FNG
Hi everyone,
any books to recommend?
Thanks in advance.
FNG
This discussion centers on the challenges and considerations of learning to play the violin independently. Participants emphasize the importance of having a trained ear and proper instruction, noting that the lack of frets on the violin makes self-teaching particularly difficult. Several users share their experiences with other instruments, such as guitar and trumpet, and highlight the benefits of formal lessons for developing skills and techniques. Overall, the consensus is that while self-learning is possible, it is not recommended for the violin due to its complexity.
PREREQUISITESMusicians interested in expanding their skills, particularly those considering learning the violin on their own, as well as educators and instructors looking for insights into the challenges of self-teaching string instruments.
devoured_elysium said:ah, but you have 10 yeras of music training. i don't think he has..does he?
FNG, I (and/or once couldFNG said:Hi, I am so glad to see replies here.
Thanks all.
Hm, I don't know whether I have a good ear...but i do play the flute, piccolo, clarinet and guitar...if anyone of these helps in learning violin, that would be great.
I have heard someone mentioning that it's not easy to learn violin without prpoer instruction. But I would like to give it a try, provided i can find ANY book that teaches it.
So far I have yet to come across one...
So if anyone has an answer...please do share.
Greatly appreciate it![]()
FNG
turbo-1 said:FNG, I (and/or once could) play trumpet, baritone, French horn, flute, etc, and do a hell of a job at it. I taught myself to play guitar and I can play a hell of a lot better (blues, rock, freestyle) than most people that I know, although as you learn these crafts, you find a whole lot of people better than yourself. I once tried to learn to play fiddle on my own, having bought a very nice one from a friend who was an antiques dealer. It was rewarding, in that the entire pitch palette was available (freedom from frets), but I had so much fretted-instrument stuff ingrained me from decades of guitar that I passed it on to a nice young lady who wanted a fine European-made violin (and two bows that were probably worth more than that violin!) Anyway, good luck to you. Nothing is cast in stone, and your talents may guide you to places you do not anticipate. As a child, I had a near neighbor (about 3/4 mile) named T-Joe who was close to my parents' ages, though he acted child-like. He could play fiddle, mandolin, banjo, guitar, and rip it up, especially on traditional maritimes tunes. If it had strings, he could play it, though you could barely get a word out of him in a jam. A smile was about the best you could hope for, but it was a BIG smile.
DaveC426913 said:At moment I'm broke so I've got to beg borrow or steal one.
If you can get a good deal on a used acoustic guitar that is set up well (relatively low string height, but the strings don't buzz when you strike them), get it. It's really easy to find people to play with, the instrument is portable, you can play multiple notes at one time, and best of all, once you learn how to play barre chords, you can transpose up and down the neck with no thought at all. That way if you learned a song in G and your buddy learned it in A, you can just play the same progression two frets further up and be in the same key he is in. I used to host open-mike blues jams in a local tavern, and I can't tell you how handy this instant transpostion is. You don't get this ease of transposition with a piano, unless you buy an electronic keyboard with built-in transposition (and then you're lugging an amplifier, etc so you can be heard). If you don't mind practicing and working on building calluses on the tips of your fretting fingers, you can progress faster on guitar than about any other instrument.Blahness said:Hey, music interests me as well!
I'm looking more towards Keyboard or Piano, myself. Hmm...