5 blocks suspended from ceiling -- What are the tensions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ocata
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Blocks
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
6 replies · 2K views
Ocata
Messages
198
Reaction score
5

Homework Statement



5 blocks connected by strings of negligible masses are suspended from a ceiling by a string of negligible mass. The strings and masses in order from bottom to top are M1, S1, M2, S2, M3, S3, M4, S4, M5, S5

M1 = 2kg
M2 = 1kg
M3 = 1kg
M4 = 2kg
M5 = 10kg

What are the tensions on S1, S2, S3, S4 and S5?

Homework Equations



F=ma

The Attempt at a Solution



Net Force is 0 because the system isn't accelerating.

T_1 = (m_1)a = 2kg(g) = 19.6N
T_2 = (m_1)a + (m_2)a = 2kg+1kg(g) = 29.4N
T_3 = (m_1)a + (m_2)a + (m_3)a = 2kg+1kg(g) + 1kg(g) = 39.2N
T_4 = (m_1)a + (m_2)a + (m_3)a + (m_4)a = 2kg + 1kg(g) + 1kg(g) + 2kg(g) = 58.8N
T_5 = (m_1)a + (m_2)a + (m_3)a + (m_4)a + (m_5)a = 2kg + 1kg(g) + 1kg(g) + 2kg(g) + 10kg(g) = 156N


Supposing this is correct, if we treat all the blocks as one system, the force vector upward from M_5 pointing toward the ceiling and the force vector downward from M_1 pointing toward the ground would both be 156N, yes?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ocata said:
Supposing this is correct, if we treat all the blocks as one system, the force vector upward from M_5 pointing toward the ceiling and the force vector downward from M_1 pointing toward the ground would both be 156N, yes?
Well, in an extended-mass system (as opposed to a point-mass system), where does the force vector of gravity act?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ocata
Ocata said:
...

Supposing this is correct, if we treat all the blocks as one system, the force vector upward from M_5 pointing toward the ceiling and the force vector downward from M_1 pointing toward the ground would both be 156N, yes?
You have a system hanging from the ceiling. There is no M1 or M5 .

The ceiling exerts a force upward on the system. The system exerts a force downward on the ceiling .
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ocata
SammyS said:
You have a system hanging from the ceiling. There is no M1 or M5 .

The ceiling exerts a force upward on the system. The system exerts a force downward on the ceiling .
Oh, I think I see. Considering the system as a whole, the force of 156N points downwards from the bottom of the system and the force of 156N upwards is from the force of the ceiling on the top string, yes?

By the way, I am guessing the values for the individual tension are correct?
 
Additionally, I am interested is specifying the tension values and uploaded a diagram of this problem and would like to know if the tension values (T) at each connection point is correct.
 

Attachments

  • Tension c.JPG
    Tension c.JPG
    21 KB · Views: 448
Ocata said:
Additionally, I am interested is specifying the tension values and uploaded a diagram of this problem and would like to know if the tension values (T) at each connection point is correct.
Yes, your tension values are correct.

The image is virtually impossible to read. -- very "washed-out" appearance.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ocata
Thank you SammyS,

I'll definitely make the contrast darker when I scan next time, thanks.

Regards