Because Physics is better than your major

40 replies · 7K views · last reply
Pengwuino
Gold Member
Messages
5,112
Reaction score
20
So sometimes people ask "why physics?" and I tell them about all that BS about learning how the world works, doing stuff that challenges me and interests me...

but this is the actual answer:

Long row of vacuum chambers, pumps, cables and electronics mounted along a raised metal beamline in a laboratory, with a yellow WARNING sign visible at the lower right.


X-ray laser experiment designed to be awesome

Dense view of a laboratory with stainless steel vacuum chambers, flanges and metal pipes, blue optical tables, and tangled cables and hoses across the equipment.


ZOMG WHAT IS THAT?!?

Cluttered lab with vacuum chambers, metal pipes and cabling on a dark blue equipment rack, with red-painted support frames and a yellow hazard-striped barrier behind.


More awesome. AND I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT IT DOES.

Control room with rows of wall-mounted monitors and desks with monitors, office chairs, and a round wooden conference table; large photos of accelerator equipment on the back wall.


Okay this is more badass when they're actually here doing experiments

Control room with two office chairs facing a curved desk holding computer monitors, with a wall of video screens above and a blue recycling bin in front.


SLAC Main Control Center, and the people working there act like they don't have a sweet *** job.

Photo of a seminar room with an audience seated at tables facing a projector screen showing a slide titled Summary with green text, and a speaker standing beside it.


Oh and to top it all off, dinner with a Nobel Prize winner.

SO WHERE WAS I?

Oh, right, I was at the Stanford Linear Accelerator National Lab for the APS CA/NV section meeting. They gave us a tour of the accelerator facility and here are my crappy photos. For cereal, though, what other areas (I know this isn't just a physicist's job) gets to play with awesome, massive experiments like this? Hell, I gave a talk, so the room was paid for by the APS! Then, oh, right, freaken Nobel Prize winner. How many people in other majors get to say stuff like that?

So, in conclusion, Physics is just better than whatever you're studying. I'm hyper right now.

DISCUSS!
 
Pengwuino said:
Photo of a cluttered laboratory apparatus with stainless steel vacuum chambers, flanged ports, blue equipment frames, bundled cables and hoses, and areas wrapped in aluminum foil.


ZOMG WHAT IS THAT?!?

Photo of a laboratory beamline apparatus with stainless steel vacuum chambers, valves and pumps, red-painted support stands, wrapped aluminium foil on pipes, and tangled cables on a concrete floor.


More awesome. AND I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT IT DOES.
I see a lot of tin foil and duct tape. :-p
 
Last edited:
Yah I was meaning to ask why is there so much tin foil on these experiments?? LIKE THIS:

Ultra-high vacuum chamber system wrapped in aluminium foil, with several viewport windows, flanges and cable runs, next to a white desk lamp in a laboratory.
 
Evo said:
I see a lot of tin foil and duct tape. :-p

I bet, with the leftovers, they make tin foil hats :biggrin:.
 
Pengwuino said:
So sometimes people ask "why physics?" and I tell them about all that BS about learning how the world works, doing stuff that challenges me and interests me...

...

So, in conclusion, Physics is just better than whatever you're studying. I'm hyper right now.

DISCUSS!

Experiments in my field can be done with pencil and paper, thereby saving millions of dollars. Thus, mathematics is better. What say you?
 
I bet it took a lot of engineers to design and build that equipment so you physicists could play with it. :cool:
 
Pengwuino said:
ZOMG WHAT IS THAT?!?
That's a standard gizmoidal deviceitron. They're constructed from restaurant grade 5 gallon steel buckets, tin cans, tin foil, and whatever random wire you have on hand. Some can cost as much as $200.00, so not every experimental facility can afford one. They're amazing: they do pretty much anything you claim they do, and you never have to demonstrate that because they're always down for maintenance.
 
zoobyshoe said:
That's a standard gizmoidal deviceitron. They're constructed from restaurant grade 5 gallon steel buckets, tin cans, tin foil, and whatever random wire you have on hand. Some can cost as much as $200.00, so not every experimental facility can afford one. They're amazing: they do pretty much anything you claim they do, and you never have to demonstrate that because they're always down for maintenance.
:smile:
 
Dembadon said:
Penguino said:
So sometimes people ask "why physics?" and I tell them about all that BS about learning how the world works, doing stuff that challenges me and interests me...

...

So, in conclusion, Physics is just better than whatever you're studying. I'm hyper right now.

DISCUSS!
Experiments in my field can be done with pencil and paper, thereby saving millions of dollars. Thus, mathematics is better. What say you?

