Why is dividing by zero impossible in math?

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
mathdad
Messages
1,280
Reaction score
0
We know division by zero is not possible but what is the math reason why it is impossible to divide by zero?
 
Let's say you wanted to do 5/0, then you're asking "how many 0's are there in 5?"

Well, try adding up 0's until you get to 5...

Hang on, 0 + 0 = 0... If I keep adding 0 we still stay at 0...

How can we ever possibly get to 5?
 
Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.

In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].<br /> <br /> - - - Updated - - -<br /> <br /> Saying that "[tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex]" is equivalent to "a= 0*c". But 0 times anything is 0 so that would say a= 0.<br /> <br /> In fact, some texts make a distinction between [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex], for a non-zero, and [tex]\frac{0}{0}[tex]. If [tex]a\ne 0[/tex] then [tex]\frac{a}{0}= c[/tex], for any number, c, is equivalent to [tex]a= 0*c= 0[/tex] which is false. There is NO number c that satisfies that so we say it is "undefined" or simply impossible.<br /> <br /> On the other hand, [tex]\frac{0}{0}= c[/tex] is equivalent to [tex]0= 0*c= 0[/tex] which <b>is</b> true- but is true for <b>any</b> number c. There is no unique number c such that this is true so we say that it is "undetermined".<br /> <br /> The difference is really only important in "limits". If I am trying to find [tex]\lim_{x\to a}\frac{f(x)}{g(x)}[/tex] and find that g, separately, goes to 0 while f goes to a non-zero number, I have the case [tex]\frac{a}{0}[/tex] for a non-zero: there is no such limit. But If both f and g go to 0 then there still might be a limit. For example, if [tex]f(x)= x^2- 9[/tex] and [tex]g(x)= x- 3[/tex] both f(3)= 0 and g(3)= 0. But for x <b>not</b> equal to 0, [tex]\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \frac{(x- 3)(x+ 3)}{x- 3}= x+ 3[/tex] so [tex]\lim_{x\to 3}\frac{x^2- 9}{x- 3}= \lim_{x\to 3} x+ 3= 6[/tex].[/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex][/tex]
 
Great information.

- - - Updated - - -

Say there are 5 people in a particular classroom. They came to class without a pencil. If the principal walks into the classroom and tells me to distribute one pencil per student but I have no pencils, no one will get a pencil. How can I divide a number by nothing? So, number ÷ nothing = undefined.