Are You Ready to Test Your Mind with 20Q?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Aether
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cool Game
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the game "20Q," where participants think of an object and respond to a series of questions posed by an AI to guess what the object is. The scope includes personal experiences with the game, the accuracy of the AI's guesses, and the nature of the questions asked during the game.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants report that the AI guessed their objects correctly after a varying number of questions, with one participant noting it took 25 questions to identify a plastic water bottle.
  • Others share their experiences with the AI guessing more unusual objects, such as a penis and a black hole, highlighting the AI's ability to navigate complex or abstract concepts.
  • Participants express confusion or amusement regarding some of the AI's questions, describing them as strange or contradictory, particularly when the AI's guesses seemed off-base.
  • One participant mentions that the AI identified a "woman" after a series of questions, which led to a humorous reflection on the AI's reasoning process.
  • Several participants note that the AI's guesses sometimes included contradictions, leading to discussions about the nature of the questions and the AI's logic.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that the AI is capable of making accurate guesses, but there is no consensus on the appropriateness or logic of some of the questions it asks. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the effectiveness of the AI's reasoning process.

Contextual Notes

Some participants mention specific contradictions in the AI's questioning, indicating a potential limitation in its logic or understanding of the objects being guessed. There are also references to the subjective nature of some answers, which may depend on individual interpretations.

Aether
Gold Member
Messages
714
Reaction score
2
http://20q.net/

Think of an object, and then answer 20 questions about it while the AI software tries to guess what you're thinking of. The software will guess right most of the time.

You can also buy a handheld version of this game.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It took 25 questions to guess my object.

---------
Q25. I am guessing that it is plastic?
Right, Wrong, Close
24. Can you use it to hit something? Yes.
23. I guessed that it was a ceiling tile? Wrong.
22. Does it come from trees? No.
21. Can it be painted? Yes.
20. I guessed that it was a tissue box? Wrong.
19. Is it brown? No.
18. Does it come from something larger? No.
17. Is it green or black? No.
16. Does it fold up easily? No.
15. Is it delivered? Sometimes.
14. Do you put things in it? Depends.
13. Can you recycle it? Yes.
12. Is it printed? No.
11. Is it red? Rarely.
10. Is it decorative? Maybe.
9. Is it something that you build? Rarely.
8. Does it burn? Yes.
7. Would you eat it? No.
6. Do you use it when it rains? Sometimes.
5. Can you find it in a church? Irrelevant.
4. Can you control it? Depends.
3. Is it used for entertainment? Rarely.
2. Does it usually have four corners? Sometimes.
1. It is classified as Other.
-------My object was a Plastic Water Bottle. I felt that the Plastic guess was sufficient.edit...

This thing is quite good! I chose Penis as my next object, and it got it!

----
Q20. I am guessing that it is a urethra?
Right, Wrong, Close
19. Can you see it in a zoo? No.
18. Does it go in your mouth? Sometimes.
17. I guessed that it was a muscle (body part)? Close.
16. Can it be chewed? Depends.
15. Is it striped? Rarely.
14. Does it stink? Sometimes.
13. Is it originally from Australia? Sometimes.
12. Will it point out the right way? Yes.
11. Is it alive? Yes.
10. Does it get hard? Yes.
9. Can you play games with it? Yes.
8. Is it inorganic? No.
7. Do you carry it in your pocket? Rarely.
6. Can it blink? No.
5. Does it have a hole in it? Yes.
4. Can you find it in a church? Yes.
3. Is it human powered? Yes.
2. Do you use it at night? Usually.
1. It is classified as Other.
-----

It told me there were some contradictions, and I guess it would be right, but some of the questions are weird to answer.
 
