B Are photons entangled with a component of the atom that emitted them?

Matthew-Champion
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
TL;DR Summary
If an atom were made to release a Photon, then a number of the components of the atoms nucleus were theoretically extremely quickly removed. would the previously emitted photon change wave length?
If an atom were made to release a Photon, then a number of the components of the atoms nucleus were theoretically extremely quickly removed. would the previously emitted photon change wave length?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
@Matthew-Champion The answer to the question in the title is yes. Generally the particles coming out of an interaction are entangled in some way at least until one of them interacts with something else (and note that a measurement is always a case of “interacts with something else”).

However, that “yes” answer does not imply what you’re asking in the body because entanglement doesn’t work the way you’re thinking. Changing one part of an entangled system (in this case, manipulating the atom after the emission) has no causal effect on the other parts of the system (in this case, the emitted photon).

There are two possibilities here. One is that we measure the wavelength (energy, frequency, they’re all related) of the photon first. This interaction breaks the entanglement so nothing we do to the atom later changes the photon energy from the value we’ve measured. The other possibility is that we interact with the atom first, breaking the entanglement, and then we measure the wavelength of the photon. Either way, we get one measurement of the photon and its wavelength is what we measure.
 
:welcome:

Your question may be the result of misunderstanding quantum theory. Although, I see @Nugatory has made some sense of it.
 
Nugatory said:
@Matthew-Champion The answer to the question in the title is yes. Generally the particles coming out of an interaction are entangled in some way at least until one of them interacts with something else (and note that a measurement is always a case of “interacts with something else”).

However, that “yes” answer does not imply what you’re asking in the body because entanglement doesn’t work the way you’re thinking. Changing one part of an entangled system (in this case, manipulating the atom after the emission) has no causal effect on the other parts of the system (in this case, the emitted photon).

There are two possibilities here. One is that we measure the wavelength (energy, frequency, they’re all related) of the photon first. This interaction breaks the entanglement so nothing we do to the atom later changes the photon energy from the value we’ve measured. The other possibility is that we interact with the atom first, breaking the entanglement, and then we measure the wavelength of the photon. Either way, we get one measurement of the photon and its wavelength is what we measure.
Thank you for your reply. yes I see where I went wrong. I got all exited before thinking properly. oh well thank you for the concise answer.
 
Not an expert in QM. AFAIK, Schrödinger's equation is quite different from the classical wave equation. The former is an equation for the dynamics of the state of a (quantum?) system, the latter is an equation for the dynamics of a (classical) degree of freedom. As a matter of fact, Schrödinger's equation is first order in time derivatives, while the classical wave equation is second order. But, AFAIK, Schrödinger's equation is a wave equation; only its interpretation makes it non-classical...
I am not sure if this falls under classical physics or quantum physics or somewhere else (so feel free to put it in the right section), but is there any micro state of the universe one can think of which if evolved under the current laws of nature, inevitably results in outcomes such as a table levitating? That example is just a random one I decided to choose but I'm really asking about any event that would seem like a "miracle" to the ordinary person (i.e. any event that doesn't seem to...
Back
Top