical field will help land me a job in this area.

I'm in a pretty similar situation, I know where I want to live but don't know exactly what career I want. Although, I'm slowly figuring it out. What I've been doing is researching the types of industries that are big in the area(s) I want to live. City websites and the BLS OOH have a lot of statistics about this kind of information. Just doing a quick search I've found these sites:

http://www.city-data.com/us-cities/The-Midwest/Minneapolis-Economy.html

http://www.positivelyminnesota.com/Data_Publications/Data/Industries/index.aspx

http://data.bls.gov:8080/oes/search.jsp?data_tool=OES - this is a fun tool where you can search the occupation for the city or state you want.

Good luck.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why not join, or set up, a landscape gardening firm? That should combine engineering, plant science, big cities, and big money from rich people wanting big gardens...
 
MatthewHaas said:
-Is it worth being alone every night, and every weekend for a career you're not even sure you like? Is it worth eating dinner in solitude? Is it worth going to the store just so you have someone to speak to? Or is it better to live somewhere that you have friends and family to share meals with, spend time with, and live your life-rather than waiting for your life to start?

-There are plenty of nice communities out there, but what if ammenities you enjoy are just not present? (Lakes, beaches, art museums, extensive bike trails, good public transportation, etc) Are you just supposed to suck it up and live for work?

-What if you don't "jive" politically with the locals? What if your neighbor hates you because you're more enlightened than they are? What if your city constantly makes headlines for anti-semitic graffiti being found every other week?

To the first question: Who says you have to be alone? Start a family, get a nice group of friends, live it up! You can do this anywhere.

To the second question: I admit you have a point.

To the third question: I am used to living in a place where my political views differ from those around me. It's not as bad as you would think. First off, it's not like left and right wingers can't be good friends. Some of my best friends have radically opposing viewpoints. As for the neighbors thing, there is a saying that 90%+ of the population is stupid. Mainly, wherever you go there will be the possibility of annoying neighbors. And with the graffiti thing, I am not quite sure how you want to live in a big city yet can't accept there being graffiti that is sometimes racist, sexist, or anti-semitic. It's just kinda a fact of life that you have to accept when living in a big city. (I was raised Jewish myself, so I know about the whole anti-semite thing. When I hear about it I just think that whoever said it must be an ignorant schmuck)
 
  • #10
DR13 said:
To the first question: Who says you have to be alone? Start a family, get a nice group of friends, live it up! You can do this anywhere.

To the second question: I admit you have a point.

To the third question: I am used to living in a place where my political views differ from those around me. It's not as bad as you would think. First off, it's not like left and right wingers can't be good friends. Some of my best friends have radically opposing viewpoints. As for the neighbors thing, there is a saying that 90%+ of the population is stupid. Mainly, wherever you go there will be the possibility of annoying neighbors. And with the graffiti thing, I am not quite sure how you want to live in a big city yet can't accept there being graffiti that is sometimes racist, sexist, or anti-semitic. It's just kinda a fact of life that you have to accept when living in a big city. (I was raised Jewish myself, so I know about the whole anti-semite thing. When I hear about it I just think that whoever said it must be an ignorant schmuck)

I can't start a family just "anywhere". I'm gay, so there aren't opportunities to meet people to date in a lot of places. That brings me to the 3rd point-I cannot be friends with people who don't support equal rights. I could care less about any other political issue, but at least in large cities I get respect.
 
  • #11
MatthewHaas said:
I can't start a family just "anywhere". I'm gay, so there aren't opportunities to meet people to date in a lot of places. That brings me to the 3rd point-I cannot be friends with people who don't support equal rights. I could care less about any other political issue, but at least in large cities I get respect.

Oh, gotcha. Whatever you decide to do, best of luck to ya. [proceeds to put foot in mouth]
 
  • #12
hm... places where people are more educated are usually more open-minded. so I'd suggest cities with good univeristies? unis usually attract a variety of people of different backgrounds, so that's good too.
 
  • #13
yeah... it might mean you'll have to consider a few more things before deciding on a place, but I think you can totally do what you want to do AND find a good place to live! I dunno, you sound kind of like you are changing careers cos you think it would allow you to live in the biger cities? I think big cities have plant sciences departments too! if you are actually interested in plants,then you should stick to it! it doesn't mean working in a farm all your life! more like working in a lab and traveling to Asia/Africa... I think... not sure tho, so check yourself too.

And I don't know about your own experiences, but from my experiences, people are quite open minded about these things! People are generally quite inclusive, and will treat you no different to anyone else.
 
  • #14
DR13 said:
Oh, gotcha. Whatever you decide to do, best of luck to ya. [proceeds to put foot in mouth]

Thanks.
 
  • #15
nucleargirl said:
yeah... it might mean you'll have to consider a few more things before deciding on a place, but I think you can totally do what you want to do AND find a good place to live! I dunno, you sound kind of like you are changing careers cos you think it would allow you to live in the biger cities? I think big cities have plant sciences departments too! if you are actually interested in plants,then you should stick to it! it doesn't mean working in a farm all your life! more like working in a lab and traveling to Asia/Africa... I think... not sure tho, so check yourself too.

And I don't know about your own experiences, but from my experiences, people are quite open minded about these things! People are generally quite inclusive, and will treat you no different to anyone else.

I don't know if I want to work with plants...I just kind of randomly picked that area of focus and ran with it. It didn't "pick me" which would be a completely different scenario.

As for travel, I'm much more interested in going to Europe and S America more so than Africa..Not that that has much to do with anything, mind you, since travel is probably infrequent enough to make it not matter.

Another advantage of big cities is that if you decide to change jobs, there are other employers in your city, so you don't need to uproot yourself-which is nice when you're paying off a house.

I'm stuck. The reason for grad school was to be a professor. But my advisor told me that since he wasn't actually a professor (he was just a research scientist) no one would hire me as a professor.. And I don't want to do academic research. I knew that from the start. My plan was to be a professor at a small teaching university, not at a state school.

I'm considering engineering because I think I would enjoy the collaborative aspect of it.
 
  • #16
Definitely get into engineering. you will have at least 2 years from when you start engineering school to decide what specific kind. I recommend Mechanical, of course ;)
Come live in boston. It's the best place on earth!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K
  • · Replies 80 ·
3
Replies
80
Views
5K
  • · Replies 47 ·
2
Replies
47
Views
7K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 92 ·
4
Replies
92
Views
22K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K