Action-Reaction Forces (Simple Problems)

  • Thread starter Thread starter rwishka
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Forces
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around identifying action-reaction force pairs in various scenarios, specifically involving a hockey stick and puck, a falling leaf, and a basketball player's jump. The subject area is Newton's laws of motion, particularly focusing on the third law regarding action and reaction forces.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants express confusion regarding the identification of action-reaction pairs and the forces involved in the scenarios presented. Some suggest interpretations of the problems, while others question their understanding of the underlying principles of Newton's laws.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided insights into Newton's third law and its implications for the scenarios, particularly regarding the forces exerted by the floor on the basketball player. However, there remains a lack of consensus on the correct answers to the initial questions, and further clarification is sought by multiple participants.

Contextual Notes

Participants are grappling with the definitions and applications of action-reaction pairs, and there is an indication that some may be misunderstanding the relationships between the forces involved in the scenarios. The original poster expresses a need for assistance in understanding these concepts.

rwishka
Messages
16
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



I promise - my last set of questions.

1. A hockey stick hits a puck on the ice. Identify an action-reaction pair, and compare the forces exerted by each object.

a. The stick exerts a force on the puck; the puck exerts a force on the stick.
b. The stick exerts a force on the puck; the puck exerts a force on the ice.
c. The puck exerts a force on the stick; the stick exerts a force on the ice.
d. The stick exerts a force on the ice; the ice exerts a force on the puck.

2. A leaf falls from a tree and lands on the sidewalk. Identify an action-reaction pair, and compare the forces exerted by each object.

a. The tree exerts a force on the leaf; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
b. The leaf exerts a force on the sidewalk; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
c. The leaf exerts a force on the tree; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
d. The leaf exerts a force on the sidewalk; the tree exerts a force on the leaf.

3. As a basketball player starts to jump for a rebound, the player begins to move upward faster and faster until his shoes leave the floor. During the time that the player is in contact with the floor, the force of the floor on the shoes is:

a. greater than the player's weight.
b. equal in magnitude and opposite in direction to the player's weight.
c. less than the player's weight.
d. zero

Homework Equations



None

The Attempt at a Solution



As you can see, I have trouble understanding these type of problems.

1. Would it be B, for isn't it like a chain reaction?
2. Would it be c, because the leaf will fall, and the sidewalk's force will make it stay for the time.
3. I think it would be either c or d, because if it was greater than the player's weight, he wouldn't jump, right?

I may be completely off, but I really need help with this! Please. :eek:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Does no one know how to do these? I really need to know how soon! Please kindly help me.
 
rwishka said:

Homework Statement



I promise - my last set of questions.

1. A hockey stick hits a puck on the ice. Identify an action-reaction pair, and compare the forces exerted by each object.

a. The stick exerts a force on the puck; the puck exerts a force on the stick.
b. The stick exerts a force on the puck; the puck exerts a force on the ice.
c. The puck exerts a force on the stick; the stick exerts a force on the ice.
d. The stick exerts a force on the ice; the ice exerts a force on the puck.

2. A leaf falls from a tree and lands on the sidewalk. Identify an action-reaction pair, and compare the forces exerted by each object.

a. The tree exerts a force on the leaf; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
b. The leaf exerts a force on the sidewalk; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
c. The leaf exerts a force on the tree; the sidewalk exerts a force on the leaf.
d. The leaf exerts a force on the sidewalk; the tree exerts a force on the leaf.

3. As a basketball player starts to jump for a rebound, the player begins to move upward faster and faster until his shoes leave the floor. During the time that the player is in contact with the floor, the force of the floor on the shoes is:

a. greater than the player's weight.
b. equal in magnitude and opposite in direction to the player's weight.
c. less than the player's weight.
d. zero

Homework Equations



None

The Attempt at a Solution



As you can see, I have trouble understanding these type of problems.

1. Would it be B, for isn't it like a chain reaction?
2. Would it be c, because the leaf will fall, and the sidewalk's force will make it stay for the time.
3. I think it would be either c or d, because if it was greater than the player's weight, he wouldn't jump, right?

I may be completely off, but I really need help with this! Please. :eek:
You're way off. For action-reaction pairs, Newton's 3rd law states that if an object A exerts a force on object B, then object B must exert a force on object A, that is equal in magnitude, but opposite in direction. For your last question, if the jumper moves faster and faster during the time he is in contact with the floor, he must be accelearting during that period. What does Newton 2 tell you about or bodies that are accelerating??
 
So would it be greater than the player's weight, as it is inversely proportional?? I think I have this all mixed up.
 
rwishka said:
So would it be greater than the player's weight, as it is inversely proportional?? I think I have this all mixed up.
Well, it will be greater, on account of Newton 2: there must be a net force acting on the jumper in order for her to accelerate in the direction of the net force. Since her weight always acts down , the floor must push up with a force greater than her weight, in order for there to be a net force acting up to accelearte her off the floor.
 
I see. Can you help me with the other ones please?
 
rwishka said:
I see. Can you help me with the other ones please?
Gee, I thought i did. If a stick exerts a force on a puck, the puck exerts an equal force on the stick, in the opposite direction. These are force pairs per Newton 3. Sure there are forces of the ice on the puck, or the stick on the ice, but the problem is not asking about these. It asks for the action-reaction pairs to be chosen from the given choices.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
7K