I Why no heavy delayed neutron emitters?

  • Thread starter Thread starter snorkack
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Neutron
Click For Summary
Heavy isotopes of elements beyond lead (Pb) predominantly exhibit beta decay without delayed neutron emission, a trend observed up to element 100. This absence of delayed neutron emitters in heavier isotopes is attributed to their nuclear energy levels and the neutron-to-proton ratio, which favors beta decay as nuclei become more neutron-rich. Some isotopes, like those of bismuth and astatine, can undergo beta decay with neutron emission, but they have short half-lives and are challenging to produce. Additionally, while isotopes like 230Ac can undergo spontaneous fission, they are less relevant in practical applications, particularly in nuclear reactors where delayed neutrons are crucial. Research continues to focus on isotopes that contribute to delayed neutron emissions, which are significant for fission processes.
snorkack
Messages
2,388
Reaction score
536
TL;DR
Delayed decays don´t seem to occur in elements heavier than Tl
As a rule, starting with He, the heavy isotopes of all elements are delayed neutron emitters:
  1. He-4 stable
  2. He-5 unbound
  3. He-6 β- only 807 ms
  4. He-7 unbound
  5. He-8 β-n 16% of 120 ms
then:
  1. Li-7 stable
  2. Li-8 β- only 839 ms
  3. Li-9 β-n2α 50% of 178 ms
etc... till
  1. Tl-205 stable
  2. Tl-206 (RaE) β- only 252 s
  3. Tl-207 (AcC) β- only 286 s
  4. Tl-208 (ThC'') β- only 183 s
  5. Tl-209 β- only 130 s
  6. Tl-210 (RaC'') β-n 0,01% of 78 s
  7. Tl-211 β-n 2,2% of 80 s
But then:
  1. Pb-208 (ThD) stable
  2. Pb-209 β- only 3,24 h
  3. Pb-210 (RaD) β- only 22 y
  4. Pb-211 (AcB) β- only 2170 s
  5. Pb-212 (ThB) β- only 10,6 h
  6. Pb-213 β- only 610 s
  7. Pb-214 (RaB) β- only 1625 s
  8. Pb-215 β- only 142 s
  9. Pb-216 β- only 40 s
  10. Pb-217 β- only 20 s
  11. Pb-218 β- only 15 s
... and that´s it? No Pb isotopes are delayed neutron emitters.
This seems also to be the case for all heavier elements to about 100. Heavy isotopes are pure beta emitters, with no delayed neutrons. Why?
Also, is it possible for an isotope to undergo delayed fission? As in β-f? Are there any such isotopes?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
snorkack said:
TL;DR Summary: Delayed decays don´t seem to occur in elements heavier than Tl

This seems also to be the case for all heavier elements to about 100. Heavy isotopes are pure beta emitters, with no delayed neutrons. Why?
It has to do with the nuclear energy levels, which are characteristic of the radionuclide. One could ask why branching fractions are the way they are, or why gamma transitions are the energy they are.

See Figure 2 in this document - https://ec.europa.eu/programmes/era..._part_2_Experiment_procedure_for_students.pdf
However, in some cases a daughter nucleus is formed after a β- decay, where the
excitation energy is higher than the neutron-separation energy. This nucleus will emit again a
neutron, almost promptly after its formation. As these neutrons are generated from several
milliseconds to several minutes after the fission event, they are called delayed neutrons.

I think one is referring to elements of Z up to 100. Some isotopes are alpha emitters, and some do both alpha or beta, otherwise, as the n/p ratio increases, the neutron rich nuclei decay by beta emission, if not by alpha.

Some nuclei decay by 'spontaneous emission', e.g., 252Cf, and important nuclide for startup neutron sources in nuclear reactors.

Looking at the Tl isotopes 209 through 214, one sees a decrease in half-life and high fraction of β-,n decay. There are heavier nuclides that may decay by β-,n, e.g., 221Bi, 227At, 233Fr, and the heavier isotopes of those elements. I suspect they have very short half-lives and are difficult to produce given the relative high n; they are also odd Z elements, Bi (Z=83), At (Z-85), Fr (Z=87).

230Ac is perhaps the lightest nuclide that can undergo 'spontaneous fission' (SF), but is more likely to undergo beta decay with a half-life of 122 s.

The heavier nuclei are of less interest in terrestrial systems, since they are hard to produce, the half-lives are short, and they are not usually found in nuclear reactors where delayed neutrons are important. Instead research has focused on those delayed neutron nuclides that are important fission products, e.g, 87Br or 93Rb.
 

Attachments

  • Tl-209-214_n-emission.png
    Tl-209-214_n-emission.png
    10.4 KB · Views: 43
Last edited by a moderator:
Theoretical physicist C.N. Yang died at the age of 103 years on October 18, 2025. He is the Yang in Yang-Mills theory, which he and his collaborators devised in 1953, which is a generic quantum field theory that is used by scientists to study amplitudes (i.e. vector probabilities) that are foundational in all Standard Model processes and most quantum gravity theories. He also won a Nobel prize in 1957 for his work on CP violation. (I didn't see the post in General Discussions at PF on his...

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K