Calculate the magnetic field from the vector potential

4 replies · 3K views · last reply
arjun_ar
Messages
3
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
Given the magnetic vector potential of a current carrying loop in cylindrical coordinate system, derive the axial and radial magnetic fields.
Relevant Equations
Please read ahead.
I am trying to derive radial and axial magnetic fields of a current carrying loop from its magnetic vector potential. So far, I have succeeded in deriving the radial field but axial field derivation gives me trouble.
Typeset derivation of the axial field of a current loop: A_phi with K and E elliptic integrals and k = sqrt(4a rho / ((a+rho)^2+z^2)), then B_r (eq 1) and B_z (eq 2) written in terms of K and E.


My derivation of radial field (eq 1) can be found here.

Can anyone point out where I went wrong in the derivation of axial field?

My derivation of axial field is given below.

Handwritten derivation of the axial magnetic field of a current loop from its vector potential, with numbered equations (4) and (7) and expressions involving K and E.


In case the images are blurred, you can see them here and here.

On comparing, Eq.7 with Eq.2, the coefficient of E do not match.

I have done this derivation multiple times, yet arrive at the same answer.
Can anyone point me where I went wrong?
 
Last edited:
Hmm is it dead sure that K and E are independent of ##\rho,z##? So you can treat them as constants when taking the derivatives with respect to those variables?
 
I think the mistake is here:

Typeset equation fragment with two green ellipses: the first circles (a^2 - ρ^2 + z^2) in a numerator, the second circles (v^2 + z^2 + 2aρ) in a second line where u = a + ρ, v = a - ρ are defined.


The two expressions circled in green are not equivalent.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you have typographical errors in your equations (1) and (2)? Should the denominators inside the square brackets be ##(a-\rho)^2 + z^2## instead of ##(a+\rho)^2 + z^2##?
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: arjun_ar and Delta2
Delta2 said:
Hmm is it dead sure that K and E are independent of ##\rho,z##? So you can treat them as constants when taking the derivatives with respect to those variables?
Thank you for your response.
I think they are independent of ##\rho,z##. In my derivation of radial field, I have treated them to be independent of ##z## and arrived at the exact solution.
 
TSny said:
I think the mistake is here:

View attachment 304311

The two expressions circled in green are not equivalent.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you have typographical errors in your equations (1) and (2)? Should the denominators inside the square brackets be ##(a-\rho)^2 + z^2## instead of ##(a+\rho)^2 + z^2##?
Thank you! This solves my problem. I don't know how I missed it!

There is indeed a typographical error for equations (1) and (2). I will update them and provide a full derivation for axial field asap.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TSny and Delta2