Recent content by Isaac0427

  1. I

    Undergrad Are certain combinations of quantum numbers (basis vectors) forbidden?

    ##|nlsm_lm_s\rangle## is equivalent to ##|nlsm_lm_j\rangle## due to the relation ##m_j=m_l+m_s##. This relation does render some ##|nlsm_lm_j\rangle## states invalid, though, eg., for a spin-1/2 particle we have the requirement ##m_j = m_l \pm 1/2##. I think this just makes ##|nlsm_lm_j\rangle##...
  2. I

    Graduate Questions about scale dependence and renormalization schemes

    Hi, I have several related questions about scale dependence in different renormalization schemes. 1. Is there scale dependence in the on-shell (OS) scheme? Peskin & Schroeder chapter 10 goes through on-shell renormalization without involving an auxiliary scale, but other sources (see...
  3. I

    Undergrad Superposition of different spins

    Thank you! I was not worried; I just curious as to how fundamental this empirical fact is to our theoretical understanding of particles.
  4. I

    Undergrad Superposition of different spins

    Ok, this is making much more sense. I think the last follow-up question is this: I can see that if we somehow discovered a particle that was a mix of spin-0 and spin-1/2, this would force us to fundamentally reconsider our understanding of quantum mechanics as a whole. If we discovered a...
  5. I

    Undergrad Superposition of different spins

    Right, I do know this. My question here was why that is the case, specifically if it was a theoretical necessity or an empirical observation. What I have gathered so far is that the superposition of integer-spin and half-integer spin is forbidden by theoretical necessity. The superposition of...
  6. I

    Undergrad Weakly interacting electrons in an atom

    Right, I am talking about the term symbols -- i.e., for carbon ##^3D## is forbidden, since #L# is even and #S# is odd. I don't know how that works. Perhaps a mentor can move this post there, if it is appropriate.
  7. I

    Undergrad Superposition of different spins

    Thank you for the answer. It leaves me with this question though: wouldn't the same logic prohibit, say, the state ##\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|210\rangle + |220\rangle)## (expressing states as ##|nlm\rangle##? My understanding is that a state like that would be allowed. Additionally, I checked out...
  8. I

    Undergrad Weakly interacting electrons in an atom

    Consider electrons in atom, and let's mostly ignore interactions between the electrons for now. What I mean by that is that the lowest energy level is the doubly degenerate 1s, then the doubly degenerate 2s, then the 6-fold degenerate 2p, etc. Textbooks like Griffiths use term symbols...
  9. I

    Undergrad Superposition of different spins

    Hi all, it has been quite a while since I've been on here. I am curious, as the TLDR summary says, if it theoretically possible to have a particle in a superposition of states with different ##S^2## eigenvalues. For example, a particle being in the state...
  10. I

    Undergrad Understanding the change of variables for PDEs

    Right, but I'm trying to figure out this with matrices/rotating coordinates to diagonalize ##A##. My understanding of what you wrote is that if you have ##\vec{y}=P\vec{x}##, this means (assuming ##P## is a constant nxn matrix) ##\partial_\vec{x}=P\partial_\vec{y}##. Is that correct? And if so...
  11. I

    Undergrad Understanding the change of variables for PDEs

    I've been trying to get change of variables in PDEs down (I don't particularly like my textbook or professor's approach to it), and I want to ask here if I am getting this right. Let ##\vec{x}=(x_1,x_2,...,x_n)^T## and ##\partial_\vec{x}=(\partial_{x_1},\partial_{x_2},...,\partial_{x_n})^T##. I...
  12. I

    Undergrad An interesting Nonlinear Differential Equation

    Force varies with distance from the center of Earth. Where does this come from? I may just be missing something obvious here.
  13. I

    Undergrad An interesting Nonlinear Differential Equation

    Where does one find the solution? Wolfram Alpha didn't come up with anything. I could try to reverse engineer it, or in any case check a few things with the solution that I've wanted to look at.
  14. I

    Undergrad An interesting Nonlinear Differential Equation

    That's pretty much it. If there is a very basic strategy that I am forgetting from ODEs, please let me know, though I don't recall any strategies for nonlinear second order equations. I've tried looking up "motion of a free falling object" with various specifications to try to get the solution...
  15. I

    High School Orthogonal Projections: Same Thing or Not?

    And yes. I see though that it would all be meaningless if they were invertible matrices, as then the span of A would be all of ##\mathbb{R}^n##, and a vector in ##\mathbb{R}^n##'s projection onto ##\mathbb{R}^n## is just itself.