Spoon Optics-Virtual Inverted image with a concave mirror

  • Thread starter ilzmaster
  • Start date
  • #1
2
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

When you look at a spoon, like at a mirror, the image of yourself appears to be on the other side of the mirror/spoon, where light does not go! So the image must be virtual!

So tell me, since a concave mirror must produce a real inverted image when you are far from the focal point http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_image how does a spoon produce a virtual inverted image?
OR is it that it only appears to be virtual and is really real? Which is problematic since you definitely see yourself on the other side of the spoon, just like with a plane mirror.

p.s. conceptual answers are preferred. I have been able to find values with the thin lens/mirror equation which work (f=-3, s=-4, s'=-12) but cannot ray trace anything like it or comprehend it. Criticisms on my f,s, and s' numbers are welcome too (and yes i know a negative s is weird but still, it works).

Thanks to anyone who dares answer!
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
When you look at a spoon, like at a mirror, the image of yourself appears to be on the other side of the mirror/spoon, where light does not go! So the image must be virtual!
Why do you think the image appears to be on the other side of the spoon? The surface is curved, so how can you tell?

I'm looking into a spoon right now. Looks like the usual inverted real image to me, on this side of the spoon (in the bowl, not behind it).

Try pointing a pencil at the spoon and look at its image.

For a ray diagram, look here: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/Hbase/geoopt/mirray.html#c3"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
2
0
I am at a college campus so I haven't used metal spoons for months.
I just got ahold of one. It is amazing. You're right, the image is real and not behind the spoon. The pencil tip helped too.

Thank you Doc Al!
 
  • #4
I will say, that image is actually formed on this side of the spoon -- means image is real, it is only we see on the background of spoon.
This can be confirmed by moving our eyes slightly, and the position of image changes drastically on tha background of spoon, proving that image is actually closer to eyes than spoon.
In case of virtual image formed by convex side of spoon, if we move our eyes little, the image position doesn't change to that extent prooving that image is farther from eyes compared to spoon.
 
  • #5
Why do you think the image appears to be on the other side of the spoon? The surface is curved, so how can you tell?

I'm looking into a spoon right now. Looks like the usual inverted real image to me, on this side of the spoon (in the bowl, not behind it).

Try pointing a pencil at the spoon and look at its image.

For a ray diagram, look here: Concave Mirror Image
I also have the same question and i still didn't understand the reason of a virtual inverted image.
Since we see the image in the spoon so it will be forming behind the mirror and the image will be virtual.
So why can't we say that the image is virtual?
 
  • #6
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
I also have the same question and i still didn't understand the reason of a virtual inverted image.
Since we see the image in the spoon so it will be forming behind the mirror and the image will be virtual.
So why can't we say that the image is virtual?
The image is in front of the spoon, not behind it (as a virtual image would be).
 
  • #7
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
You can get both a real and a virtual image with a concave reflector (same as with a convex lens). 'Shaving mirrors' are concave and produce a virtual (erect) magnified image (behind the wall, of course), when you are fairly close to them. If you move your head away, the image will suddenly 'burst' and then become a real, inverted image. This effect is much easier to see when the radius is large then in a spoon with a radius of only a few cm.
 
  • #8
The image is in front of the spoon, not behind it (as a virtual image would be).
If the image is in front of the spoon (or real) , then it should only appear on a screen in front of the spoon.But ,to our eyes, the light rays appear to come from behind the spoon.So, how can the image be real?
(I more thing sir. I have posted on my blog "the dispersion of sunlight by our eyelashes" , but i don't know the reason of it.Can you please help me in that?)
 
  • #9
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
If the image is in front of the spoon (or real) , then it should only appear on a screen in front of the spoon.But ,to our eyes, the light rays appear to come from behind the spoon.So, how can the image be real?
(I more thing sir. I have posted on my blog "the dispersion of sunlight by our eyelashes" , but i don't know the reason of it.Can you please help me in that?)
You may be confused because the spoon has such a small radius of curvature. The {inverted) image you see is real and in front of the reflecting surface. You can verify this by holding a pencil point just in front of the spoon and, getting the right position, you can use the no-parallax method to put it where it moves with your head (image) as you move from side to side.
The parallax method is described (though not very well) in this link.

If you can find a concave reflector with a less curved surface, you will find it a lot easier to see what's going on.
Taks some time to reflect on the problem, :biggrin:
 
  • #10
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
If the image is in front of the spoon (or real) , then it should only appear on a screen in front of the spoon.
The light is reflected off the spoon and is headed for your eyes. So you don't need a screen to see it.

But ,to our eyes, the light rays appear to come from behind the spoon.So, how can the image be real?
If you look closely, the image appears to be in front of the spoon, just within the bowl. (We are talking about the image formed at the concave side of the spoon.)

I recommend that you get a shaving mirror, as suggested by sophiecentaur, and play around with it. The larger radius of curvature allows you to move in and out of the focal length.
 
