What is Relativity: Definition and 997 Discussions
The theory of relativity usually encompasses two interrelated theories by Albert Einstein: special relativity and general relativity, proposed and published in 1905 and 1915, respectively. Special relativity applies to all physical phenomena in the absence of gravity. General relativity explains the law of gravitation and its relation to other forces of nature. It applies to the cosmological and astrophysical realm, including astronomy.The theory transformed theoretical physics and astronomy during the 20th century, superseding a 200-year-old theory of mechanics created primarily by Isaac Newton. It introduced concepts including spacetime as a unified entity of space and time, relativity of simultaneity, kinematic and gravitational time dilation, and length contraction. In the field of physics, relativity improved the science of elementary particles and their fundamental interactions, along with ushering in the nuclear age. With relativity, cosmology and astrophysics predicted extraordinary astronomical phenomena such as neutron stars, black holes, and gravitational waves.
Spacetime is a differential manifold and at each point is attached a Minkowski spacetime.
There the laws of physics are the usual ones without gravity.
Gravity is the curvature of spacetime. To define the concept of curvature do we need to evaluate at least one neighborhood of point P? Is...
Hello,
this is my first thread.
Robert Wald, in General Relativity, equation (4.2.8) says :
E = – pa va
where E is the energy of a particle, pa the energy-momentum 4-vector and va the 4-velocity of the particle. How can I see this is compatible with the common energy-momentum-relation E2 – p2 =...
In GR, a free falling object when viewed by a distant observer appears to be length contracted and slows down as it approaches the event horizon of a black hole. The length contraction piece, however, seems counterintuitive. I would have thought that the leading edge of the object would...
Some physicists prefer to explain the problem of conservation of energy in General Relativity by considering the gravitational potential energy of the universe that would cancel all the other energies and therefore the energy in the universe would be conserved this way.
However, many other...
What mathematical topics do I need to know to start studying general relativity?
From which textbooks can I learn them?
I don't currently know anything about differential geometry. I know calculus, linear algebra, mathematical methods of physics (the necessary topics for quantum mechanics) and...
Hi,
In general relativity, gravitation is not anymore a Force but a deformation of space time. I would like to know what's becomes the 3 law of Newton for gravity that action equal reaction ? When a apple fall on the earth, does "the force" is exactly the same as the one applied on Earth ...
i) The muon reaches the ground
ii)
To a ground observer, the decay time is dilated
$$\Delta t_d=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}}\Delta\tau_d>\Delta \tau_d$$
The time for the muon to reach the ground is
$$\Delta t_g=\frac{10 km}{0.999c}< \Delta t_d$$
which is why it reaches the ground...
Following are not strictly physics questions. But cool questions to discuss.
We need to add dark energy to our cosmological model if we strictly follow GR. This lead to some beliefs that GR is an effective theory.
(1)Do you believe that GR is the fundamental theory? If GR is an effective...
Hi everybody.
I recently started to learn GR from a very begginer level. I would like to share with you some lines of discussion, to understand your approach to some specific topics which for me are key to better understand the whole story.
If a put an accelerometer on the floor it reads 9.8...
When we compute the stress energy momentum tensor ## T_{\mu\nu} ##, it has units of energy density. If, therefore, we know the total energy ##E## of the system described by ## T_{\mu\nu} ##, can we compute the volume of the system from ## V = E/T_{00}##?
If it holds, I would assume this would...
We know that both momentum and position can not be known precisely simultaneously. The more precisely momentum is known means position is more uncertain. In fact, as I understand quantum mechanics, position probability never extends to 0% anywhere in the universe (except at infinity) for any...
A rocket has length L with a separate head on top. The rocket lands in a cilinder on Earth with height L with speed v. From the point of view of the rocket, the cylinder undergoes a Lorentz contraction. The rocket will therefore collide with the bottom of the cilinder and damage it. From the...
Hello!
I'm starting to study curved QFT and am slightly confused about the invariance of the Klein Gordon Lagrangian under a linear diffeomorphism.
