Are protons attracted to magnets or controlled by them?

12 replies · 8K views · last reply
Kalrag
Messages
104
Reaction score
0
Alright, this one is really bugging me. Are protons magnetic. Are they attracted to a magnet or can the be controlled by a magnet?
 
They have a Magnetic moment and so do neutrons .
 
yes they can be controlled magnetically, that's how particle accelerators work.
 
So is that also true for neutrons. That they can be controlled by magnets?
 
Idoubt said:
yes they can be controlled magnetically, that's how particle accelerators work.
That is also how magnetic resonance imaging works.
 
Kalrag said:
So is that also true for neutrons. That they can be controlled by magnets?
Yes but their B field is very weak.
 
Kalrag said:
Alright, this one is really bugging me. Are protons magnetic. Are they attracted to a magnet or can the be controlled by a magnet?

Just to clear a point: a magnetic field will not do work on the proton. It will accelerate the proton in a circular way, just changing the direction but not the magnitude.
 
Individual protons are magnetic in the same sense as individual electrons! They are both charged spin-1/2 particles.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-factor

electron fudge factor
Equation for the magnetic moment of a spin particle: mu_S = g_e mu_B S/hbar, with g_e the electron g-factor and mu_B the Bohr magneton.

proton and neutron fudge factor
Equation for magnetic moment: mu equals g times mu_N times I over h-bar, where mu_N is the nuclear magneton and I is the spin angular momentum vector.

muon fudge factor
Equation for magnetic moment: mu = g times e times S divided by 2 m_mu, where g is the g-factor, e is the elementary charge, S is spin and m_mu is the muon mass.
 
We would expect magnetic moment and angular momentum to always be proportional to each other.
They arent.
Hence the fudge factors.
 
Last edited:
Sakha said:
Just to clear a point: a magnetic field will not do work on the proton. It will accelerate the proton in a circular way, just changing the direction but not the magnitude.
What you said is true for CONSTANT magnetic field. A gradient in the field can accelerate a magnetic moment.
 
Idoubt said:
yes they can be controlled magnetically, that's how particle accelerators work.

This doesn't sound right to me. Particle accelerators use magnetic fields to curve the path of protons but this is due to the proton's electric charge moving through an external magnetic field, not the proton's magnetic moment.