Aeroplane follows circular trajectory-Tension? (geometry)

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
Const@ntine
Messages
285
Reaction score
18

Homework Statement



So, I have this problem here that's pretty basic, but the solution manual sets different axes, and I'm having a bit of trouble understanding the geometry part, meaning how he applies the given forces to the new axes.

A model airplane of mass 0.750 kg fl ies with a speed of 35.0 ms in a horizontal circle at the end of a 60.0 m control wire. The forces exerted on the airplane are shown in Figure P6.63: the tension in the control wire, the gravitational force, and aerodynamic lift that acts at θ = 20.0° inward from the vertical. Compute the tension in the wire, assuming it makes a constant angle of 20.0° with the horizontal.First of all, here's the main pic:

Free-body diagram of a model airplane on a circular path: lift F_lift and weight F_g vertical, tension T along the control wire, each at 20 degrees from the vertical or horizontal.


Homework Equations



It's the geometry part that gives me trouble.

The Attempt at a Solution



He finds the radius of the circular trajectory that the plane follows:

The radius of the circle of motion is (60.0 m) cos 20.0° = 56.4 m


No trouble here, we just take the direction of T as the hypotenouse and going with cosθ = r/l finds the radius.

Then there's this:

Solution text setting axes: x along the 20.0 degree direction of tension, y along lift; a_cx = a_c cos(20 degrees); sum of Fx = m a_x gives T + F_g sin 20.0 = m a_cx; solving for T and computing T = 12.8 N.

English is not my native language, so I'm not sure whether he means that x and y are the crossed lines, or the lines that "fall on top" the directions of T & F respectively. From the test I'm getting the latter, but if I try to apply the usual cosx = adjacent/hypotenouse and sinx = opposite/hypotenouse, I can't figure out how he gets his results.

I'd appreciate some help!

PS: I know this isn't exactly a "problem" with statements and such, but it's only this part that troubles me, and I didn't know where else to post it.
 
Darthkostis said:
I'm not sure whether he means that x and y are the crossed lines, or the lines that "fall on top" the directions of T & F respectively.
The book defines x as at 20 degrees to the horizontal, along the line of the tether. Correspondingly, y is at 20 degrees to the vertical, along the line of the lift force.
Please clarify where you have difficulty with the resulting equations.
 
haruspex said:
The book defines x as at 20 degrees to the horizontal, along the line of the tether. Correspondingly, y is at 20 degrees to the vertical, along the line of the lift force.
Please clarify where you have difficulty with the resulting equations.

How he gets that Fgx = Fg*sin(20) & acx = ac*cos(20). I know that he uses the formulas of cosine and sine, but I can't figure out how he gets these particular results.
 
Darthkostis said:
How he gets that Fgx = Fg*sin(20) & acx = ac*cos(20). I know that he uses the formulas of cosine and sine, but I can't figure out how he gets these particular results.
What would you calculate for the component of Fg in the x direction?
 
haruspex said:
What would you calculate for the component of Fg in the x direction?

I worked at it again and realized I was looking at it wrong. The new axes confused me and I lost my train of thought. If I'm not mistaken, it should look something like this:

Handwritten force diagrams on paper: a left diagram with forces F, T and Fg and angle theta, an arrow, then a rotated diagram marked vertical with components Fgx and Fgy, and below, derivation sin theta = Fgx/Fg giving Fgx = Fg sin theta and cos theta = acy/ac.


I go by the previous x & y axes, I take the directions the acceleration and Fg had on them, and then I create a net force based on the new axes. Correct? (there might be a misconception or two in my wording, but I'm still trying to get the hang of the english scientific terms).
 
Darthkostis said:
I worked at it again and realized I was looking at it wrong. The new axes confused me and I lost my train of thought. If I'm not mistaken, it should look something like this:

Handwritten physics working on a sheet of paper: a diagram of a force F and tension T at an angle θ from vertical, with Fg labelled, a second diagram with components Fgx and Fgy, and equations including cosθ = acv/ac and sinθ = Fgx/Fg giving Fgx = Fg sinθ.


I go by the previous x & y axes, I take the directions the acceleration and Fg had on them, and then I create a net force based on the new axes. Correct? (there might be a misconception or two in my wording, but I'm still trying to get the hang of the english scientific terms).
Yes, that looks right. At least, I see you now get Fgx=Fgsin(θ). Is the rest ok now?
 
haruspex said:
Yes, that looks right. At least, I see you now get F[SUBgx][/SUB]=Fgsin(θ). Is the rest ok now?

Yeah, that was the only part I had trouble with, not with the formulas themselves. I've got the acceleration vectors on the left as well, so that's all.

Thanks for taking the time!