Why must gamma equal beta in the Heine-Borel theorem proof?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter kidsasd987
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Proof Theorem
3 replies · 3K views · last reply
kidsasd987
Messages
142
Reaction score
4
Hello, I have a question about Heine Borel Theorem.

First, I am not sure why we have to show
"gamma=Beta"
gamma is the supremum of F(which is equivalent to H_squiggly_bar in the text ), and it has to be greater than beta. Otherwise, S contains H_squiggly_barSecond, for the case 1, why S_gamma+eps does not have a finite subcovering? which definition the author is referring to?

I understand sup(F) = gamma, so S_gamma-eps must have a finite subcovering because by definition H_squiggly_bar is a set of finite subcovering. But isn't there a possibility that S_gamma+eps also has a finite subcovering?

That consists of H_squiggly bar + some finite set that belongs to H but not contained within H_squiglly bar?
 
Attachments
  • Scanned page from Trench's Real Analysis textbook showing a proof of the Heine-Borel theorem, Case 2, with the surrounding text on compact sets and Example 1.3.11.
    스크린샷 2016-07-11 5.45.36 PM.png
    94.4 KB · Views: 765
  • Screenshot of a PDF page from Trench's Real Analysis, page 33, showing the proof of the Heine-Borel theorem with the definitions of S_t and the set F, followed by the start of the argument that gamma equals beta.
    스크린샷 2016-07-11 5.45.30 PM.png
    76.5 KB · Views: 698
  • Typeset proof page titled Heine-Borel Theorem: if H is an open covering of a closed and bounded set S, there exists a subcover H~ of H covering S, with steps (a) S subset of H~, (b) sup(S) < sup(H~), (c) inf(H~) < inf(S), and a contradiction argument.
    Heine_Borel_Theorem.png
    31.1 KB · Views: 1,599
Without the text, the notation you use needs to be defined.
 
mathman said:
Without the text, the notation you use needs to be defined.

I am sorry. This is the updated version. Do you think the proof is right? and what do you think of the question at the end?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten-style typeset notes proving the Heine-Borel theorem: a closed bounded set S covered by open sets H_i, with nested sets C_k and H_i intersections, ending with a question about covering S by infinitely many sets.
    Heine_Borel_2.png
    28.9 KB · Views: 670
I am finding these attachments hard to read (type size). In the latest attachment, much of the analysis makes use of [itex]H_i[/itex], which is not defined.