Seriously though, I'm pretty jealous. That looks awesome.
 
zoobyshoe said:
That's a standard gizmoidal deviceitron. They're constructed from restaurant grade 5 gallon steel buckets, tin cans, tin foil, and whatever random wire you have on hand. Some can cost as much as $200.00, so not every experimental facility can afford one. They're amazing: they do pretty much anything you claim they do, and you never have to demonstrate that because they're always down for maintenance.

:smile: :smile: :smile: that's hilarious!
 
Dembadon said:
Experiments in my field can be done with pencil and paper, thereby saving millions of dollars. Thus, mathematics is better. What say you?

plus, with a pencil and paper I can make a drawing of an x-ray laser.

:snarky:

also, with the foil, aren't they supposed to put the shiny side inward?
 
Pengwuino said:
Yah I was meaning to ask why is there so much tin foil on these experiments?? LIKE THIS:

Photo of an ultra-high-vacuum apparatus with multiple flanged chambers and viewports wrapped in aluminum foil, with white and yellow cables and a white desk lamp in the foreground.

The foil are there to help during bake-outs.

When a system start from atmospheric pressure and the pumped down to ultra-high vacuum level, you need to do a number of things to hasten the vacuum level to get to that. One of the things that is typically done is to bake the walls of the chamber to above 100 C (some time even up to 200 or 300 C). So there are typically heating tapes wrapped around these vacuum systems. To reduce heat loss to the surrounding, and to promote uniform heating, we tend to wrap the chambers/structures with aluminum foil.

http://physicsandphysicists.blogspot.com/2007/03/its-shiny-and-glittery-and-covered-with.html

BTW, you were probably at the LCLS facility. However, I'm not sure if what you saw was one of the LCLS beamline, part of the LINACS, or part of the LCLS main accelerator itself.

Zz.
 
Pengwuino said:
For cereal, though, what other areas (I know this isn't just a physicist's job) gets to play with awesome, massive experiments like this?
Biologists get to play with awesome instruments too, with the difference that we don't care about the number of wires and valves: it's the experimental result that counts :-p
So, in conclusion, Physics is just better than whatever you're studying. I'm hyper right now.

DISCUSS!
Of course you are free to your own opinion :wink:
 
Woohoo Zapper smartens this thread up :D

I think we were at the LCLS beamline.

That last pic with all the tinfoil was at the SSRL.

The humungousness of the buildings made focusing a camera kind of difficult. We saw the Collider Experimental Hall and there was a pit like, 4 stories deep and a football field long and I couldn't get any good pictures because my stupid camera couldn't focus right :(. The 2 mile tunnel with all the klystrons was impossible to focus too!

Monique said:
Biologists get to play with awesome instruments too, with the difference that we don't care about the number of wires and valves: it's the experimental result that counts :-p

PFF, if you don't care about the number of wires, what else is there to care about?!
 
Pengwuino said:
PFF, if you don't care about the number of wires, what else is there to care about?!

Oooh.. you missed a golden opportunity to tell Monique that most of what Biologists use as their awesome equipment started out as equipments that physicists use! :)

Zz.
 
ZapperZ said:
Oooh.. you missed a golden opportunity to tell Monique that most of what Biologists use as their awesome equipment started out as equipments that physicists use! :)

Zz.

Score! Second hand technology :biggrin:

I need to get a job at a national lab. I don't think the coolness factor would ever wear off. If it did, I would probably cry.
 
ZapperZ said:
Oooh.. you missed a golden opportunity to tell Monique that most of what Biologists use as their awesome equipment started out as equipments that physicists use! :)

Zz.

Oh sure, I would entirely agree with that: physics was a big part of my education as a biologist and we heavily rely on insights in physics for our experiments.

For instance the new super-resolution microscope that uses the non-linear de-excitation of fluorescent dyes to overcome the resolution limit imposed by diffraction with standard confocal laser scanning microscopes and conventional far-field optical microscopes (I stole that from Wikipedia).

Cool technology, but the biologist has the cool application :wink:
 
Monique said:
Oh sure, I would entirely agree with that: physics was a big part of my education as a biologist and we heavily rely on insights in physics for our experiments.

For instance the new super-resolution microscope that uses the non-linear de-excitation of fluorescent dyes to overcome the resolution limit imposed by diffraction with standard confocal laser scanning microscopes and conventional far-field optical microscopes (I stole that from Wikipedia).

Cool technology, but the biologist has the cool application :wink:

Ah, you're forgetting that since I started out as a condensed matter physicists, I also have cool applications for the technology.

Biologists use the light from synchrotron radiation to image biological structures. I, on the other hand, used such light to perform spectroscopy on interesting material. The result can be something like my avatar. So yes, physicists not only care about the hardware, but we also make use of them. There are exotic stuff being done with STM right now, for example, that you will drool over if it ever gets modified to work on biological problems.

