We haven't changed all that much - epidemic social response

  • Thread starter Thread starter 256bits
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Response
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights historical instances of public resistance to vaccination during epidemics, drawing parallels to contemporary attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccines. In late 1894, Milwaukee faced a significant smallpox outbreak, leading to public dissent against health department policies, reflecting underlying animosities toward emerging public health science. Similarly, the Montreal vaccine riot showcased fears surrounding smallpox vaccinations, fueled by misinformation and religious beliefs, with some viewing vaccination as a harmful imposition. The aftermath of these events saw a shift in anti-vaccination efforts from public protests to legal challenges, exemplified by Ontario's Vaccination Act of 1887, which mandated vaccinations and allowed for enforcement during outbreaks. The discussion emphasizes the enduring nature of anti-vaccination sentiments and the critical role of science and public health initiatives in disease prevention.
256bits
Gold Member
Messages
4,039
Reaction score
2,092
TL;DR Summary
A couple of reports of 1895 smallpox outbreaks in two cities - Montreal , Milwaukee - and the reaction of citizens.
Someone should find these interesting reads, with the backdrop of the last year or so of the epidemic.

https://www.marquette.edu/cgi-bin/cuap/db.cgi?uid=default&ID=5982&view=Search&mh=1

... however Milwaukee had in late 1894 and early 1895 one last epidemic, in some ways the most notable, for it brought to the surface latent animosities and resentments against the relatively new science of public health. It was a revolt, some thought, against newly emerging scientific knowledge. In 1894 south side residents openly resisted Milwaukee Health Department policies.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2021/08/10/montreal-vaccine-riot-smallpox/
Though inoculation against smallpox wasn’t new, some feared the vaccinations were dangerous. Some didn’t understand how contagious the disease was. Some believed rumors that city vaccinators were going into bedrooms and tying down children to be vaccinated.
One anti-vaccination pamphlet read “Stop! People Driven Like Dumb Animals To The Shambles.” Some religious groups called the smallpox shot the biblical “mark of the beast” — the same claim being made by conspiracy theorists about the Coronavirus vaccines on the social networks of some Christian groups.


And sadly,
Two weeks later, Dr. Alexander Ross, one of the anti-vaccination city council members who had incited the protesters, was stopped aboard the Chicago Express train from Montreal by a Canadian health inspector, the St. Louis Post Dispatch reported. A search revealed “the great advocate of the ignorant antivaccination party had been vaccinated recently.”

https://www.cmaj.ca/content/193/14/E490
The outcome of the riot was neither capitulation to the demands of antivaccine activists, nor a heavy-handed enforcement of policy. Rather, after this epidemic, the opposition to vaccination shifted to courtrooms and activist leagues. Ontario passed a Vaccination Act in 1887, which required that “parents must have their children vaccinated against smallpox within three months of birth and re-vaccinated when necessary every seven years.” It allowed cities to issue vaccination orders in the event of a smallpox outbreak, and allowed school boards to demand that students provide a vaccination certificate.9 The Anti-Vaccination League of Canada emerged in 1900, in part a reaction to the Vaccination Act, modelling its rhetoric and methods on British antivaccine groups. The British Anti-Compulsory Vaccination League had been founded in 1867, and in 1885 had its own (peaceful) march in Leicester with an estimated 100 000 attendees.10
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes Laroxe, hutchphd, Not anonymous and 4 others
Biology news on Phys.org
These are all really interesting reads - it's amazing to see how the antivaccination movement has changed over time, and yet some of the arguments remain the same. It's also interesting to see how the response to the smallpox epidemic in 1894 was handled in Milwaukee, and how that differs from our current situation with the COVID-19 pandemic. It's a great reminder of the importance of science and public health measures, and the need for vaccination to prevent the spread of diseases.
 
Deadly cattle screwworm parasite found in US patient. What to know. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2025/08/25/new-world-screwworm-human-case/85813010007/ Exclusive: U.S. confirms nation's first travel-associated human screwworm case connected to Central American outbreak https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/us-confirms-nations-first-travel-associated-human-screwworm-case-connected-2025-08-25/...
Chagas disease, long considered only a threat abroad, is established in California and the Southern U.S. According to articles in the Los Angeles Times, "Chagas disease, long considered only a threat abroad, is established in California and the Southern U.S.", and "Kissing bugs bring deadly disease to California". LA Times requires a subscription. Related article -...
I am reading Nicholas Wade's book A Troublesome Inheritance. Please let's not make this thread a critique about the merits or demerits of the book. This thread is my attempt to understanding the evidence that Natural Selection in the human genome was recent and regional. On Page 103 of A Troublesome Inheritance, Wade writes the following: "The regional nature of selection was first made evident in a genomewide scan undertaken by Jonathan Pritchard, a population geneticist at the...
Back
Top