Aether equal to spacetime?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter quark69
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Spacetime
15 replies · 3K views · last reply
quark69
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
I’m wondering if the thought of the eather from early physics is equal to the the spacetime we now today?
None, just a thought
 
No, it was supposed to be a material filling all of space. Like a gas, basically.

Experiment chipped away at the properties it could have until we were left with the Lorentz ether that has no properties except its existence. This version of the ether is simply special relativity with an undetectable (even in principle) ether that doesn't actually do anything, so it got dropped as a concept.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: quark69 and Dale
The basic principle behind the theory of ether was that there was such a thing as "absolute 0 velocity" - and that the speed of light was relative to that speed. So, if the sun was motionless, with Earth orbiting it, then we should see light apparently moving faster when Earth was moving "down stream" and slower when we were moving "upstream".

But no such difference could be found. Several possible "fixes" were theorized in an attempt to explain this.
Then Einstein introduced Special Relativity which eliminated this absolute reference (the ether).
 
quark69 said:
I’m wondering if the thought of the eather from early physics is equal to the the spacetime we now today?
The word 'ether' has had several meanings throughout the history of science. For example, regarding your question, look at what Einstein wrote in his book 'Sidelights on Relativity' (1920):

But on the other hand there is a weighty argument to be adduced in favour of the ether hypothesis. To deny the ether is ultimately to assume that empty space has no physical qualities whatever. The fundamental facts of mechanics do not harmonize with this view. For the mechanical behaviour of a corporeal system hovering freely in empty space depends not only on relative positions (distances) and relative velocities, but also on its state of rotation, which physically may be taken as a characteristic not appertaining to the system in itself. In orderto be able to look upon the rotation of the system, at least formally, as something real, Newton objectivises space. Since he classes his absolute space together with real things, for him rotation relative to an absolute space is also something real. Newton might no less well have called his absolute space " Ether " ; what is essential is merely that besides observable objects, another thing, which is not perceptible, must be looked upon as real, to enable acceleration or rotation to be looked upon as something real.

It is true that Mach tried to avoid having to accept as real something which is not observable by endeavouring to substitute in mechanics a mean acceleration with reference to the totality of the masses in the universe in place of an acceleration with reference to absolute space. But inertial resistance opposed to relative acceleration of distant masses presupposes action at a distance ; and as the modern physicist does not believe that he may accept this action at a distance, he comes back once more, if he follows Mach, to the ether, which has to serve as medium for the effects of inertia. But this conception of the ether to which we are led by Mach's way of thinking differs essentially from the ether as conceived by Newton, by Fresnel, and by Lorentz. Mach's ether not only conditions the behaviour of inert masses, but is also conditioned in its state by them.

Mach's idea finds its full development in the ether of the general theory of relativity. According to this theory the metrical qualities of the continuum of space-time differ in the environment of different points of space-time, and are partly conditioned by the matter existing outside of the territory under consideration. This spacetime variability of the reciprocal relations of the standards of space and time, or, perhaps, the recognition of the fact that "empty space" in its physical relation is neither homogeneous nor isotropic, compelling us to describe its state by ten functions (the gravitation potentials ##g_{\mu \nu}##), has, I think, finally disposed of the view that space is physically empty. But therewith the conception of the ether has again acquired an intelligible content, although this content differs widely from that of the ether of the mechanical undulatory theory of light. The ether of the general theory of relativity is a medium which is itself devoid of all mechanical and kinematic qualities, but helps to determine mechanical (and electromagnetic) events.

What is fundamentally new in the ether of the general theory of relativity as opposed to the ether of Lorentz consists in this, that the state of the former is at every place determined by connections with the matter and the state of the ether in neighbouring places, which are amenable to law in the form of differential equations ; whereas the state of the Lorentzian ether in the absence of electromagnetic fields is conditioned by nothing outside itself, and is everywhere the same. The ether of the general theory of relativity is transmuted conceptually into the ether of Lorentz if we substitute constants for the functions of space which describe the former, disregarding the causes which condition its state. Thus we may also say, I think, that the ether of the general theory of relativity is the outcome of the Lorentzian ether, through relativation.

