MHB 215 AP Calculus Exam Problem Power Rule

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on finding the derivative of the function y=(x^3-cos x)^5 using the power and chain rules. The correct derivative is identified as y'=5(x^3-cos x)^4(3x^2+sin x), which corresponds to option (E) but contains a sign error and a missing square in the second factor. Participants emphasize the importance of careful observation in multiple-choice settings to avoid unnecessary calculations. The conversation highlights common mistakes students make when interpreting derivative problems. Overall, the focus is on accurately applying calculus rules to solve the problem efficiently.
karush
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,240
Reaction score
5
If $y=(x^3-cos x)^5$, then $y'=$(A) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4$(B) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$(C) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$(D) $\quad 5(x^3+\sin x)^4(6x+\cos x)$(E) $\quad 5(x^3+\cos x)^4(3x+\sin x)$
The Power Rule

$\displaystyle{d\over dx}x^n = nx^{n-1}$

by observation we know the derivative of the inside is multiplied to the outside
thus this leaves option (E) the other steps probably are not necessary

ok I am sure this could be worded better. but I think many students take these tests and are not used multiple choice and just plunge into timely calculations when observation could be within a few seconds
 
Physics news on Phys.org
$$y'=5(x^3-\cos x)^4(3x^2+\sin x)$$
 
Last edited:
karush said:
If $y=(x^3-cos x)^5$, then $y'=$(A) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4$(B) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$(C) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$(D) $\quad 5(x^3+\sin x)^4(6x+\cos x)$(E) $\quad 5(x^3+\cos x)^4(3x+\sin x)$
The Power Rule

$\displaystyle{d\over dx}x^n = nx^{n-1}$

by observation we know the derivative of the inside is multiplied to the outside
thus this leaves option (E) the other steps probably are not necessary

ok I am sure this could be worded better. but I think many students take these tests and are not used multiple choice and just plunge into timely calculations when observation could be within a few seconds

Choice (E) is closest to being correct, but as you typed it, has a sign error in the first variable factor and is missing a square in the second.
It's not just the power rule alone, it's also an application of the chain rule.

$\dfrac{d}{dx} u^n = nu^{n-1} \cdot \dfrac{du}{dx}$

$y = (x^3-\cos{x})^5 \implies y'=5(x^3-\cos{x})^4 (3x^2 + \sin{x})$
 
If $y=(x^3-cos x)^5$, then $y'=$

(A) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4$

(B) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$

(C) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$

(D) $\quad 5(x^3+\sin x)^4(6x+\cos x)$

(E) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4(3x+\sin x)$
The ChainRule
$\displaystyle \dfrac{d}{dx}u^n = nu^{n-1} \cdot \dfrac{du}{dx}$
so
$y = (x^3-\cos{x})^5 \implies y'=5(x^3-\cos{x})^4 (3x^2 + \sin{x})\quad (E)$
hopefully
 
karush said:
If $y=(x^3-cos x)^5$, then $y'=$

(A) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4$

(B) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$

(C) $\quad 5(3x^2+\sin x)^4$

(D) $\quad 5(x^3+\sin x)^4(6x+\cos x)$

(E) $\quad 5(x^3-\cos x)^4(3x+\sin x)$
The ChainRule
$\displaystyle \dfrac{d}{dx}u^n = nu^{n-1} \cdot \dfrac{du}{dx}$
so
$y = (x^3-\cos{x})^5 \implies y'=5(x^3-\cos{x})^4 (3x^2 + \sin{x})\quad (E)$
hopefully


you forgot the square in the $\dfrac{du}{dx}$ factor ... again.
 
where ?
 
karush said:
where ?
Look at answer key for E). It should be a [math]3x^2[/math], not 3x.

-Dan
 
got it
thanks