Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter synch
  • Start date
15 replies · 1K views · last reply
synch
Messages
95
Reaction score
12
In Newtonian physics, does mass have any intrinsic properties apart from inertia ?
[ Obviously effects exist but most stem from charge or electromagnetic properties ]
If there is no evidence of mass apart from inertia, I don't see how there is definite quantitation.
Is the mass m in Newtons laws actually referring to inertia ?
 
The orbit of one mass about another, is the combination of inertia in one direction and gravitational attraction in another.
 
synch said:
In Newtonian physics, does mass have any intrinsic properties apart from inertia ?
[ Obviously effects exist but most stem from charge or electromagnetic properties ]
If there is no evidence of mass apart from inertia, I don't see how there is definite quantitation.
Is the mass m in Newtons laws actually referring to inertia ?
The mass itself, is this what you mean? Protons, neutrons, electrons?
 
synch said:
Is the mass m in Newtons laws actually referring to inertia ?
Depends on which of Newton's Laws you mean. In Newton's 2nd Law of motion it's inertia, in Newton's Law of Gravitation it's not.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dale and dextercioby
Ibix said:
Here, hold this ten ton weight for me.

It depends on which planet / orbit ... and I'm trying to give up bosons .. :)

So, is gravity a property of inertia instead of mass ?
 
synch said:
So, is gravity a property of inertia instead of mass ?
Mass is both the resistance to a change in state of motion and the gravitational charge.

You are free to substitute the word "inertia" everywhere you see the word "mass" if you wish. This will change nothing about the physics, merely impede communication with everyone else.
 
Back in college my late professor of mechanics said: classical Newtonian mechanics is the basis theory of physics, upon which all theories are built. So its fundamental concepts are hard(er) to define, because they don't reduce to others. So we will make an extraordinary definition for one of the simplest and most important notions: mass or inertial mass. It is simply the quantity of substance possessed by a physical body, so it's essentially the definition from macroscopic general chemistry.
 
synch said:
In Newtonian physics, does mass have any intrinsic properties apart from inertia ?
Gravitation.

Although talking about a property of mass is a little weird since mass is a property of matter. So literally you are asking about if properties have properties. But not taken quite so literally I would say gravitation is a different thing than inertia.
 
My impression is, an entity (say an apple) (and its frame of reference) in free space is drifting in whatever gravity is present. A human observer (on Earth in the orchard) projects the observers frame of reference onto the phenomenon, and to stop the apple falling locally (down) an acceleration has to be applied (up), against the inertia of the entity, the observer perceiving that resistance as weight. The inertia of the entity is also experienced when, say, throwing the apple. So I think "mass" is usually just inertia.

Many physics textbooks simply state the law F = ma as a statement of causality which doesn't help much.
I think F = a / I (where I = inertia) would be better.

It is easier for me to think of gravity and inertia being related, instead of gravity and mass. Maybe if inertia has a gravitational field, "mass" is not required (!?). I think the gravitation laws could use inertia instead of mass with no quantitative difference but that may not be advisable !!!
 
Last edited:
synch said:
I think F = a / I (where I = inertia) would be better.
As I said, you are free to define ##I=1/m## and use it everywhere everybody else uses ##m## if you wish. You are changing nothing except notation.

Note that your definition of inertia implies that applying the same force to an object with a large inertia will cause it to accelerate faster than one with a smaller inertia, which is not the customary meaning of the word.
 
synch said:
It is easier for me to think of gravity and inertia being related, instead of gravity and mass
You could say something similar in General relativity, but your question was specifically about Newtonian physics.

In standard Newtonian physics free fall motion in a gravitational field is not straight line motion. So it is not inertia.

Even in GR where free fall motion is straight-line motion, mass still measures how much a spherical object curves spacetime.
 
Last edited:
synch said:
I think F = a / I (where I = inertia) would be better.
This is the opposite of how most people use the word 'inertia'.
 
I agree the formula went scrambled there !
The intention is to use inertia instead of mass, where inertia is the resistance to forced acceleration.
So F = m a becomes F = I a where I is inertia.

Newton assumed gravity was a force acting on the apple, but that was a mistake I think. If Newton fell from the tree alongside the apple as he observed it, he would not see the apple being affected at all (well, for a short time :) ).
 
Last edited:
synch said:
Newton assumed gravity was a force acting on the apple, but that was a mistake I think.
For the purpose of your question however, it doesn't really matter. Either way gravity is something beyond inertia, either a force or a spacetime curvature.
 
synch said:
Many physics textbooks simply state the law F = ma as a statement of causality which doesn't help much.
I think F = a / I (where I = inertia) would be better.
##F_{net} = \frac{dp}{dt}##

There, we not only got rid of your confusion but also now have the correct second law in the Newtonian framework.

Everything else is just semantics.