A stone is thrown off a bridge....

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a stone thrown off a bridge that is 40 meters above water, landing 48 meters from the bridge's base. The stone is thrown with an initial velocity of 15 m/s at an angle of 30 degrees above the horizontal. The question posed is about determining the maximum height the stone reaches above the water.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of the stone's x and y-components of velocity and the time of flight. There are attempts to apply various kinematic equations to solve for the final vertical velocity and maximum height. Some participants express frustration over not arriving at the expected answer and question the validity of the equations used.

Discussion Status

Several participants are exploring different interpretations of the equations and their components. There is a recognition of potential misunderstandings regarding the application of the equations, particularly concerning the acceleration components and their meanings. Some guidance is offered regarding the need to clarify the definitions of variables used in the equations.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the problem's parameters must be compatible for a valid solution, and there is concern about the accuracy of the equations provided by the instructor. The discussion reflects a mix of confusion and attempts to clarify the problem setup and the relationships between the variables involved.

DracoMalfoy
Messages
88
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


A stone is thrown off of a bridge that is 40m above the water. The stone lands 48m from the base of the bridge. The stone was thrown with an initial velocity of 15m at 30 degrees above the horizontal.

What is the maximum height the stone reaches above the water? (ans:42.87m)

Homework Equations


  • Vfx=VicosΘ
  • Δx=vicosΘ(t)
  • Vfy=(VicosΘ)+ay(t)
  • Δy=(VisinΘ)(t)+1/2(ay)(t)
  • (Vfy)^2=(VisinΘ)^2+2(ay)(Δy)
  • Δy=1/2(Vfy+(VisinΘ))(t)
[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


ax:13
ay:7.5
Δy:40m
Δx:48m[/B]

I found the x and y-components. Ax:15cos30=13 and Ay:15sin30=7.5.

Then I tried to find the time using the second equation and got 3.69s.

I've been trying to solve for vfy... and I've done everything. I'm not getting that answer. I don't know why I can't understand how to do this. it's frustrating... I even tried to draw it on an axis.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
DracoMalfoy said:

Homework Statement


A stone is thrown off of a bridge that is 40m above the water. The stone lands 48m from the base of the bridge. The stone was thrown with an initial velocity of 15m at 30 degrees above the horizontal.

What is the maximum height the stone reaches above the water? (ans:42.87m)

Homework Equations


[/B]


    • Vfx=VicosΘ
    • Δx=vicosΘ(t)
    • Vfy=(VicosΘ)+ay(t)
    • Δy=(VisinΘ)(t)+1/2(ay)(t)
    • (Vfy)^2=(VisinΘ)^2+2(ay)(Δy)
    • Δy=1/2(Vfy+(VisinΘ))(t)

The Attempt at a Solution


ax:13
ay:7.5
Δy:40m
Δx:48m[/B]

I found the x and y-components. Ax:15cos30=13 and Ay:15sin30=7.5.

Then I tried to find the time using the second equation and got 3.69s.

I've been trying to solve for vfy... and I've done everything. I'm not getting that answer. I don't know why I can't understand how to do this. it's frustrating... I even tried to draw it on an axis.

IMHO, some of your equations make no sense; go back to the textbook and look up correct formulas (or go on-line if you do not have a good textbook). Almost all of these types of problems are clones of each other, so once you have done one or two of them you should be able to deal with new ones quickly and efficiently.

What does ##ay## stand for? Why is it equal to 7.5? How and why do you use information about ##x## and/or ##\Delta x## in this problem?
 
Ray Vickson said:
IMHO, some of your equations make no sense; go back to the textbook and look up correct formulas (or go on-line if you do not have a good textbook). Almost all of these types of problems are clones of each other, so once you have done one or two of them you should be able to deal with new ones quickly and efficiently.

What does ##ay## stand for? Why is it equal to 7.5? How and why do you use information about ##x## and/or ##\Delta x## in this problem?
How are the equations wrong? my teacher gave us those. :oldfrown: Δx is the distance that it lands away from the bridge. Δy is the height that its thrown from. I guess that ay and ax are the coordinates?
 
DracoMalfoy said:
How are the equations wrong? my teacher gave us those. :oldfrown: Δx is the distance that it lands away from the bridge. Δy is the height that its thrown from. I guess that ay and ax are the coordinates?

You wrote ##a_x## and ##a_y##, so presumably you know what they mean. I have no prior idea what they stand for.

I could guess that ##a_y## means the y-component of acceleration, since you earlier wrote ##Vf_y = V_i \cos(\theta) + a_y t ,## meaning that the y-component of velocity depends linearly on ##t## with coefficient ##a_y.## Then you go on to say that ##a_y = 7.5,## which could only be true on a much, much smaller planet than Earth, with a much weaker gravitational force. You also say that the initial y-velocity is ##V_i \cos(\theta)##, which cannot possibly be true (if, as you also wrote, the x-component of initial velocity is ##V_i \cos(\theta).## Below that, you claim that ##\Delta y = V_i \sin(\theta) t + \frac{1}{2} a_y t,## and that is false.

I really hope your teacher did not give you the equations exactly as you wrote them.
 
DracoMalfoy said:

Homework Statement


A stone is thrown off of a bridge that is 40m above the water. The stone lands 48m from the base of the bridge. The stone was thrown with an initial velocity of 15m at 30 degrees above the horizontal.

What is the maximum height the stone reaches above the water? (ans:42.87m)

Homework Equations


[/B]


    • Vfx=VicosΘ
    • Δx=vicosΘ(t)
    • Vfy=(VicosΘ)+ay(t)
    • Δy=(VisinΘ)(t)+1/2(ay)(t)
    • (Vfy)^2=(VisinΘ)^2+2(ay)(Δy)
    • Δy=1/2(Vfy+(VisinΘ))(t)

The Attempt at a Solution


ax:13
ay:7.5
Δy:40m
Δx:48m[/B]

I found the x and y-components. Ax:15cos30=13 and Ay:15sin30=7.5.

Then I tried to find the time using the second equation and got 3.69s.

I've been trying to solve for vfy... and I've done everything. I'm not getting that answer. I don't know why I can't understand how to do this. it's frustrating... I even tried to draw it on an axis.

Not quite sure either of us know what symbols you are using, but when you state
"I found the x and y-components. Ax:15cos30=13 and Ay:15sin30=7.5."
I can say that those two values you have calculated are the horizontal and vertical components of the launch velocity.

Note: if anyone piece of the original information values (48, 40, 15, 30) was deleted, the problem could still be solved. I hope that who ever set the problem made sure that the 4 values are compatible (can all be correct).
If you did not know the 48m answer, the "Ay" value, plus the 40m high bridge would enable you to calculate when the stone will land, then using the "Ax" value you have you could calculate how far away the stone lands - and I just hope that answer is 48 or the whole problem has 4 different answers - one corresponding to the case where the initial values are each "ignored" one at a time.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K