Last edited:
Got mine in 25 too ...
Q25. I am guessing that it is seaweed?
Right, Wrong, Close
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
24. Does it fold up easily? Yes.
23. Does it break if dropped? No.
22. Does it grow on trees? No.
21. Can it be washed? Yes.
20. I guessed that it was a grape? Wrong.
19. Can you play with it? No.
18. I guessed that it was a caper (bud of the caper bush)? Wrong.
17. Is it made in many different styles? No.
16. Can it be used to season foods? Maybe.
Are there many different sorts of it? Unknown.
Does it come in many varieties? Unknown.
15. Does it come in different colours? Yes.
14. Is it man made? No.
13. Can it be dried? Yes.
12. Is it normally planted in gardens? No.
11. Would you find it on a farm? No.
10. Would you use it in a garden? No.
9. Is it found on a desk? No.
8. Is it smooth? Yes.
7. Is it red? No.
6. Will it eat almost anything? Doubtful.
5. Can you peel it? No.
4. Can you find it in a house? Yes.
3. Is it usually green? Yes.
2. Is it crunchy? No.
1. It is classified as Vegetable.
 
It took 30 questions to get TV Remote.
 
Q17. I am guessing that it is a piece of paper?
Right, Wrong, Close

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16. Does it come from something larger? Yes.
15. Does it come from a plant? Yes.
14. Does it have cash value? Yes.
13. Do you make something with it? Sometimes.
12. Can you find it in a church? Probably.
11. Do you write on it? Yes.
10. Do you love it? No.
9. Can you use it as money? Probably.
8. Do you use it at night? Sometimes.
7. Does it have a cable? No.
6. Is it an emotion? No.
5. Does it have pages? No.
4. Does it fold up easily? Yes.
3. Can you read it? Yes.
2. Is it square shaped? Sometimes.
1. It is classified as Other.
It was correct. It said that my contradiction was that you don't use paper at night
 
I had some fun with this over the summer

and by the way, holy sh*t

Q17. I am guessing that it is a black hole?
Right, Wrong, Close
16. Would you wear it on your wedding day? No.
15. Is it a rodent? No.
14. Does it purr? No.
13. Does it grow over time? Depends.
12. Is it transparent? No.
11. Is it an abstract concept? Partly.
10. Does it come from space? Yes.
9. Is it commonly used? Irrelevant.
8. Is it colorless? Yes.
7. Have you seen one in real life? No.
6. Can it cry? No.
5. Can you touch it? No.
Is it independent? Unknown.
4. Does it come in specific sizes? No.
3. Can you control it? No.
2. Is it used for entertainment? No.
1. It is classified as Other.


it was correct o.o

btw, I messed up on some questions and it still got it o.o
 
moose said:
Q17. I am guessing that it is a black hole?
16. Would you wear it on your wedding day? No.
15. Is it a rodent? No.
14. Does it purr? No.
...
10. Does it come from space? Yes.
Let's see, does it come from space? Yes.
Hmm, does it purr? No...
Hmmn, is it a rodent? Noo...
Hmmnn, Would you wear it on your weddding day? Nooo...
Oh, I guess that it must be a black hole then...
 
Aether said:
Let's see, does it come from space? Yes.
Hmm, does it purr? No...
Hmmn, is it a rodent? Noo...
Hmmnn, Would you wear it on your weddding day? Nooo...
Oh, I guess that it must be a black hole then...
:smile: I was wondering the same thing. Some of the questions this thing asks are a tad strange.
 
WOW!

I messed with the thing for quite a while. Then I did this:
Of course question 29 was right. But jeez it thought I was thinking of a fool? What kind of artificial intelligence is this? LOL BTW, please don't pick my answers apart. I would have said the same thing about a man on #14. As for #11 I would have also said the same thing about a man. I mean I wasn't thinking of security guard right?