This is $$L=\sqrt{-g}\left(g^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu \phi \partial_\nu \phi-\frac{m^2}{2}\phi^2\right),$$
I don't see how ##g^{\mu\nu}\to...
Given what we know about special relativity and its implication for time and the observer, could this in any way be linked to why the isolated processes of QM are exhibiting everything happening at once and then collapsing to classical physics when bigger objects interact - the measurement...
In both Wald and Carroll, a type (k,l) tensor has k dual vectors and l vectors, yet a (1,0) tensor is a vector and a (0,1) tensor is a dual vector. I must be missing something simple. Please explain.
<Moderator’s note: a reference to an article published in a predatory journal has been removed. References on PF should be from the professional scientific literature or from other sources consistent with the professional scientific literature>
I read through many posting on various threads in...
In case you haven't heard, there is a new textbook on relativity to be published by Cambridge UP in 2022. It is compiled and edited by Coleman's three students Griffiths, Derbes, and Sohn who took Physics 210 relativity course at Harvard in the late 60's when Sidney was teaching it.
The book...
Initial observer is at rest. So ##x\prime=0##, and according to question they are 10 meter apart. So lorentz transformation becomes
##vt=x##
##v=\frac{x}{t}##
##=\frac{10 \\ \mathrm m}{13\times10^{-9} \mathrm s}##
But I don't get the expected answer. I believe if I had took ##\beta c## instead...
Hi, I´m trying to solve a special relativity problem, and I think I need some help. There are two inertial frames of reference, ##O## and ##O'##, the last one moving with relative velocity ##v## in the ##x## direction. There's a rod with length ##L'## fixed to frame ##O'##, such that front end...
I'm a female neurobiologist in my 60s with a lifelong passion for physics (but my math was not strong enough). I have a special interest in special relativity and a decent grasp of the basics. I can solve Lorenz calculations 'til the cows come home'. I don't need help with homework of any type...
> A particle of mass M at rest decays into two particles of masses m1 and m2 traveling in opposite directions at velocity v1 and v2 respectively. Express v2 in terms of v1, m1, m2, and M.
Since both objects are from a single object that's why I took relativistic mass of both objects are same. I...
This set of videos by eigenchris (separate playlists on Relativity and on Tensors) also looks interesting
and can help anyone interested in learning about these topics.
A while back I watched some of them and thought they could be helpful.
I like his presentation of one-forms.
(I've been...
I was browsing YouTube (again) and stumbled upon this set of lectures by Ta-Pei Cheng.
(I've seen the cover of the textbooks...
but I'm not familiar with the author-lecturer or the details of the texts... but this looks interesting.)
http://www.umsl.edu/~chengt/...
Summary:: Special relativity and Lorentz Transformations - I got this problem from a first-semester course at university. I have been struggling for a few days and decided to get some help.
A rocket sets out from x = x' = 0 at t = t' = 0 and moves with speed u in the negative x'-direction, as...
Andrzej Dragan ( https://www.fuw.edu.pl/~dragan/ )
has a "Course on relativity" on YouTube.
https://www.youtube.com/c/relaTVty/playlists
I'm not familiar with Dragan... but the videos display some flair and personality.
(...
I am new here, so pardon my ignorance.
First of all, I am aware of the impossibility to distinguish experimentally between SR (Special Relativity) and LET (Lorentz Ether Theory). I know there is a PF policy article on LET and the Block Universe.
I must admit though that LET is more appealing...
I recently noticed that "General Relativity: The Essentials" by Carlo Rovelli has been published. Based on the description, table of contents, and the Amazon reviews, it seems to me that it might be a spiritual successor to Dirac's "General Theory of Relativity." Is that an accurate assessment...
In a stressful situation, when you're thinking rapidly, time really does seem to slow down. Like "that was the longest 30 seconds of my life."
Since thinking is made up of the firing of action potentials in neurons, could those events, in the brain, work with relativity to slow down personal...
I was starting out some problems on force and motion at 10+2 level. I was told you don’t need to know about frame of reference. But I want to. So which books are there to understand frames? Is it a part of relativity? If yes then which books?
Thank you guys.
