Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the potential adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Silmarillion" by Peter Jackson for film. Participants explore the challenges and implications of adapting a work that is largely considered a collection of histories and backstories rather than a cohesive narrative. The conversation touches on Jackson's previous adaptations of Tolkien's works and the varying opinions on their quality.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants express skepticism about the viability of adapting "The Silmarillion," arguing it lacks a traditional narrative structure and may result in a dull film.
- Others suggest that while "The Silmarillion" is more of a historical account, it contains stories worth adapting, though they caution about potential misinterpretations by filmmakers.
- Several participants praise Peter Jackson's previous work on "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," with some believing he could successfully adapt "The Silmarillion" if approached correctly.
- Concerns are raised about Jackson's treatment of source material, particularly regarding the expansion of "The Hobbit" into three films, leading to fears that "The Silmarillion" could suffer a similar fate.
- Some participants propose that specific stories within "The Silmarillion," such as "The Children of Hurin" or the tale of Beren and Lúthien, could be adapted into films, though opinions vary on how many films would be necessary for such adaptations.
- There is mention of the rights issues surrounding "The Silmarillion," with one participant stating that Jackson does not hold the rights to adapt it.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether "The Silmarillion" should be adapted into film. While some express enthusiasm for the idea, others strongly oppose it, leading to a range of competing views on the feasibility and desirability of such an adaptation.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight the unfinished nature of "The Silmarillion" and its structure as a collection of histories, which may complicate any adaptation efforts. There are also references to the rights issues that could impact Jackson's ability to adapt the work.