I What Prevents Electrons from Expanding Radially in White Dwarfs?

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter MarkL
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
White dwarfs maintain stability against gravitational collapse through electron degeneracy pressure, which also influences electron behavior. Electrons do not expand radially due to electromagnetic forces; if they did, it would create a charge imbalance that would restore neutrality. There is a possibility of slight variations in local net charge within the star, but these do not significantly impact electron behavior under the immense pressure present. The discussion emphasizes that while some electron expansion may occur, it is limited by the balance of forces at play. Overall, the interactions between gravity, electromagnetism, and degeneracy pressure are crucial in understanding electron dynamics in white dwarfs.
MarkL
Messages
34
Reaction score
2
From Wikipedia : White dwarfs resist gravitational collapse primarily through electron degeneracy pressure

What prevents electrons from expanding radially through the space between the ions (carbon, say)?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Gravity?
 
No, electromagnetism I think. If electrons were to migrate outwards the inner part would acquire a positive charge and the outer part a negative charge, which would rapidly become a very strong restoring force bringing back neutrality.

It is possible that you might find that there is a slight variation in local net charge with depth as various different effects push or pull slightly differently on different particles. I don't know for certain. You won't get a pure nucleon core withan electron atmosphere, though.
 
  • Like
Likes ohwilleke and Drakkith
bring back...or expand till
 
Huh?
 
the answer above was: "restoring force bringing back neutrality"
Does this mean,
bring back (to neutrality) = zero electron expansion or prevents electron expansion
or
expand till (neutrality) = electrons expand till force equals fermi pressure = some electron expansion
 
MarkL said:
the answer above was: "restoring force bringing back neutrality"
Does this mean,
bring back (to neutrality) = zero electron expansion or prevents electron expansion
or
expand till (neutrality) = electrons expand till force equals fermi pressure = some electron expansion
As my last paragraph said:
Ibix said:
It is possible that you might find that there is a slight variation in local net charge with depth as various different effects push or pull slightly differently on different particles. I don't know for certain.
I'm not sure what question you are asking that isn't answered by that.
 
Your last paragraph would never influence an electron with enough pressure to support the mass of a star.
Your first paragraph, however, is spot on and intuitive.
And I'm good...thanks for your response.
 
Back
Top