Verification of a problem -> force needed for car stopping in 1.8cm

  • Thread starter Thread starter simphys
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Car Force
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on verifying the calculations for the force needed to stop a car in 1.8 cm, highlighting a mistake in using the initial velocity of 37 m/s instead of the correct 37 km/h. Participants emphasize the importance of accurately reading the problem statement and note discrepancies in the car's weight and speed. Practical limitations of braking are discussed, including friction, excessive g-forces on passengers, and heat generated in brake components. The conversation also touches on the theoretical concept of a car stopping "on a dime," with humorous remarks about the feasibility of such a stop. Overall, the thread combines technical verification with practical considerations in automotive physics.
simphys
Messages
327
Reaction score
46
Homework Statement
picture
Relevant Equations
newton's 2nd law of motion F_net = ma
Kinematic equation: v_fx^2 = v_0x^2 + 2*a_x*(deltaX)
1644778250216.png

hello guys can someone verify my solution (in the picture) whether the solution is correct or I guess the steps followed would be enough. There is no solution in the book for this one but wanted to be sure.

Thanks in advance
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    53.2 KB · Views: 119
Physics news on Phys.org
You used 37 m/s for the initial velocity of the car when it is given as 37 km/h. The method is correct.
 
  • Like
Likes simphys
Why does your homework statement talk of a 850 kg car traveling at 45 km/h when the question you copy says a 840 kg car traveling at 37 km/h?
Note v0 = 37 km/h, NOT 37 m/s!
First rule of any test is READ THE QUESTION ACCURATELY.

Edit; kuruman got there first!
 
  • Like
Likes simphys
kuruman said:
You used 37 m/s for the initial velocity of the car when it is given as 37 km/h. The method is correct.
mjc123 said:
Why does your homework statement talk of a 850 kg car traveling at 45 km/h when the question you copy says a 840 kg car traveling at 37 km/h?
Note v0 = 37 km/h, NOT 37 m/s!
First rule of any test is READ THE QUESTION ACCURATELY.

Edit; kuruman got there first!
Thanks guys, appreciate it! And well no.. I mistakenly copied the wrong question. I typed it in google but found a question on cheg from the same book (other edition) with just the numbers changed hence why, my apologies
 
Then, you have three practical limitations to that strong braking effect:
1) Friction between tires and asphalt.
2) Excessive negative acceleration (g-force) for passengers.
3) Excessive heat in brake pads-discs.
 
  • Informative
Likes simphys
Lnewqban: That's why you need to supply your own brick wall (or borrow a neighbor's). The car *can* stop on a dime, though.
 
I don't see why advertise a car that can stop on a dime. Its air bags would have to be deployed every time it did so. If it doesn't have air bags for that reason, its driver can stop on a dime exactly once in a lifetime.
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban
Lnewqban said:
Then, you have three practical limitations to that strong braking effect:
1) Friction between tires and asphalt.
2) Excessive negative acceleration (g-force) for passengers.
3) Excessive heat in brake pads-discs.
Thanks for the indication that.
Mike S. said:
Lnewqban: That's why you need to supply your own brick wall (or borrow a neighbor's). The car *can* stop on a dime, though.
I presume that that was sarcastic😄
 
simphys said:
Thanks for the indication that.
Velocity used in the calculation should be 10.28 m/s.

After you calculate the force necessary to stop in 1.8 cm, just for curiosity, you could see how much force the maximum available static friction (rubber-asphalt μ is around 0.8) would actually allow, as well as how big of g-force the passengers would experience.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes simphys
  • #10
kuruman said:
its driver can stop on a dime exactly once in a lifetime.
While this may be true for the spirit of the idiom, if taken literally the driver can do it many many times. Stopping on a dime would technically just require you to be on top of it as you come to a rest. 😏
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes kuruman, simphys and SammyS
  • #11
Lnewqban said:
Velocity used in the calculation should be 10.28 m/s.

After you calculate the force necessary to stop in 1.8 cm, just for curiosity, you could see how much force the maximum available static friction (rubber-asphalt μ is around 0.8) would actually allow, as well as how big of g-force the passengers would experience.
wow that's insane very curious how this these coefficients for the frictions are calculated (I guess looking at the molecular interaction between both surfaces explains that.. and lots of experimentation ofc)
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban
Back
Top