Block sliding on a semicircular track with friction

  • Thread starter zuzelle
  • Start date
10 replies · 3K views · last reply
zuzelle
Messages
6
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
A block of mass m rests at point A on a circular track of radius r with coefficient of friction u. It is then released with no initial speed. Find the dependance of velocity on angle, v(theta).
Relevant Equations
Potential Energy = mgh
Kinetic Energy = mv^2/2
Work done by a force = F*S
Centripetal force = mv^2/R
Since the friction is constantly changing because of both angle change and velocity change, I took a very small angle dθ, so that while the block is covering it, its velocity would change by dv, its height by rdθ*cosθ and the friction force wouldn't change much, because N isn't changing either.
Diagram of a block m released from rest at point A on the rim of a semicircular track; angle theta from the horizontal, small angle d-theta, and velocity v along the track are marked in red.

Then, I wrote the equation for centripetal force:
N - mgsin(θ) =
Fraction with numerator mv squared and denominator r, the centripetal force expression mv²/r.


FBD:
Free-body diagram of a block on the inside of a curved track, with normal force N pointing toward the centre, friction Ff pointing up along the track, and weight mg pointing straight down, with angle theta marked at the block.


Next, I thought of writing conservation of energy for this small displacement:
Potential energy + Kinetic energy = Work by friction on this small displacement + Kinetic Energy after.

So I got this:
Handwritten diagram of a block on a circular arc of radius r, with angle dθ and angle θ marked, and two handwritten equations: N - mg sinθ = m v²/r, and mgr dθ cosθ + m v²/2 = μ m (v²/r + g sinθ) r dθ + m(v + dv)²/2.

And I am not sure if this is right, because I end up getting an equation with differentials left, and it doesn't make sense. Could someone help, please?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a block of mass m at point A on the rim of a semicircular bowl, with a second block partway down the curved surface. A red line from the centre marks an angle θ, a small increment dθ, and the speed v along the arc.
    1712748555183.png
    7.6 KB · Views: 159
  • Fraction with numerator mv squared and denominator r, the centripetal force expression mv²/r.
    1712748791367.png
    1.9 KB · Views: 132
  • Handwritten diagram of a block on a circular arc of radius r, angle θ marked and dθ shown, with two handwritten equations: N - mg sinθ = mv²/r, and mgr dθ cosθ + mvdv... expression involving m(v+dv)²/2.
    1712748971900.png
    7 KB · Views: 125
Last edited:
zuzelle said:
Okay
Maybe dont work with the differentials in Work-Energy right away. Write Work-Energy in the standard way and differentiate w.r.t. ##\theta##. So you will have your normal terms plus an integral ( representing the work done by the friction force up to some angle ##\theta## ) in the first step. Then that result will be differentiated w.r.t ##\theta## to get the first order-nonlinear ODE.

I think it can be transformed into a linear ODE from there with a standard substition technique and solved with integration factor technique.
 
Last edited:
Excuse me for asking again, like this?
 
Attachments
  • Equation: mgr = mgr(1 - sin θ) + mv²/2 + μm ∫ from 0 to θ of (g sin θ + v²/r) r dθ
    1712760056140.png
    2.7 KB · Views: 156
  • Equation: g r sin θ + μ g r cos θ = v^2/2 + integral from 0 to θ of v^2 dθ, written in handwritten-style typeset math.
    1712760876453.png
    3.7 KB · Views: 148
Start with ##~N=mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r.~## Using ##\omega## is preferable because linear variables (##v##) and angular variables (##\theta##) are not mixed. The force of friction is
##f_k=\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r)## and the Newton's second law in the tangential direction of motion is
##ma_t=mr\dfrac{d\omega}{dt}=mg\cos\theta-\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r).##
Following @erobz's suggestion
erobz said:
I think it can be transformed into a linear ODE from there with a standard substition technique and solved with integration factor technique.
##\dfrac{d\omega}{dt}=\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}\dfrac{d\theta}{dt}=\omega\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}## Now you see the reason for ditching variable ##v##. The differential equation you have to solve is $$m\omega\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}=mg\cos\theta-\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r).$$ It should give you ##\omega(\theta)## from which getting ##v(\theta)## is trivial since ##r## is constant.

(Edited to fix typo in equation. See posts #10 and #11)
 
Last edited:
zuzelle said:
Excuse me for asking again, like this?
Your equation on the left becomes:

$$ 0 = -mgr \sin \theta + \frac{1}{2}m v^2 + \mu m r \int \left( \frac{v^2}{r} + g \sin \theta \right) d\theta $$

Now differentiate both sides with respect to ##\theta##.

EDIT: Going from Newtons Laws obviously works too (also more direct) as @kuruman showed.
 
Last edited:
Also, so we can quote your equations that follow, please take a moment to learn the math formatting from LaTeX Guide
 
kuruman said:
Start with ##~N=mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r.~## Using ##\omega## is preferable because linear variables (##v##) and angular variables (##\theta##) are not mixed. The force of friction is
##f_k=\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r)## and the Newton's second law in the tangential direction of motion is
##ma_t=mr\dfrac{d\omega}{dt}=mg\sin\theta-\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r).##
Following @erobz's suggestion

##\dfrac{d\omega}{dt}=\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}\dfrac{d\theta}{dt}=\omega\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}## Now you see the reason for ditching variable ##v##. The differential equation you have to solve is $$m\omega\dfrac{d\omega}{d\theta}=mg\sin\theta-\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r).$$ It should give you ##\omega(\theta)## from which getting ##v(\theta)## is trivial since ##r## is constant.
erobz said:
Your equation on the left becomes:

$$ 0 = -mgr \sin \theta + \frac{1}{2}m v^2 + \mu m r \int \left( \frac{v^2}{r} + g \sin \theta \right) d\theta $$

Now differentiate both sides with respect to ##\theta##.

EDIT: Going from Newtons Laws obviously works too as @kuruman showed.
That makes sense, thank you
 
kuruman said:
Newton's second law in the tangential direction of motion is
##ma_t=mr\dfrac{d\omega}{dt}=mg\sin\theta-\mu(mg\sin\theta +m\omega^2r).##
Check the first term on the right side. I don't think ##\sin \theta## is the correct trig function here. For example, ##a_t## should equal ##g## at the starting point where ##\theta = 0## and ##\omega = 0##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: kuruman and erobz
TSny said:
Check the first term on the right side. I don't think ##\sin \theta## is the correct trig function here. For example, ##a_t## should equal ##g## at the starting point where ##\theta = 0## and ##\omega = 0##.
Yes. One cannot have the same trig function of ##\theta## for ##N## and ##a_t## which are orthogonal. Nice catch. Typo fixed - thanks.