Q29. I am guessing that it is a woman?
Right, Wrong, Close

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
28. Is it used for communications? No.
27. Is it colorful? No.
26. I guessed that it was a child? Wrong.
25. Is it tall? Sometimes.
24. Is it made in many different styles? Yes.
23. Can it add? Yes.
22. Is it used in a sport? No.
21. Does it perform? Sometimes.
20. I guessed that it was a magician? Wrong.
19. I guessed that it was a fool? Wrong.
18. Can it run fast? Maybe.
17. Is it bad for your health? No.
16. Does it like to run? Maybe.
15. Can you play games with it? Yes.
14. Is it a lazy animal? Sometimes.
13. Can you find it in a house? Yes.
12. Does it bite? Sometimes.
11. Does it provide protection? No.
10. Can it help you find your way? No.
9. Does it play music? No.
8. Is it awake at night? Sometimes.
7. Does it have a long tail? No.
6. Is it a conductive element? No.
5. Does it stand on two legs? Yes.
4. Does it have teeth? Yes.
3. Is it bigger than sofa? No.
2. Does it have paws? No.
1. It is classified as Animal.
 
Last edited:
  • #10
I'm impressed.

Q28. I am guessing that it is nothing?
Right, Wrong, Close

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
27. Do you look at it? No.
26. Is it inorganic? Irrelevant.
25. Can any age group use it? Irrelevant.
24. Was it ever alive? No.
23. Is it dangerous? No.
22. Is it usually warm? No.
21. Is it comforting? No.
20. I guessed that it was infinity? Close.
19. Is it a part of something larger? No.
18. I guessed that it was an electron? Wrong.
17. Can you read it? No.
16. Does it grow over time? No.
15. Does it come in many varieties? No.
14. Can you find it in a church? Sometimes.
13. Does it make noise? No.
12. Can you find it in a house? Sometimes.
11. Is it lumpy? No.
10. Do you use it in public? No.
9. Does it stink? No.
8. Does it come in a pack? No.
7. Is it water-based? No.
6. Is it an insect? No.
5. Does it have cash value? No.
4. Is it a specific color? No.
3. Is it lifeless? Yes.
2. Is it colorful? Irrelevant.
1. Do you use it at night? Irrelevant.
It is classified as Unknown.
 
  • #11
Q17. I am guessing that it is a cadaver?
Right, Wrong, Close
16. Is it tall? Sometimes.
15. Is it multicoloured? Yes.
14. Is it commonly used? No.
13. Can it bend without breaking? Yes.
12. Can you lift it? Yes.
11. Is it smooth? No.
10. Does it make noise? No.
9. Can you see it in a zoo? No.
8. Does it weigh more than a duck? Yes.
7. Is it smaller than a loaf of bread? No.
6. Will it point out the right way? No.
5. Does it live in salt-water? No.
4. Can it climb? No.
3. Does it have hooves? No.
2. Can it scratch? No.
1. It is classified as Animal.

How does it guess these??
 
  • #12
Ok DeadWolfe were you really thinking cadaver?

It guesses them based on pre-loaded criteria I would imagine. Every time someone plays it it adjusts that criteria. So we can make it as dumb or as smart as we want it to be. I wonder if only ONE person played it over and over and over and over for like years, what kind of profile would we have about this person? Makes you wonder if it is part of something larger. Considering that it is possible to record IP addresses and what not, maybe we are all being profiled. Oh well, they won't find much out about me other than that I have a dirty mind. I tried using different body parts, sex toys, etc. and all it ever said was that I was thinking of something to do with sex and to get my mind out of the gutter.
 
  • #13
Yes I was. I was trying to think of something that would be too strange to guess.
 
  • #14
Hey this could be perfect for buying Presents. Ask a person 20-30 questions and you will know what they want!
 
  • #15
mattmns said:
Hey this could be perfect for buying Presents. Ask a person 20-30 questions and you will know what they want!

Lol, I actually did this earlier.

My mom was asking me what I wanted, but I didn't want to tell her exactly what. So she got clueless, and then I went onto the 20q thing and it said "books"...
 
  • #16
pph, it doesn't have ambition, magnetic monopoles or LEGO stored in it's database - appaling!:rolleyes:
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 131 ·
5
Replies
131
Views
9K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
35
Views
10K