Which dimension does the black hole belongs?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the dimensionality of black holes, their properties, and the forces involved in their behavior. Participants explore concepts related to general relativity, gravity, and the nature of matter within and around black holes, including speculative ideas about what happens to matter that crosses the event horizon.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that black holes exist in a 3+1 dimensional spacetime, while others question the implications of this dimensionality.
  • Gravity is discussed as the primary force responsible for the attraction of matter to black holes, with some participants challenging the use of the term "absorption."
  • There are differing views on what happens to matter that crosses the event horizon, with suggestions that it may be torn apart or converted into radiation.
  • Some participants mention that black holes do not have a definable shape, but the event horizon can be described as approximately spherical or oblate due to spinning.
  • Uncertainty exists regarding the nature of the core of a black hole and what happens beyond the event horizon, with mathematical models suggesting continuous compression without resolution.
  • There are references to neutron stars as objects similar to black holes, with discussions on their properties and the state of matter within them.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express multiple competing views regarding the nature of black holes, the forces at play, and the fate of matter that enters them. The discussion remains unresolved with no consensus on several key points.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the dependence on theoretical frameworks such as general relativity and the unresolved nature of what occurs inside black holes. The discussion also reflects varying interpretations of dimensionality and the behavior of matter under extreme gravitational conditions.

praveena
Messages
69
Reaction score
1
I want to know which dimension does the black hole belongs? Can anyone say which force is responsible for the absorption? In case, if the black holes absorbs everything then were the things might gone?Is that everything becomes invisible or just blast into pieces?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
praveena said:
I want to know which dimension does the black hole belongs?
Black holes are objects in spacetime like all others. In general relativity, spacetime is described with 3+1 dimensions (three in space, one in time).
praveena said:
Can anyone say which force is responsible for the absorption?
Absorption is not the right word. Gravity is responsible for their attraction.
praveena said:
In case, if the black holes absorbs everything then were the things might gone?
Everything that crosses the event horizon cannot get back. It goes to the center of the black hole.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: praveena
A black hole is an extremely massive object and it therefore it has an immense amount of gravity.
So much gravity that beyond a certain point of closeness to it (the event horizon), the only direction anything can go is deeper into the gravity well, even light cannot escape beyond that point.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: praveena
mfb said:
Black holes are objects in spacetime like all others. In general relativity, spacetime is described with 3+1 dimensions (three in space, one in time).Absorption is not the right word. Gravity is responsible for their attraction.Everything that crosses the event horizon cannot get back. It goes to the center of the black hole.
Is there gravitational force is more? beyond the evenhorizon what happens?
 
rootone said:
A black hole is an extremely massive object and it therefore it has an immense amount of gravity.
So much gravity that beyond a certain point of closeness to it (the event horizon), the only direction anything can go is deeper into the gravity well, even light cannot escape beyond that point.
Is the black hole has any density?
 
Anything which has mass has density.
Nobody can be sure what happens to matter once it's inside the black hole since we can't look inside.
However there are objects which are nearly like black holes but just a little less massive, these are neutron stars.
In neutron stars individual atoms are disintegrated into a sea of subatomic particles, mainly consisting of neutrons.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: praveena
rootone said:
Anything which has mass has density.
Nobody can be sure what happens to matter once it's inside the black hole since we can't look inside.
However there are objects which are nearly like black holes but just a little less massive, these are neutron stars.
In neutron stars individual atoms are disintegrated into a sea of subatomic particles, mainly consisting of neutrons.
thank you sir.
 
mfb said:
Black holes are objects in spacetime like all others. In general relativity, spacetime is described with 3+1 dimensions (three in space, one in time).Absorption is not the right word. Gravity is responsible for their attraction.Everything that crosses the event horizon cannot get back. It goes to the center of them black hole.
You had mentioned about 3+1 dimension.Which means that you are talking about 4th dimension?
 
rootone said:
Anything which has mass has density.
Nobody can be sure what happens to matter once it's inside the black hole since we can't look inside.
However there are objects which are nearly like black holes but just a little less massive, these are neutron stars.
In neutron stars individual atoms are disintegrated into a sea of subatomic particles, mainly consisting of neutrons.
does the black hole has any shape? if the shape doesn't exist then how can we able to mention the dimension of black hole?
 
  • #10
A black hole doesn't have a surface as such so it's 'shape' isn't definable.
However we can talk of it's event horizon as having a shape, and like most other large cosmological objects, this is expected to be approximately spherical.
Most black holes are likely to be spinning, (again as do almost all other large cosmological objects).
Due to the spin the sphere shape is flattened into what is called an 'oblate spheroid' - most planets are actually oblate spheroids rather than perfect spheres.

