- #1
Schrodinger's Dog
- 835
- 7
All actions have motivational considerations, but can you describe a truly selfless act that transcends motivation or gain? It's a simple question, but a difficult one to answer I think.
Schrodinger's Dog said:All actions have motivational considerations, but can you describe a truly selfless act that transcends motivation or gain? It's a simple question, but a difficult one to answer I think.
AsianSensationK said:doing what duty tells you to do.
eaboujaoudeh said:panda just to get ur last comment straight. Do you think that giving money to the poor is selfish or not?
eaboujaoudeh said:panda just to get ur last comment straight. Do you think that giving money to the poor is selfish or not?
gabee said:Question inspired by the Friends episode? :P
Schrodinger's Dog said:There is obviously no possible gain to you personally, unless you consider dying a gain.
eaboujaoudeh said:But in both cases, who could live with himself if he knows that he could have done something but didn't? so even that has a slight selfish act, cause not doing anything for saving someone also has its consequences and no1 ever wishes to live them.
eaboujaoudeh said:panda just to get ur last comment straight. Do you think that giving money to the poor is selfish or not?
eaboujaoudeh said:finally some ppl who feel the same way as i do..human beings are naturally forced to be selfish, but some in a good way, some in better ways then others, some selfish to the extreme
Panda said:Ahhh, if you are theist then dying to save a thousand souls would be a gain as you would be rewarded in heaven and therefore again there is a selfish factor to the act. I think you can only do something selflessly if you do it instinctively.
Of course what drives your instincts if not your mind and personality? it could be an unconscious selfish act, but as that is untestable it is beyond the scope of the post.
baywax said:Being born.
Schrodinger's Dog said:I think by act we mean something you have a choice about, I'm pretty sure all babies have no choice about this.
baywax said:OK. But do you have a choice about doing what makes you feel good? Is there any other choice?
Panda said:Naturally we do. Could glue thumb tacks to each of the keys of my keyboard, but that would make me feel bad whilst typing so I'll choose not to, equally I could design a keyboard made out of chocolate that would make be feel good whilst typing, but I'd then get fat(ter) and feel bad so again I'll choose not to.
Schrodinger's Dog said:All actions have motivational considerations, but can you describe a truly selfless act that transcends motivation or gain?
Panda said:Naturally we do. Could glue thumb tacks to each of the keys of my keyboard, but that would make me feel bad whilst typing so I'll choose not to, equally I could design a keyboard made out of chocolate that would make be feel good whilst typing, but I'd then get fat(ter) and feel bad so again I'll choose not to.
Unless you are trying to swing this to an argument about the existence of free will, given the apparent prescence of free will we can choose to make ourselves happy or sad. I think that we will always make choices towards happiness in the long term.
baywax said:If pain makes you happy then you are going to put yourself in pain. If pain is all you know then that is what you will seek. It is not as cut and dried as you make it out to be.
What act is there that a person performs that doesn't gratify their conscious and/or subconscious desires?
out of whack said:What motivates a conscious decision is the desired and expected outcome of the decision. There is no way you can interpret a desired and expected outcome as something you do not actually want, something selfless. Any decision you make is necessarily selfish because every one of your conscious decisions is the result of what motivates you.
that's very real motivation. if soldier disobey, he's going to jail.AsianSensationK said:no real motivation, other than doing what duty tells you to do.
Not really, you will have short moments of increased self-respect.Schrodinger's Dog said:If for example your conscious decision is to save 4000000 people and to die yourself and you are not religious and believe you will get no reward for your action nor will anyone else benefit ever except obviously the 400000 people but all of them will be totally unaware your action saved them and you will die in such a way that no one even knew you were there, and thus you will be reported missing and no one will tie in your act with you, etc, etc is this truly selfless?
whatta said:Not really, you will have short moments of increased self-respect.
Schrodinger's Dog said:OK so is it possible to have a truly selfless act given what you just typed, given the whole of humanity or x group?
Schrodinger's Dog said:If for example your conscious decision is to save 4000000 people and to die yourself and you are not religious and believe you will get no reward for your action nor will anyone else benefit ever except obviously the 400000 people but all of them will be totally unaware your action saved them and you will die in such a way that no one even knew you were there, and thus you will be reported missing and no one will tie in your act with you, etc, etc is this truly selfless?
out of whack said:I don't believe so for the reason I gave in my previous post.
I think you can formulate any dilemma in any manner you wish and it would still not matter. In your example, if you are motivated to make this decision then clearly your expect that the outcome will be to save these people and clearly you desire this outcome. The exact reason why you desire this outcome are personal. It could be that you would not want to keep on living with the knowledge that you sacrificed four million people. It could be that failure to act would violate your self-respect. Or anything along these lines. A motivator can be avoidance of a negative as well as desire of a positive. Regardless of the specific motive, the motive exists and it is what you personally want. The fact that different people would make different decisions simply reflects different personal motivators.