Work done by torque on a wheel turning about a curb

7 replies · 4K views · last reply
Taulant Sholla
Messages
96
Reaction score
5

Homework Statement


Diagram of a wheel of radius r with a horizontal force F applied at its axle, pushing it against a step obstacle of height h on the right.


Homework Equations


work-kinetic energy theorem

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten-style worked solution on a wheel-over-curb problem: work-energy steps with integrals of torque times d theta, mg R sin theta and F R cos theta, limits 60 to 0 degrees, F = 4.526 N, and a note that the correct answer is 13.58 N. Beside it, a diagram of a wheel against a curb of height h with force F and a 60 degree torque arm.
 
You've assumed that it is possible for Wnet to equal zero when F is constant. Try to see why this can't be true.

Can you figure out how much force is required to get the wheel to start to rise?
 
Further to TSny's hints...
You write that you have to solve it by the Work-KE theorem. I suspect you have misunderstood the requirement. As TSny writes, you have no guarantee that ##\Delta KE=0##.
You can solve statics problems using virtual work. Maybe that is what you are supposed to be using? But that method considers infinitesimal changes in position, not integrating over a substantial change.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hamal_Arietis
TSny said:
You've assumed that it is possible for Wnet to equal zero when F is constant. Try to see why this can't be true.

Can you figure out how much force is required to get the wheel to start to rise?
Ah, yes. Thank you. It would take a variable force to result in a final kinetic energy of 0. I know torque equilibrium yields the constant force required to offset the torque produced by gravity. Thank you again.
 
haruspex said:
Further to TSny's hints...
You write that you have to solve it by the Work-KE theorem. I suspect you have misunderstood the requirement. As TSny writes, you have no guarantee that ##\Delta KE=0##.
You can solve statics problems using virtual work. Maybe that is what you are supposed to be using? But that method considers infinitesimal changes in position, not integrating over a substantial change.
Right. Thank you. I need to find the rotational kinetic energy of the wheel once it rises to the top of the curb.
 
You assumed that ##ds=Rd\theta## but ##ds>0## and ##d\theta <0##. So it is wrong
If you assumed that ##ds=-Rd\theta## I think you will get answer
 
Hamal_Arietis said:
You assumed that ##ds=Rd\theta## but ##ds>0## and ##d\theta <0##. So it is wrong
If you assumed that ##ds=-Rd\theta## I think you will get answer
Taulant's error was to calculate a funny kind of average force (averaged over horizontal distance, which is not what is meant by "average force") necessary to provide the PE gain. Instead, the force to be found is the minimum constant force that will get it over the step. The next stage is to find the residual KE that results. That could be done by integration, but it is not necessary.
Monsterboy said:
Isn't that angle = 30o ?
Taulant set θ as the angle to the vertical, the 60o. That reduces as the wheel rises.