(in the cases of many galaxies this flattened sphere shape goes to an extreme and the results is a broad disk)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Generator Gawl and praveena
  • #11
praveena said:
Is there gravitational force is more? beyond the evenhorizon what happens?
Possibly, all of the other forces exist there, thought with the amount of pressure and heat, they have have merged. Beyond the event horizon, what happens is unknown, mathematically, things just keep compressing further and further without end.

praveena said:
You had mentioned about 3+1 dimension.Which means that you are talking about 4th dimension?
Height, width, depth, and time

praveena said:
does the black hole has any shape? if the shape doesn't exist then how can we able to mention the dimension of black hole?
When astronomers talk about the radius of a black hole, they are usually referring to the diameter of the event horizon. That's simply the point at which gravity overwhelms light, which is calculable based on the theory of gravity and the formulation for escape velocity. As for the object itself, that's the core in the middle, different theories have different ideas of what the core is, it's most likely either a sphere or a point.

rootone said:
Most black holes are likely to be spinning, (again as do almost all other large cosmological objects).
Due to the spin the sphere shape is flattened into what is called an 'oblate spheroid' - most planets are actually oblate spheroids rather than perfect spheres.
A spinning point is still a point. The event horizon will have no distortion what so ever because it's not a physical thing. If the core is a sphere like string theory suggests, the idea that there would be centripetal forces is correct, but the amount of force created by the spinning would be next to nothing compared to the force of gravity.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: praveena
  • #12
praveena said:
I want to know which dimension does the black hole belongs? Can anyone say which force is responsible for the absorption? In case, if the black holes absorbs everything then were the things might gone?Is that everything becomes invisible or just blast into pieces?

As far as we know a black hole exists in our 3+1 dimensional space but it itself is considered to be in a state known as singularity so its size is infinitly small and does not consume more that one dimension but its strong gravity bends the space around it so much that it pulls virtually everything into it eve the light which makes a dark region around it and creates an optical illusion that the black hole has large sizes. The gravity of the black hole is dependent on the mass of the star once it was so, the more massive the black hole is the greater will be the size of its event horizon. The event horizon is the region beyond which nothing (even light) can escape the pull of the black hole.

As of now we are not sure where the matter being pulled into the black hole is going. But there are some possibilities, one of such possibility is that the matter being pulled is torn apart upto the subatomic level and the matter is converted into radiation and being ejected by the black hole. Another of such possibility is the matter is ejected into another part of the space since the black hole might have created a hole in the fabric of space itself.

The matter sucked into the black hole does not fall directly into the black hole, instead it first enters the accretion disk where the matter gets diffused or its physical properties are lost and then it is in an orbit around the black hole and eventually fall into the black hole in a spiral path.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Generator Gawl and praveena
  • #13
newjerseyrunner said:
Possibly, all of the other forces exist there, thought with the amount of pressure and heat, they have have merged. Beyond the event horizon, what happens is unknown, mathematically, things just keep compressing further and further without end.Height, width, depth, and timeWhen astronomers talk about the radius of a black hole, they are usually referring to the diameter of the event horizon. That's simply the point at which gravity overwhelms light, which is calculable based on the theory of gravity and the formulation for escape velocity. As for the object itself, that's the core in the middle, different theories have different ideas of what the core is, it's most likely either a sphere or a point.A spinning point is still a point. The event horizon will have no distortion what so ever because it's not a physical thing. If the core is a sphere like string theory suggests, the idea that there would be centripetal forces is correct, but the amount of force created by the spinning would be next to nothing compared to the force of gravity.

Hi
Really is the fourth dimension exist in our universe?
 
  • #14
Gautham Sharma said:
As far as we know a black hole exists in our 3+1 dimensional space but it itself is considered to be in a state known as singularity so its size is infinitly small and does not consume more that one dimension but its strong gravity bends the space around it so much that it pulls virtually everything into it eve the light which makes a dark region around it and creates an optical illusion that the black hole has large sizes. The gravity of the black hole is dependent on the mass of the star once it was so, the more massive the black hole is the greater will be the size of its event horizon. The event horizon is the region beyond which nothing (even light) can escape the pull of the black hole.

As of now we are not sure where the matter being pulled into the black hole is going. But there are some possibilities, one of such possibility is that the matter being pulled is torn apart upto the subatomic level and the matter is converted into radiation and being ejected by the black hole. Another of such possibility is the matter is ejected into another part of the space since the black hole might have created a hole in the fabric of space itself.

The matter sucked into the black hole does not fall directly into the black hole, instead it first enters the accretion disk where the matter gets diffused or its physical properties are lost and then it is in an orbit around the black hole and eventually fall into the black hole in a spiral path.
I was little confused by your answer. Does 3+1 dimension equals to 3rd dimension or 4th dimension?
 
  • #15
praveena said:
Hi
Really is the fourth dimension exist in our universe?
praveena said:
I was little confused by your answer. Does 3+1 dimension equals to 3rd dimension or 4th dimension?

You misunderstand. You and I and everything in the universe exists within 4 separate dimensions. Three of these are spatial dimensions and one is time. Here's what we mean by the word 'dimension'. If we need to specify where an object is or where an event takes place, we can set up something known as a 'coordinate system'. You already know what this is. Anytime you ever see a graph you see a 2-dimensional coordinate system where each point on the graph is represented by two numbers. The first number represents the X-coordinate and the second represents the Y-coordinate. So a point on the graph at (3,5) is located three to the right and five up from the origin (where each axis meets the other).

Now, that's just a 2-dimensional coordinate system. For the real world we have to add two more. The first one we have to add will give us our three spatial dimensions. Any point in space can be represented by three numbers, one for the X, Y, and Z axes each. In addition to these spatial coordinates, we need a 4th number to represent the point's location in time. (One minute ago, two minutes from now, last year, etc)

So in my coordinate system I can now label object A as being located at (5, 7, 2, 10), which is 5 meters to the right, 7 up, 2 coming 'out of the screen', and 10 seconds from now (assuming that I set my origin to be at the present).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: praveena
  • #16
Thank you for your explanation.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
6K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
7K