What are the main weed out classes in engineering?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
7 replies · 11K views
JesseJC
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
In your experience, what were the most difficult intro courses in engineering with the highest failure rates? calculus, physics?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
JesseJC said:
In your experience, what were the most difficult intro courses in engineering with the highest failure rates? calculus, physics?

At my alma matter it was thermodynamics for the ME's and integrated circuits for the EE's.
 
Physics 2 and Calc 2 freshman year have a high fail rate here

I think the classes only get harder but a lot of people freshman year change majors when they realize it's not for them.
 
JesseJC said:
In your experience, what were the most difficult intro courses in engineering with the highest failure rates? calculus, physics?

Here, the main 'weed-out' engineering class is 'Statics', which is also the first real engineering class they take. Prior to that, the primary obstacles are Calc I and II and Physics I and II.
 
"Weed out" course? <cringe> o_O <urk!>

We have all experienced the negative aspects of how things are taught versus one's learning style. Or the quality of some instructors. But there are plenty of students who attempt to take <select course from list above> who are insufficiently prepared and/or motivated to achieve. Or to work harder and overcome their deficiencies. The subject matter is tough for a reason. Not everyone has what it takes.
 
tygerdawg said:
"Weed out" course? <cringe> o_O <urk!>

We have all experienced the negative aspects of how things are taught versus one's learning style. Or the quality of some instructors. But there are plenty of students who attempt to take <select course from list above> who are insufficiently prepared and/or motivated to achieve. Or to work harder and overcome their deficiencies. The subject matter is tough for a reason. Not everyone has what it takes.

I agree with this. Funny how all of the weed out courses are early in the curriculum.

It is probably more likely that they're easier, but filled with more people who aren't willing to put in the effort.