Why Might a Math Solution Involve Doubling the Percentage Difference?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a problem involving the calculation of percentage difference in a physics context, specifically related to vertical height gained. Participants are examining discrepancies between their calculations and those provided in a mark scheme.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants are comparing their calculated percentage difference with a provided value, questioning the basis for the percentage difference calculation. There is an exploration of whether to use different baseline values (1.1 m vs. 1.2 m) for the calculation, leading to differing interpretations of the problem.

Discussion Status

Some participants have offered clarifications regarding the baseline for the percentage difference calculation, while others have raised concerns about the ambiguity in the problem statement. The discussion reflects a mix of understanding and confusion regarding the appropriate values to use in the calculations.

Contextual Notes

There is mention of a 'worked example' that may provide additional context, but it was not initially included in the discussion. This omission has contributed to the confusion regarding the baseline values for the percentage difference calculation.

tahmidbro
Messages
15
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
My answer does not match with the ones in book
Relevant Equations
N/A

Attachments

  • sdfsd.PNG
    sdfsd.PNG
    21.7 KB · Views: 188
  • sasd.PNG
    sasd.PNG
    4.9 KB · Views: 166
Physics news on Phys.org
If you read the question, you will find that you were asked to compare against 1.1, not against 1.2
the poorly quoted question said:
Compare your answer with the 1.1 m calculated in the...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tahmidbro
tahmidbro said:
Homework Statement:: My answer does not match with the ones in book
Relevant Equations:: N/A

See the question : https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/att...hmentid=978958

The mark scheme/answer : https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/att...hmentid=978956

I have got the answer to the vertical height gained = 1.355 m. No problem.

But not the value of the percentage difference. Their value : 23%, my value =( (1.355-1.2 )/1.35) x 100% = 11.48%

Well, I suspect that they are multiplying %D by 2, but why?
Your first link says the calculated height is 1.1m, not 1.2m.
You are asked for the % difference relative to 1.1m, so you should divide (1.355 - 1.1) by 1.1
 
Now I understand. Thank you!
 
I have a minor quibble with the response given by @Steve4Physics. He points out quite correctly that if one is computing the percentage difference of 1.355 from 1.1 that one should divide the delta by 1.1.

However, the question at hand does not specify whether we should use the 1.1 or the 1.355 as the baseline.

the poorly quoted question said:
calculate the percentage difference between the two answers
There is nothing in that request that elevates either of the two answers to the status of baseline. One could argue for the correctness of any of three possible answers to this ambiguous question.

1. ##\frac{\text{high}-\text{low}}{\text{low}}##
2. ##\frac{\text{low}-\text{high}}{\text{high}}##
3. ##\frac{\text{high}-\text{low}}{\text{high}}##
 
Sorry for forgetting to upload the 'worked example' along with the question
My bad :-d
 

Attachments

  • jfk.PNG
    jfk.PNG
    40 KB · Views: 163
jbriggs444 said:
There is nothing in that request that elevates either of the two answers to the status of baseline. One could argue for the correctness of any of three possible answers to this ambiguous question.
Agreed that the question isn't particularly well expressed, but the OP's first link explicitly says
"Compare your answer with the 1.1m calculated in the worked example..."
which implies 1.1m is the 'baseline'.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jbriggs444
tahmidbro said:
Sorry for forgetting to upload the 'worked example' along with the question
My bad :-d
For future reference, it is much easier to quote sections of the problem if it is transcribed as text rather than attached as an image.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tahmidbro