So we have the best of both worlds!

:)

Zz.
 
ZapperZ said:
Ah, you're forgetting that since I started out as a condensed matter physicists, I also have cool applications for the technology.
Oh, I'm definitely not forgetting that, I was just challenging Penguino :biggrin:
 
Pengwuino said:
Photo of a dense laboratory apparatus with stainless steel vacuum chambers, flanges, blue metal frames, bundled cables and hoses, and mounted instruments crowded together.

Can it make a cup of tea? If not, my kettle trumps.
 
Pengwuino said:
So sometimes people ask "why physics?" and I tell them about all that BS about learning how the world works, doing stuff that challenges me and interests me...

but this is the actual answer:

Photo of a long laboratory beamline apparatus with vacuum chambers, valves, cabling and metal supports running along a raised platform, with a yellow warning sign at the right edge.


X-ray laser experiment designed to be awesome

Photo of a cluttered laboratory apparatus with stainless steel vacuum chambers, flanges and ports, blue metal frames, bundled cables and flexible metal hoses, with silver foil insulation on some chambers.


ZOMG WHAT IS THAT?!?

Photo of a laboratory beamline apparatus with stainless steel vacuum chambers, flanges, red-painted support frames, cabling, and pumps, with aluminium foil wrapping on a pipe.


More awesome. AND I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT IT DOES.

Control room with rows of dark monitors on wood-finish consoles, black mesh office chairs, a round wooden table, and large photos of mechanical hardware on the back wall.


Okay this is more badass when they're actually here doing experiments

Control room with several wall-mounted monitors above two desks, black office chairs, a computer screen showing a green display, and a blue recycling bin in the foreground.


SLAC Main Control Center, and the people working there act like they don't have a sweet *** job.

Audience seated at round tables in a dim room facing a projector screen showing a slide titled Summary with a block of bullet text; a speaker stands to the right of the screen.


Oh and to top it all off, dinner with a Nobel Prize winner.

SO WHERE WAS I?

Oh, right, I was at the Stanford Linear Accelerator National Lab for the APS CA/NV section meeting. They gave us a tour of the accelerator facility and here are my crappy photos. For cereal, though, what other areas (I know this isn't just a physicist's job) gets to play with awesome, massive experiments like this? Hell, I gave a talk, so the room was paid for by the APS! Then, oh, right, freaken Nobel Prize winner. How many people in other majors get to say stuff like that?

So, in conclusion, Physics is just better than whatever you're studying. I'm hyper right now.

DISCUSS!

ZapperZ said:
The foil are there to help during bake-outs.

When a system start from atmospheric pressure and the pumped down to ultra-high vacuum level, you need to do a number of things to hasten the vacuum level to get to that. One of the things that is typically done is to bake the walls of the chamber to above 100 C (some time even up to 200 or 300 C). So there are typically heating tapes wrapped around these vacuum systems. To reduce heat loss to the surrounding, and to promote uniform heating, we tend to wrap the chambers/structures with aluminum foil.

http://physicsandphysicists.blogspot.com/2007/03/its-shiny-and-glittery-and-covered-with.html

BTW, you were probably at the LCLS facility. However, I'm not sure if what you saw was one of the LCLS beamline, part of the LINACS, or part of the LCLS main accelerator itself.

Zz.

I think I'm in love. :!)

My heart beats faster, my mind wonders, ... I just want to touch it.
 
Monique said:
For instance the new super-resolution microscope that uses the non-linear de-excitation of fluorescent dyes to overcome the resolution limit imposed by diffraction with standard confocal laser scanning microscopes and conventional far-field optical microscopes (I stole that from Wikipedia).\

If you didn't add that last part in parenthesis, I was going to tell you to stop making up large words! :P

Science rocks, it makes me sadface to think of people who work the most mundane boring jobs their entire life that contribute very little to the world.
 
Cool toys.

Yet a challenge is stated by a surgeon. You get to work on it when it is shut down. we get to work on it while it is still working.

Just saying.. And I aint no surgeon. Would not be/ could not handle the fail part of it.
 
zoobyshoe said:
That's a standard gizmoidal deviceitron.
What a nice surprise it's just the right size
For someone just like you
It's just what you need
and it's guaranteed
To do exactly what it will do
It stays together
it'll last forever
Which is something new these days
One thing about it you can live without it
But you'll order one today

- Klaatu
 
Tune in next week when I prove that Italian food is better than whatever you eat.
 
Pengwuino said:
Tune in next week when I prove that Italian food is better than whatever you eat.

Don't penguins eat fish and squid?
 
chiro said:
Don't penguins eat fish and squid?

Are fish and squid typical Italian foods?