Applying desiccant to surfaces (aluminum sheet or PLA/PETG)

  • Thread starter Thread starter mess
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Surfaces
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around methods for applying a coating of silica desiccant to surfaces made of aluminum, PLA, or PETG, with the aim of managing heat and humidity in a campervan project. Participants explore various techniques for coating these materials and the implications of each method.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests using a spray adhesive to apply silica desiccant to a constructed wheel, emphasizing the need to sprinkle gently to avoid clumping.
  • Another participant questions the use of pure silica powder, proposing the idea of creating a solution for dipping the part, but raises concerns about the adhesive coating the silica.
  • A different approach is suggested involving the use of a powder adhesive that could adhere to the disk with static electricity, allowing for silica to be added afterward.
  • One participant proposes surrounding a 3D printed part with silica powder and baking it to create a thin film of silica on the surface, drawing parallels to existing methods using salt for reinforcement.
  • Another participant mentions the process of incorporating silica into materials during manufacturing, referencing a patent and discussing the challenges of following detailed instructions for creating impregnated materials.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a variety of methods and ideas for applying silica, but there is no consensus on the best approach. Multiple competing views remain regarding the effectiveness and practicality of each proposed method.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations related to the depth and narrowness of the channels in the wheel, as well as the potential need for pressure to achieve adhesion of the silica powder. There are also unresolved questions about the specific properties of adhesives and their interactions with silica.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in DIY projects involving humidity control, 3D printing, or material science may find the discussion relevant.

mess
Messages
59
Reaction score
8
TL;DR
I would like to prototype building my own enthalpy wheel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_wheel) and I need to apply some desiccant to the surface of the material that I will be making the wheel out of. How can I do this?
I will either be using aluminum strips wound up, or 3d printing it out of PLA or PETG. How can I apply a coating of silica to the surface of either of these materials so that it can hold and release the moisture of the incoming air/outgoing air?

This is to manage heat and humidity in my campervan project.

Ideally It would be easiest to 3d print the wheel, and PETG has much better thermal conductivity than PLA plastic, but both are significantly lower than aluminum.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
After the wheel is constructed, use a spray adhesive on it then sprinkle the dessicant on. Then leave it alone for a bit. After the adhesive cures, shake off the excess dessicant.

Cheers,
Tom
<edit> Sprinkle gently so the dessicant doesn't bounce around and get covered with adhesive. </edit>
 
and would i just use pure silica powder? I would have to toss it around in a bag of it or something because the channels in the wheel will probably be around 1-2 inches deep and extremely narrow.

It would be much better if i could make a solution of it that i dip the part into
 
mess said:
and would i just use pure silica powder? I would have to toss it around in a bag of it or something because the channels in the wheel will probably be around 1-2 inches deep and extremely narrow.

It would be much better if i could make a solution of it that i dip the part into
If you make a solution of silica and an adhesive you end up with the silica completely coated with adhesive; seems rather counter-productive.

Or perhaps you were thinking of applying adhesive to the disk then shaking the sticky disk in a bag of silica. Could work if you can stop the adhesive from filling the channels due to surface tension.

Another perhaps: Maybe you can find an adhesive, say a powder, that will adhere in a thin film to the disk with static electricity, and will cure with heat (or maybe UV). Coat the disk, shake in a bag of silica, cure.

Sounds like the fix is to change the aspect ratio of the channels and/or use a larger disk. :oldcry:

How about making the disk of spun polyester mat, the kind used in COVID-19 masks? Then you can soak the disk in a water or alcohol suspension of silica and then 'regenerate' it. Of course a frame is needed to hold the mat in a disk shape.

Or, the "obvious" is to ask a manufacturer how they do it. You may have to ask several of them before one responds with an answer beyond "No comment."

As a last resort, by a replacement disk for a commercial unit.

end of brainstorm [/size]

Cheers,
Tom
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mess
I think i just thought of a great way to do this. I will try to get silica powder, and then surround my 3d printed part in the powder, and then I bake it, this way it will maintain its shape and a thin film of silica will stick to the printed part.

people are already doing this with salt in order to reinforce 3d printed parts, so i assume it should work fine with silica powder.Any thoughts on this idea?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Tom.G
Last edited:
mess said:
I think i just thought of a great way to do this. I will try to get silica powder, and then surround my 3d printed part in the powder, and then I bake it, this way it will maintain its shape and a thin film of silica will stick to the printed part.

people are already doing this with salt in order to reinforce 3d printed parts, so i assume it should work fine with silica powder.

Any thoughts on this idea?
Certainly worth trying! Nicely creative too.
I suggest trying it first on a small scale to work out all the 'unknowns.'

I have no experience in 3D printing, but an 'unknown' that comes to mind is you may have to apply some pressure (as in forcefully compacting the powder) to partially imbed the silica powder in the surface to get adhesion.

Cheers,
Tom
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mess
chemisttree said:
Try this.

Or this.
Thank you but I am not seeing any relevant (how its made) info on either of those links. I hope i didnt miss anything.
 
mess said:
Thank you but I am not seeing any relevant (how its made) info on either of those links. I hope i didnt miss anything.
Did you read the patent? Column 2, lines 8-56, for example?

This picture on the Munters site should describe in enough detail what needs to be done.
1610223031008.jpeg


Impregnated filamentous material means fiberboard or cardboard and excelsior means wood shavings. Incorporating silica into that occurs during its manufacture. A slurry of fibers and silica is poured out onto a screen mold and residual moisture is pressed out (like how you make paper) and then dried. That’s “impregnated” paper. From that paper a cardboard stack is made. From the cardboard stack is cut out a round shape and then it is fixed to an arbor.

You are going to have lots of trouble if you can’t follow bread crumbs like these...
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: Tom.G
  • #10
chemisttree said:
Did you read the patent? Column 2, lines 8-56, for example?

This picture on the Munters site should describe in enough detail what needs to be done.
View attachment 275928

Impregnated filamentous material means fiberboard or cardboard and excelsior means wood shavings. Incorporating silica into that occurs during its manufacture. A slurry of fibers and silica is poured out onto a screen mold and residual moisture is pressed out (like how you make paper) and then dried. That’s “impregnated” paper. From that paper a cardboard stack is made. From the cardboard stack is cut out a round shape and then it is fixed to an arbor.

You are going to have lots of trouble if you can’t follow bread crumbs like these...

Thanks for your suggestion. Also a descant wheel is not an ERV wheel (which is why I specified I need to apply it to aluminum or a plastic capable of heat transfer). They do different things and are manufactured differently.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 36 ·
2
Replies
36
Views
5K
  • Poll Poll
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
10K