Why is the Heat equation solved with separation of variables but not with Fourier transformations?

  • Thread starter Thread starter yaman
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    math Physics
yaman
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
How did you find PF?: Years ago online forums were more visible. These days they are left behind social media. I searched Google and now I am here.

Why in heat transfer books Fourier's partial differtial unsteady state heat transfer equation is solved with seperation of variables but not with Fourier transformations?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello and :welcome:!

Have fun and stay curious!

Moderator's Note: I moved this into a technical forum. The "New member introduction" forum is only meant to say 'hello'.
 
yaman said:
Why in heat transfer books Fourier's partial differtial unsteady state heat transfer equation is solved with seperation of variables but not with Fourier transformations?

Have you tried solving it on a finite interval subject to initial and boundary conditions (the typical geometry appropriate for separation of variables) using a transform method? Is that easier or harder than separation of variables?
 
yaman said:
Why in heat transfer books Fourier's partial differtial unsteady state heat transfer equation is solved with seperation of variables but not with Fourier transformations?
This is simply incorrect. The method applied will generally depend on the domain. An infinite domain will be suited for transforms such as the Fourier transform, whereas a finite domain will be more suited for series expansions. Both methods are effectively the same and amount to separation of variables.

I know at least one textbook that uses Fourier transforms to solve the heat equation (and series expansion on finite domains). I know this because I wrote it.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and hutchphd
There is the following linear Volterra equation of the second kind $$ y(x)+\int_{0}^{x} K(x-s) y(s)\,{\rm d}s = 1 $$ with kernel $$ K(x-s) = 1 - 4 \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} \dfrac{1}{\lambda_n^2} e^{-\beta \lambda_n^2 (x-s)} $$ where $y(0)=1$, $\beta>0$ and $\lambda_n$ is the $n$-th positive root of the equation $J_0(x)=0$ (here $n$ is a natural number that numbers these positive roots in the order of increasing their values), $J_0(x)$ is the Bessel function of the first kind of zero order. I...
Are there any good visualization tutorials, written or video, that show graphically how separation of variables works? I particularly have the time-independent Schrodinger Equation in mind. There are hundreds of demonstrations out there which essentially distill to copies of one another. However I am trying to visualize in my mind how this process looks graphically - for example plotting t on one axis and x on the other for f(x,t). I have seen other good visual representations of...
Back
Top