As to the part which the new ether is to play in the physics of the future we are not yet clear. We know that it determines the metrical relations in the space-time continuum, e.g. the configurative possibilities of solid bodies as well as the gravitational fields ; but we do not know whether it has an essential share in the structure of the electrical elementary particles constituting matter. Nor do we know whether it is only in the proximity of ponderable masses that its structure differs essentially from that of the Lorentzian ether ; whether the geometry of spaces of cosmic extent is approximately Euclidean.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: gentzen, quark69 and Demystifier
quark69 said:
TL;DR: I’m wondering if the thought of the eather from early physics is equal to the the spacetime we now today?

None, just a thought
Spacetime is a geometric construct that is very useful to physicists in describing and predicting the way Nature behaves.

The aether, described as an actual substance filling all of space, is of no use whatsoever in describing or predicting the way Nature behaves. It is of historical interest only, and has no scientific value whatsoever.
 
Ibix said:
No, it was supposed to be a material filling all of space. Like a gas, basically.

Experiment chipped away at the properties it could have until we were left with the Lorentz ether that has no properties except its existence. This version of the ether is simply special relativity with an undetectable (even in principle) ether that doesn't actually do anything, so it got dropped as a concept.
You are probably confusing the 'Einsteinian ether' which is devoid of all properties with the Lorentz electromagnetic ether.

The Lorentz electromagnetic ether leads to the anisotropy of the speed of light in systems moving through the ether. In turn, this leads to the physical compression of objects (length contraction) and the slowing down of processes.

In SR, length contraction and time dilation are purely kinematic effects.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_ether_theory

1795347463116.webp
 
AlexOsipovich said:
the 'Einsteinian ether'
I am not familiar with the Einsteinian ether. Please post the professional scientific paper that defines it and asserts that it is devoid of all properties.
 
Dale said:
I am not familiar with the Einsteinian ether. Please post the professional scientific paper that defines it and asserts that it is devoid of all properties.
Just above, Jaime Rudas shared a quote from Einstein's lecture:

"The ether of the general theory of relativity is a medium which is itself devoid of all mechanical and kinematic qualities, but helps to determine mechanical (and electromagnetic) events."

"But this conception of the ether to which we are led by Mach's way of thinking differs essentially from the ether as conceived by Newton, by Fresnel, and by Lorentz."

In other words, he is talking about a completely "different" kind of ether.
 
quark69 said:
TL;DR: I’m wondering if the thought of the eather from early physics is equal to the the spacetime we now today?
You can build an interpretation like that, yes. But you need to expand the early version of the eather to modern day standards.

For example you could interpret space time curvature differently: assuming that the length of meter and duration of second is not constant but changes (within whatever measure) due to physical effects. Looking for a time/space that is unaffected in such a way would basically mean finding a flat space-time - and since time is what a clock measures and and a clock is which measures time (physical definitions are not more concrete than that) - you are quite free to find a valid alternative measure of time from principles alone. flatness won't be enough though. if you opt for something akin to Newtonian absolute space and time, you'll find your time specification will get very close to some special coordinates. and you will find that coordinating space travel in a complex scenario is anyway calculated in such a way, e.g. TCB coordinates.

But using such an interpretation seriously requires rewriting physics into your new metric - in which all space time geometry is now reappears as a new physical tensor field. It will differ from the old ether only in that it includes gravity effects from GRT unlike Poincarés corrected LET version.

There are quite a few technical benefits from such structure, hence why there is various independent research from different motivations in such direction.
 
Killtech said:
using such an interpretation seriously requires rewriting physics into your new metric - in which all space time geometry is now reappears as a new physical tensor field.
Are you referring to the model of gravity as a massless spin-2 field?
 
