Why does a periscope reflect an inverted image?

  • Thread starter heatherro92
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Reflection
7 replies · 3K views · last reply
heatherro92
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Periscope diagram with two parallel plane mirrors on a grid, the object a red dot to the right, and labelled dots A to I showing candidate image locations for choosing the mirror images.


Multiple-choice checklist with nine options, Dot A through Dot I, each stating which mirror (mirror 1 or mirror 2) creates the image shown by that dot; none are selected.


This is the question and the answer choices. I thought it would be mirror one creates E and mirror 2 creates F, but It's not... help?
 
Attachments
  • Checklist of nine answer choices, Dot A through Dot I, each stating which mirror (1 or 2) shows the image of a dot, with a red X beside the list.
    Screen Shot 2013-04-04 at 8.55.32 PM.png
    3.4 KB · Views: 478
Then I thought the answer might be C and G, but that's also incorrect, I'm just not sure what to do!
 
heatherro92 said:
View attachment 57485

View attachment 57487

This is the question and the answer choices. I thought it would be mirror one creates E and mirror 2 creates F, but It's not... help?

Extend the mirrors 1, so that you can find a point perpendicularly behind the mirror, and the same distance behind as well - as always happens with a flat mirror.

Now extend mirror 2 and repeat the above step for the final image position.
 
Perhaps remember that mirrors don't magnify an image so the image can't appear closer than the distance a light ray takes from the object to the eye via the mirrors.
 
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror
 
heatherro92 said:
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror
As PeterO says, extend mirror 1 (in this case, up and to the right). If the object is at O and the image is at point X then you should find that the mirror perpendicularly bisects OX. That is not true of OB.
 
heatherro92 said:
Then I would think B would be the image from 1, but then there is no image from 2... I mean D is perpendicular, but it is further away then the distance from the object to the original mirror

You got B by extending the line from the object past the end of the existing mirror 1. That line is not perpendicular to the mirror.

I said extend mirror 1 - especially up to the right - then draw a line from the object that forms a right angle with the mirror.

Images in plane mirrors are DIRECTLY behind the mirror - so the line joining an object and and image is always perpendicular to the mirror.
 
heatherro92 - Try this experiment. Go to the bathroom and stand facing the mirror. Turn 45 degrees to the right. Does the image in the mirror stay in position A or move to position B ?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a person viewed from above beside a horizontal mirror line, with dotted sight lines labelled A and B; A points straight up, B points diagonally up and to the right.
    Mirror.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 558