  • #11
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
The light is reflected off the spoon and is headed for your eyes. So you don't need a screen to see it.
Yes. There are several optical instruments which produce a real image that's not on a screen, although there is often an eyepiece to take that real image and put it, as a virtual image, somewhere more easy for the eye to focus on.
 
  • #12
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
Here's an example of a real image that's viewable without a screen (or an eyepiece), the classic "mirage" toy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBzjKHEJCaY
 
  • #13
1
0
The piggy illusion illustrated in the video above makes the piggy appear at a distance away from the surface of the concave mirror and not on it. The point raised in the beginning is why does appear that we see an image on the spoon or a concave surface.

Apart from a real image, a virtual image is also formed with a concave surface. Think of the concave mirror as made up of a large number of small pieces of plain mirrors, each such plain mirror will form a virtual image of its own, however since all the reflected rays converge , a real image is formed as well.
 
  • #14
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
The piggy illusion illustrated in the video above makes the piggy appear at a distance away from the surface of the concave mirror and not on it. The point raised in the beginning is why does appear that we see an image on the spoon or a concave surface.

Apart from a real image, a virtual image is also formed with a concave surface. Think of the concave mirror as made up of a large number of small pieces of plain mirrors, each such plain mirror will form a virtual image of its own, however since all the reflected rays converge , a real image is formed as well.
Not at the same time though. Real or virtual will depend upon were the object is placed. This is basic book work stuff and there is hardly any question about it.
 
  • #15
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
The piggy illusion illustrated in the video above makes the piggy appear at a distance away from the surface of the concave mirror and not on it. The point raised in the beginning is why does appear that we see an image on the spoon or a concave surface.
You might want to reread the first few posts again. The image in question is a real image that appears in front of the spoon--within the bowl, but in front of the surface of the spoon, not behind it.

The piggy illusion was just given as an example of a real image.
 
  • #16
1,007
76
But why it is said ,to view a real image a screen is needed ,when we can see real image with our eyes in this spoon case in air?I thought that we can only see virtual images directly by our eyes.
 
  • #17
1,007
76
This means that if we directly look in projector that forms real image we can watch movie?
Also it would be great help if one can answer how

Our retina can form real image of both virtual and real objects.
 
  • #18
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
But why it is said ,to view a real image a screen is needed ,when we can see real image with our eyes in this spoon case in air?I thought that we can only see virtual images directly by our eyes.
That is not "said", by people who 'know' the subject. What is said is that you can project a real image on a screen. Inside many optical devices you will find real images with no screen. At the other end, you may or may not find a projected real image to look at.
This is yet another example where the way things are classified is regarded as more important than understanding of the Physics.
 
  • #19
1,007
76
Thanks sophiecentaur for clearing my doubt.This real images sometimes confused me.I would be pleased if you can solve my other doubt that is above your reply.
 
  • #20
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
This means that if we directly look in projector that forms real image we can watch movie?
Also it would be great help if one can answer how

Our retina can form real image of both virtual and real objects.
If you stand in the right place, in front of a projector you can, in fact, see a real image. It is hard to identify what you are seeing but if you focus the projector to as short a distance as possible and stand well beyond the focal plane, you can actually see parts of the film slide. But it is not easy or pleasant to watch as the image moves about and looks distorted. Why are you trying to find exceptions to a 'rule' that you have found? Just consider that the rule might be an oversimplification of real life. (Like so many other things that teachers have to tell you in School.)
Look on this link and you will see the ray diagrams for various lens arrangements. The bottom three diagrams show what I mean. Note: you need to have your eye in the right place for the light in the narrow cone to enter it, if you look from the side the light will just go straight past you.
 
  • #21
1,007
76
Well one more time thanks for explaining in detail by giving heed to my reply.By the way I like applying things in practical life and like sometimes being critic.
 
  • #22
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,844
4,639
Well one more time thanks for explaining in detail by giving heed to my reply.By the way I like applying things in practical life and like sometimes being critic.
It can be great fun to try to apply the Physics of the Schoolroom to real life. It's surprising how accurate it can be.
 
  • #23
1,007
76
Can I ask you one more question that have came in my mind.For me it looks interesting and I think it's answer would also require skill and some deep knowledge.It's related to this virtual and real images only and I think you may be able to answer this question.Well I could have posted this in new thread as the spoon topic is receding but the way you are replying gives me satisfaction in topic and when I am posting you also may get alert, which will not in new thread(as we don't know each other really).If you are ready for the question just reply by yes or no as you may think it is going one on one interaction.
I would be grateful also to help you in some query if required.
 
  • #24
Doc Al
Mentor
44,959
1,223
Why don't you just ask your question?
 
  • #25
1,007
76
The question is , there are real objects around.Our eyes have a convex lens.So it forms a real inverted image on retina and our brain interprets by changing it to erect image.But when there is a real image around our brain interprets it as inverted but not erect,why that is so?Why the brain is doing opposite?Also there are cases of virtual object and virtual image in front of our eyes.How that you can explain?
 

Related Threads on Spoon Optics-Virtual Inverted image with a concave mirror

  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
7K
Replies
3
Views
596
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
8K
  • Last Post
Replies
18
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
787
Top