PeterDonis said:
Are you referring to the model of gravity as a massless spin-2 field?
you are thinking of some ideas from quantum gravity? I was thinking to stay classical and do only the reinterpretation - without breaking anything and particularly no weak-field approach taking away the non-lineariy in Einsteins eqs.

The is no reason for additional physical degrees of freedom or changing the predictions of GR. Rather a different physical interpretation of the same mathematical structure - a general purpose starting point to think from.

I think the massless 2-spin field should follow implicitly for small perturbations.
 
Killtech said:
you are thinking of some ideas from quantum gravity?
Sort of. I am referring to the effort in the 1960s and early 1970s to develop a quantum field theory of a massless spin-2 field, by analogy with quantum electrodynamics as the quantum field theory of a massless, spin-1 field. The outcome of this effort was that the field equation for such a theory is the Einstein Field Equation of GR--which means the classical limit of this QFT is standard classical GR. We have had previous PF threads on this topic.

From an interpretation point of view, this means that (with some technical caveats), you can interpret gravity as a massless spin-2 field on a flat background spacetime. But the flat background spacetime is unobservable; the actual observable spacetime metric is the curved one that includes the effects of the spin-2 field.

This seems to be what you are describing, but if so some of the things you say about it are not correct--which makes me wonder if you are referring to something else, in which case you need to give a reference for what it is.

Killtech said:
if you opt for something akin to Newtonian absolute space and time, you'll find your time specification will get very close to some special coordinates. and you will find that coordinating space travel in a complex scenario is anyway calculated in such a way, e.g. TCB coordinates.
This has nothing whatever to do with the massless spin-2 field interpretation, which does not in any way introduce "something akin to Newtonian absolute space and time".

Killtech said:
using such an interpretation seriously requires rewriting physics into your new metric - in which all space time geometry is now reappears as a new physical tensor field.
No, no "rewriting" is needed at all. As above, the Einstein Field Equation is the correct field equation. Mathematically, the theory is just standard GR. The "spin-2 field on a flat background spacetime" is only an interpretation. It doesn't "rewrite" any of the math or any of the predictions of the theory.

Killtech said:
There are quite a few technical benefits from such structure, hence why there is various independent research from different motivations in such direction.
What research are you referring to? Can you give specific references? AFAIK since the early 1970s there hasn't been any significant additional research done on the massless spin-2 field QFT. It just became part of the standard toolbox of known QFTs.

Killtech said:
I was thinking to stay classical and do only the reinterpretation - without breaking anything and particularly no weak-field approach taking away the non-lineariy in Einsteins eqs.

The is no reason for additional physical degrees of freedom or changing the predictions of GR. Rather a different physical interpretation of the same mathematical structure - a general purpose starting point to think from.
Here you appear to be describing the actual line of research that I referred to above, but you do not appear to be aware that it has already been done--in the 1960s and early 1970s.

Killtech said:
I think the massless 2-spin field should follow implicitly for small perturbations.
As above, the massless spin-2 field is not limited to small perturbations. It gives you, once you correctly develop the QFT correct to all orders, the exact, nonlinear Einstein Field Equation.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
devoid of all properties
AlexOsipovich said:
devoid of all mechanical and kinematic qualities
There is an enormous gap between “devoid of all mechanical and kinematic qualities” and “devoid of all properties”.
 
Dale said:
There is an enormous gap between “devoid of all mechanical and kinematic qualities” and “devoid of all properties”.
I agree, I went a bit too far there—thanks for correcting me. What I meant is that Einstein's ether is different from Lorentz's, and it's really important not to confuse the two.
 
AlexOsipovich said:
I agree, I went a bit too far there—thanks for correcting me. What I meant is that Einstein's ether is different from Lorentz's, and it's really important not to confuse the two.
The modern terminology for what you call Einstein’s aether is “the metric”. I don’t think any professional scientists use the “Einstein’s aether” terminology. Certainly not now and maybe not ever.