Age Impact on Academic Career: German Study & PhD at 30+

  • Studying
  • Thread starter MedLam
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Age Matter
In summary, based on personal observations, it is generally easier to advance in an academic career if you graduate from school at a younger age.
  • #1
MedLam
30
1
I am 18, I am going to be studying German in Germany for 10 months, and then go to a preparatory year (German studienkolleg) I will probably be 20 or 21 before I start actually studying in the university ( although I finished high school at 17 and got accepted in my home country's university, but it sucks, Germany is my only hope ) considering that I am really good at math and physics, and all I will be doing those 2-3 years is study ameliorate my level, will I be too old when I finally get a PhD? Knowing that I want to go to academics and do research, I may be 30 or 31 by the time I finish my PhD, which is the time that most physicist do their most notable work, how will it impact my career? and my chances of finding a position in a good university. Especially that some people get their PhD very young, and most people at 25 or 26. Also, will my brain work the same way? some people may say do something because you love it, but if I am going to do something I love without the hope of ever achieving anything or advancing the field, or even effecting it, then I don't think I can do it.
Also, is there no way I can make the period shorter? This is just not letting me think straight, I am starting to think of changing my plans to Engineering or Medicine ..
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You will be too young to apply for a permanet position, most likely. And students won't realize if you are a student or a professor.
 
  • #3
Asteropaeus said:
You will be too young to apply for a permanet position, most likely. And students won't realize if you are a student or a professor.
Yes, but I will have to apply for a postdoc, which would only make me older .. I like the student or professor thing though.
 
  • #4
Most people get a PhD at 25 or 26? Where are you getting this statistic?
 
  • Like
Likes Wadih Hanache and Delong
  • #5
Dishsoap said:
Most people get a PhD at 25 or 26? Where are you getting this statistic?
Now that I looked it up, I realized it is wrong, I assumed that based on research I have done about Nobel prize winners. But doesn't that actually mean there's a correlation? the people that are doing really good are the people that are graduating young ( or it may be that the reason they are graduating young is because they are good ) ..
 
  • #6
MedLam said:
Now that I looked it up, I realized it is wrong, I assumed that based on research I have done about Nobel prize winners.

The situation is very different today. Things have changed in the past past 100 years and it now takes quite a bit longer to get a PhD than it used to.
Also, different countries have different systems. Here in the UK it used to be possible (just a few years ago) to -in theory- get a PhD after six years (3 years for a BSc and then 3 years as a PhD student). Now most CDTs will require you to have a MSc or equivalent before they accept you and then the CDT program itself is 4 years; so the total time is now about 8 years.
In Sweden where I studied you needed a 4.5 year MSc and then the PhD itself was 4+1 years (the PhD itself was in theory 4 years, but you also spent 20% of your time teaching so 5 years in total)

Anyway, the point is that most people will be about 28-29 years old when they finish. It is not a race and you can't really shorted the duration of your PhD; if you are good you will simply do better work and publish more/better papers.
 
  • #7
MedLam said:
( or it may be that the reason they are graduating young is because they are good )
This.
 
  • Like
Likes Delong
  • #8
"Delaying" entry into a university program for a few years is not going to make any difference to your academic career in the long run. In fact, just based on personal observations, having a couple of extra years of maturity and life experience can often be a major advantage in university.
 
  • Like
Likes Delong
  • #9
Someone told me once that it's the slope of the line that matters more than it's placement on the "time" axis.

I.e. whatever your age is, just don't waste time in school - especially grad school. People can sit aimlessly for awhile, especially when completing their dissertation.

-Dave K
 
  • Like
Likes Dishsoap and Logical Dog
  • #10
Does age matter? The younger you are, the less likely you'll keel over in your sleep. So, probably.

Does it matter what age you graduate from school? Since you can't finish if you're dead, probably.

Is there a difference between graduating at 26 or 30? At least not in the US - assuming you're still alive. There are age discrimination laws on the books (As if you'd need them at 30, I'll be closer to 40 when I finish.) There are other minor concerns; such as, can you work long enough to retire comfortably, assuming a later start date in the workforce and less time to build up a retirement nest egg.

