Balsa Bridge Design Optimisation

In summary, the student is seeking help in designing a balsa bridge that will span 200mm without failing, and is loaded centrally for testing. The objective is to have the bridge fail at a certain weight, with points given for high strength to weight ratios and simplicity of design. The student already has a design but is struggling with the calculations and is hoping for assistance from a civil engineer. The failure weight of the bridge is 200N, but the performance criteria can be adjusted if calculated and stated beforehand. The allowed dimensions for balsa wood are 2x2, 3x3, 4x4, 5x5, 6x6, 100x2, 100x3, 100x
  • #1
kuleke
14
0
Hi,

I need to design a balsa bridge that will cover a distance of 200mm. It will be loaded centrally for testing. The objective of this however is not to test until failure, but to have it fail at a certain weight. Points are also given for high strength to weight ratios and simplicity of the design. I already have a design but the calculations are looking very tedious and I am hoping that a civil engineer out there can help me with a simplified design. The failure weight of the bridge is by default 200N but if calculated and stated beforehand, the performance criteria is adjusted to match the defined failure weight.

Thank you very much
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
What are the dimensions of the balsa wood you have to hand?

What other materials are you allowed?

Are there any specific restrictions that should be highlighted before we start?
 
  • #3
How do you define failure?
 
  • #4
jarednjames said:
What are the dimensions of the balsa wood you have to hand?

What other materials are you allowed?

Are there any specific restrictions that should be highlighted before we start?

Allowed Dimensions: 2x2, 3x3, 4x4, 5x5, 6x6, 100x2, 100x3, 100x4, 100x5 and 100x6. They also have sheets but their dimensions weren't specified.

We're only allowed balsa wood and glue.

We require the structure to break at 200N, and the design has to make provision for the attachment of the bolts that will connect to the weight.
 
  • #5
Studiot said:
How do you define failure?

The bridge failing completely. The idea is that all the components have the same chance of failure at the weight of 200N so it breaks down completely. We're trying to achieve a very high strength to weight ratio.
 
  • #6
Hello?? :confused:
 
  • #7
OK, sorry completely forgot.

So now, as this is school work, we need to see some effort from yourself.

What design do you currently have? What is its breaking point? What ideas do you have for increasing structural strength?
 
  • #8
http://www.elpla.com/elpla_en/images/truss.gif

What I have is effectively that, I'm really stuck on how to optimize strength to weight and find the failing point (and possibly failure mode and location of failure). Also, I don't think that design is great. i chose it because they appear to emphasize simplicity. I'm really pressed for time at the moment on this so I would really appreciate some quick responses. Thank you :)
 
  • #9
One other thing, what dimensions are you using? Never forget units!

Also, you're balsa wood should have three dimensions (it's not 2D is it?). Or is the third whatever length you require?
 
  • #10
All dimensions are in N, mm and effectively Mpa. the bridge has to span at least 200mm so it doesn't fall through to the ground, we're allowed to analyze as though its a 2d structure since there are no components in the direction of the third axis as far as the majority of designs go(also makes the concept of simplicity fail). The area of the balsa wood i believe we have but we just do a frameworks analysis until we need to estimate total weight/failure stress/load etc
 
  • #11
Given your wood is mainly square, I'd recommend you go with something like the following 3D structure:
[PLAIN]http://www.heightec.com/shop/images/tower-crane-rescue_1.jpg [Broken]

It's slightly more complex, but it's a lot stronger.

If you'd prefer to go with something more 'square' for easier calculations, you're possibly going to need a fair bit more wood.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
will it not be difficult to model/analyse this? I'm not very good with CAD/Simulation software :(
 
  • #13
It would.

A 2D design is all well and good to analyse, but your final model will be 3D.

That structure is a good strong one (hence the use on cranes).

I'm trying to think of one that would be simple to analyse but strong.
 
  • #14
From previous experience in balsa bridge building, keep in mind that you bridge will probably start failing at your joints rather than in the middle of a spar. This could make predicting when it will fail more difficult. I would recommend making two kinds of joint- one that is strong, and the other designed to fail. If you place your joints which are designed to fail at strategic locations, the whole bridge should come down at the load you designed it to. Repeatability will be key.

From an analysis standpoint, my guess is the easiest "bridge" to design would be a single simply-supported beam structure. Either an I-beam, hollow tube, or solid cross-section. Analysis would only require a simple beam-bending equation, and probability of failure could be tested ahead of time with test samples and a load cell.
 
  • #15
Mech_Engineer said:
From previous experience in balsa bridge building, keep in mind that you bridge will probably start failing at your joints rather than in the middle of a spar. This could make predicting when it will fail more difficult. I would recommend making two kinds of joint- one that is strong, and the other designed to fail. If you place your joints which are designed to fail at strategic locations, the whole bridge should come down at the load you designed it to. Repeatability will be key.

From an analysis standpoint, my guess is the easiest "bridge" to design would be a single simply-supported beam structure. Either an I-beam, hollow tube, or solid cross-section. Analysis would only require a simple beam-bending equation, and probability of failure could be tested ahead of time with test samples and a load cell.
Please refer to the available dimensions of balsa I mentioned earlier, I'd like to know how you think I can construct the I-beam because I don't think it will be able to handle 200N at the center. Thanks
 
  • #16
What are your own thoughts? Have you done any test configurations?

The project is yours, we can help but no one will do your work for you.
 
  • #17
http://www.elpla.com/elpla_en/images/truss.gif

That photo is what I had in mind (the dimensions are incorrect), I know how to find the internal forces, but I don't know how I'd optimise it and be able to predict its failure mode. I think the beam will be too difficult to construct and I also doubt I'll get any marks for simplicity if I were to do that
 
  • #18
OK here are a few pointers to start off with.

The material is Balsa.

If you are only allowed to glued joints, do you think the joints will be rigid?
If so will you analysis be valid?

Balsa is a very soft material, is the material as strong in compression as tension?
How does the answer affect the size and shape of members made from it?
Could any difference be exploited to define the failure member?
 

1. What is balsa bridge design optimisation?

Balsa bridge design optimisation is the process of using scientific principles and techniques to design a strong and efficient bridge made out of balsa wood. This involves considering factors such as weight, load distribution, and material properties to create a bridge that can support the desired weight while using the least amount of materials.

2. Why is balsa wood commonly used for bridge design optimisation?

Balsa wood is often used for bridge design optimisation because it is lightweight yet strong, making it an ideal material for creating efficient and durable bridge structures. It is also readily available and relatively inexpensive compared to other types of wood or building materials.

3. What are the key factors to consider in balsa bridge design optimisation?

The key factors to consider in balsa bridge design optimisation include the weight of the bridge, the distribution of load and stress, the strength and stiffness of the materials, and the overall cost and feasibility of the design.

4. How can computer simulations be used in balsa bridge design optimisation?

Computer simulations can be used in balsa bridge design optimisation to analyze and predict the behavior of the bridge under different conditions, such as varying loads and stress levels. This allows for the testing and refinement of the design before physically constructing the bridge, saving time and resources.

5. What are some real-world applications of balsa bridge design optimisation?

Balsa bridge design optimisation has various real-world applications, including designing bridges for pedestrian crossings, small-scale bridges for model or experimental purposes, and even larger bridges for vehicles or other heavy loads. It is also commonly used in educational settings to teach students about engineering and design principles.

Similar threads

  • DIY Projects
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
9
Views
8K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
10K
Replies
3
Views
29K
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
5K
Back
Top