Considering an atom within a rigid body, does the angular momentum of an electron within the atom vary when the body is put in motion?
My intuition is that, whether considered in a classical sense or quantum sense, the speed of a given electron in its motion within an atom will be constant and...
In a recent thread, I said that if there was interest, I would post in a separate thread the calculations for the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the rod in the "rod and hole" relativity paradox discussed in that thread. Since there was interest, I am posting...
I am confused by the concept of space-time in special relativity, I have 3 spatial dimensions and 1 time dimensions. In Newtonian physics don't I also have 3 spatial dimensions and 1 time dimension? Then why call it space time in special relativity and not in Newtonian physics?
Einstein says ' we cannot whether it is true that only one line goes through two points' ' We can only say Euclidean Geometry deals with things called straight lines to each of which is ascribed the property of being uniquely determined by two points situated on it, - What does he mean? and...
A rigid rod with length ## l_0## slides on a smooth and flat tabletop along the length at speed of ## ~\frac {\sqrt{3}}{2}c~ ##, there is a hole of width ##~l_0~##on the table.
The observer who is stationary relative to the desktop thinks that the length of the rigid rod ##~ l=l_o...
From the section[5.1] of 'Homogeneity and Isotropy' from General Relativity by Robert M. Wald (pages 91-92, edition 1984) whatever I have understood is that -
##\Sigma_t## is a spacelike hypersurface for some fixed time ##t##. The hypersurface is homogeneous.
The metric of whole space is ##g##...
The way I was doing is that I list events
1. lightning hits x=0 this is (x_1=0,t_1)
2. lightning hits x=12 (x_2=12,t_2)
3. left lightning reaches "me" (x_3=9,t_3)
4. right lightning reaches "me" (x_4=9,t_4=t_3) t_4=t_3 since "I" see the lightning at the same time
Then the...
The twin paradox can be explained by changing reference frames. But I’m really curious how this paradox can be explained.
In the situation below there are three observers:
A: Standing at a moving train platform moving at a speed of c/2 relative to “the ground”.
B: Standing at a moving train...
I saw a book that uses special relativity to solve the twin paradox, the inference process is roughly as follows.
Suppose a spacecraft sets off from the Earth to travel to a distance black hole and then return to the earth. We divide this process into three stages, that is, the process of...
I believe this does not belong to the homework category. I hope I won't be mistaken.
I am reading a book to self-study special relativity, the following is an example mentioned in the book.
When clock C' and clock C1 meet at times t'=t1=0, both clocks read zero. The Observer in reference frame...
Posed question is that a comment plunges into Jupiter. Same time as my physics class starts on Earth. My friend is traveling towards Jupiter at a significant percentage of c. Would the person in spaceship say that the comment collision occurred before, after or as class started?
My answer: same...
I was discussing in another page this topic with someone. He said it's relative in everything, meaning that energy and force doesn't count. This is obviously wrong because the fact that today we can't (maybe tomorrow we can) know which thing is moving towards the other and which not, doesn't...
Dear readers,
Maybe someone can enlighten me on the understanding of the proof given by the Michelson–Morley experiment on the special relativity.
Just as introduction to detail the setting: There are 2 coordinate systems A and B. A stands still and B moves with the velocity v along one of...
Does time dilation in Special Relativity relate to the Doppler effect? If you move near the speed of light you experience time differently and the sound is stretched. Are these similar phenomenon?
Hi all,
What I notice is that there's a significant difference in style between the GR texts and the other textbooks. In particular, GR texts very much try hard to read like a math textbooks, emphasizing theorems and abstract definitions, which I'm not sure are practically useful (though...
Some introduction books on Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics use classical mechanics as the theoretical framework, and when it come to special relativity it goes back to the basics and force language again. I would like to ask for some recommendations on good books that introduces Lagrangian...
I'd like to get some help on checking my understanding of special relativity, specifically I'm trying to clarify the idea of coordinates. Any comment is really appreciated!
The spacetime is an affine space ##M^4##, which is associated with a 4 dimensional real vector space ##\mathbb{R}^4##...