Are the Red Terms Equal to Zero in This Cross Product Problem?

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
sparkle123
Messages
172
Reaction score
0
Background: we're trying to show that the rate of change of angular momentum of an object about its center of mass (position given by R) is equal to the total torque about R.

Why are the terms in red equal to 0? If anything, shouldn't the terms circled in in blue be equal to zero since the vectors R and ai are parallel and ri` and ai` are parallel?

Thank you!
 
Attachments
  • Slide deriving the sum of m_i (R + r_i') x (A + a_i') expanded into three cross-product sums, with the first term circled in blue, the middle term circled in red, and the last term circled in blue, followed by a line of simplified sums.
    centre of mass.JPG
    31.4 KB · Views: 489
What would it mean if, as you say, the acceleration of each individual particle were parallel to [itex]\vec R[/itex]?
 
Last edited:
Then there is no angular momentum and only linear momentum?

EDIT: actually i made an error with my question. the new image is attached.
If ri` and ai` are parallel, shouldn't the cross-product be 0? So in the last line, the Ʃ miri` × A would be left instead?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten-style slide of vector equations in centre-of-mass form: sum of m_i(R + r_i') x (A + a_i') = sum (R + r_i') x F_i, then sum m_i R x a_i + sum m_i r_i' x A + sum m_i r_i' x a_i = sum R x F_i + sum r_i' x F_i, with a red circle around the middle term and a blue circle around the last term.
    centre of mass.JPG
    27.6 KB · Views: 530
sparkle123 said:
Then there is no angular momentum and only linear momentum?
No. Reexamine your assumption.

EDIT: actually i made an error with my question. the new image is attached.
If ri` and ai` are parallel, shouldn't the cross-product be 0?
Why do you think they are parallel?
 
tms said:
No. Reexamine your assumption.Why do you think they are parallel?

Isn't a the double derivative of r (so they are parallel)?
Thanks again!
 
That doesn't mean they must be parallel. If it did, it would mean that you could change the forces on an object just by moving the origin of the coordinate system.