You're not from the US, so I don't know about what protections Germany or wherever you're from offers, but graduating four years later at 30? Come on. o_O
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Delong
  • #11
If you do your undergrad in the US and start grad school there right after completing your undergrad, you will usually be about 27-28 when you finish your PhD. Most people I know started straight from undergrad, but some people took a few years in between. So that being said, it would not be very noticeable if you graduated at age 30 or 31 having taken 5-6 years to complete your PhD.
 
  • #12
radium said:
If you do your undergrad in the US and start grad school there right after completing your undergrad, you will usually be about 27-28 when you finish your PhD. Most people I know started straight from undergrad, but some people took a few years in between. So that being said, it would not be very noticeable if you graduated at age 30 or 31 having taken 5-6 years to complete your PhD.
How about germany? What if I do my undergrad in Germany in a university ranked 13th in physics, I will be probably be 23 or 24 when I apply for grad school, I may want to go to the UK or the US, will age effect my chances of gettig into a top tier school? Can I skip masters?
 
  • #13
MedLam said:
How about germany? What if I do my undergrad in Germany in a university ranked 13th in physics, I will be probably be 23 or 24 when I apply for grad school, I may want to go to the UK or the US, will age effect my chances of gettig into a top tier school? Can I skip masters?

I don't even think age is part of any application in the US, at least I can't remember it being on any I filled out.

Regardless, I can't see why'd it matter.
 
  • #14
MedLam said:
How about germany? What if I do my undergrad in Germany in a university ranked 13th in physics, I will be probably be 23 or 24 when I apply for grad school, I may want to go to the UK or the US, will age effect my chances of gettig into a top tier school? Can I skip masters?

Most places in the UK will require you to have completed a MSc or equivalent.. 23-24 would be the normal age for starting a PhD in the UK (nowadays quite a few people take a gap year etc so many are 1-2 years older).
 
  • #15
I mean, look around on this forum and you'll find people in their 40s and 50s asking if it's too late. But taking just a few extra years? Not even a question, it's likely no one will even notice the difference (although I do know grad students that are frustrated being thrown in with "babies").
 
  • Like
Likes Dr. Courtney and Delong
  • #16
Choppy said:
"Having a couple of extra years of maturity and life experience can often be a major advantage in university.

This is righteous. You will probably become a better student as you get older.
 
  • #17
do we get dumber when we get older? I think we get wiser and smarter from what I've seen
 
  • #18
Bipolar Demon said:
do we get dumber when we get older? I think we get wiser and smarter from what I've seen

Yes, but I believe that what happens (what happened to me anyway) is that you have to pay more attention to your physical health as you get older. The (younger) students I worked with had more physical energy so were able to study longer, sleep less, and eat less. They could also get away with eating poorer diets.. pizza, ramen, whatever.

To "keep up" I realized that what I had to do was not try to study more, but to get more exercise and pack my food!

-Dave K
 
  • Like
Likes Logical Dog
  • #19
I was 24 when I started, and I had to start from behind normal university students. I'm now in a good school studying physics and doing research in astrophysics. I'll be 36 before I get a PhD, but literally nobody will care.

You're good dude.
 
  • Like
Likes Logical Dog

1. How does age impact an academic career in Germany?

The German study found that age does have a significant impact on academic career progression. Older PhD students and researchers tend to have slower career advancements and are less likely to reach higher positions in academia.

2. Why is there a perceived disadvantage for PhD students over the age of 30?

Many universities and research institutions in Germany have an age limit for PhD positions, which can range from 30 to 35 years old. This can make it more difficult for older students to secure funding and opportunities for their research.

3. What are the possible reasons for this age limit in academic careers?

One reason for the age limit is to maintain a younger and more dynamic research community. Another is to ensure that PhD students have enough time to complete their research within a reasonable time frame.

4. Is it still worth pursuing a PhD at the age of 30 or older?

While there may be some challenges and limitations for older PhD students in Germany, it is still possible to have a successful academic career. Many universities and research institutes value diverse perspectives and experiences, which can be an advantage for older students.

5. What can be done to address the age impact on academic careers in Germany?

There have been calls for universities and research institutions to re-evaluate their age limits and to provide more support and opportunities for older PhD students. Additionally, creating a more inclusive and diverse environment in academia can help address the age impact on academic careers.

Similar threads

Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
488
Replies
3
Views
900
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
596
Replies
28
Views
695
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
946
Replies
2
Views
827
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
16
Views
864
Back
Top