edoarad
- 19
- 0
is it also due to solar wind? if so why is it in a different direction than the gaz tail?
The discussion centers on the nature of comet tails, specifically the dust tail and its relationship to the gas tail, exploring the effects of solar wind and radiation pressure on their formation and orientation. The conversation includes theoretical aspects of comet behavior and observational phenomena.
Participants express differing views on the dynamics of comet tails, particularly regarding their orientation and the effects of solar wind. There is no consensus on the implications of these dynamics.
Participants note the complexity of observing comet tails in a three-dimensional context, which may affect interpretations of their orientation and behavior.
The dust tail is physical debris that it ablated from the comet by solar radiation, and it tends to trail the direction of travel of the comet. The ion (gas) tail often points in a different direction because the gases are less massive than the dust/ice, etc and are carried away from the direction of the Sun by the solar wind. There are times when the dust and gas tails coincide, and there are times when they can appear to point in opposite directions from our vantage point. We seen the comets' tails as if they were projected on a 2-D sky, but keep in mind that apart from that X-Y alignment, there are also Z-components (toward or away from us) that we cannot observe.edoarad said:is it also due to solar wind? if so why is it in a different direction than the gaz tail?
DaveC426913 said:Some people don't realize that the tail always points away from the Sun, regardelss of which way the comet is moving. Which means that, when the comet has rounded the sun and is on its way out of the system again, its tail is not a tail at all, it's a ... nose?