When Physics Class Demonstration Goes Wrong

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
Sign up Log in
11 replies · 4K views
ZapperZ
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Messages
32,819
Reaction score
4,724
Physics news on Phys.org
Absolutely! Physics teachers can be very sneaky.

In a satellite attitude control class I teach at work, I use a spinning tire and let all the students hold it and then try to change the orientation of the spin axis so they can actually feel angular momentum (gyroscopic stability). When I get to a student I don't like, I tell him to just jerk the tire to the left!

Unfortunately, I eventually teach them about precession maneuvers and it sometimes dawns on the student that that initial demonstration may not have been an accident. But that's okay. Their lips are still so sore that they don't say much about it anyway.
 
Last edited:
In one of my big intro Physics classes in undergrad, the prof wanted to demonstrate conservation of energy and pendulum motion. He had a bowling ball that was suspended from the high ceiling with a thin rope -- he pulled the bowling ball to one end of the lecture stage and climbed a few steps up an A-frame ladder. He held the bowling ball to his nose and said "Now you will see that when the ball comes back it will stop a little short of my nose because of the small losses due to air resistance." he released the ball, it swung across the lecture stage, turned around and came back, and almost broke his nose. I'm guessing he just didn't hold his position very still while the bowling ball was swinging out and back to him... :woot:
 
berkeman said:
In one of my big intro Physics classes in undergrad, the prof wanted to demonstrate conservation of energy and pendulum motion. He had a bowling ball that was suspended from the high ceiling with a thin rope -- he pulled the bowling ball to one end of the lecture stage and climbed a few steps up an A-frame ladder. He held the bowling ball to his nose and said "Now you will see that when the ball comes back it will stop a little short of my nose because of the small losses due to air resistance." he released the ball, it swung across the lecture stage, turned around and came back, and almost broke his nose. I'm guessing he just didn't hold his position very still while the bowling ball was swinging out and back to him... :woot:

Professor Clint Sprott at UW-Madison had this as one of the demo in the now-famous "Wonders of Physics" show. He actually put his chin on a folding ladder so that his face doesn't move.

I had him as an instructor when I was there, and he didn't do any demo in his class, unfortunately.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
I'm pretty sure Feynman originated the bowling ball demonstration:

The lectures themselves were brimming with inspiring “showbiz demonstrations” as his friend Richard Davies describes them. Most memorably, Feynman used to set up a heavy brass ball on a pendulum, send it swinging across the room, and then wait for it to swing back towards him. Students would gasp as it rushed towards his face, but Feynman would stand stock still, knowing it would stop just in front of his nose.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/10036024/Richard-Feynman-Life-the-universe-and-everything.html

Couldn't find a source for this, but I think the sledgehammer to the balls demonstration was originated by Vlad the Impaler.
 
Greg Bernhardt said:
oh my! That was difficult to watch! Terrible aim!
I was thinking that he was going to get hit in the head. That would have really hurt and could have killed him. Amazing stupidity. :wideeyed:
 
The guy on the floor seems to be wearing safety goggles - what could go wrong!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Borg and berkeman