Calculating x Position of a Moving Object

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the time of flight for a marble rolling off a table and falling to the ground. The initial vertical position equation was incorrectly applied, leading to a miscalculation of time. The correct approach involves considering both vertical and horizontal components of motion, specifically the distances and velocities involved. After clarifying the calculations and addressing previous errors, the correct time from L to N was determined to be 0.572 seconds. This highlights the importance of accurately interpreting the problem and applying the relevant equations.
Undeterred247
Messages
6
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
A very small steel marble is shown rolling at a constant speed on a horizontal table. The marble leaves the table at M, falls, and hits the ground at N. This is illustrated in the diagram below which is drawn to scale. Calculate the time it took the marble to travel from L to N.
Relevant Equations
p(t) = p0 +v0 * t +1/2*a*t^2
a = -g = -9.81m/s^2 = -981cm/s^2
Vertical position (x component):
y(t) = y0 +v0 * t -1/2*g*t^2
Position yx(t) = 0cm = 40cm + 0 *t -1/2 * 981cm/s/s * t^2
edit: I replaced v0 = 0 and got t = 0.286s, which is incorrect according to the submission.

This didn't work so I thought maybe by finding the angle of the throw would help with the following equation but there are still not enough parts to it:
yx(t) = y0 +v0 * sintheta * t -1/2 *g * t^2
yx(t) = 40cm + v0 * sin(36.84) * t -1/2 *981cm/s/s *t^2

Theta = angle of throw where
horizontal = 30cm
vertical = 40cm
hypotenuse = 50cm

I found https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/rolling-marble-on-table.469634/ which is similar to this problem but I still don't understand how to solve this. Please help!
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2022-05-24 at 11.42.26 AM.png
    Screen Shot 2022-05-24 at 11.42.26 AM.png
    21.8 KB · Views: 121
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Start with eliminating all aspects of the x-axis.

That leaves a marble that starts off with v=0 and falls a given distance. You should be able to determine the time of that fall.
 
Watch this video. What does it suggest about the time of flight of the marble?

 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban
Undeterred247 said:
Homework Statement:: A very small steel marble is shown rolling at a constant speed on a horizontal table. The marble leaves the table at M, falls, and hits the ground at N. This is illustrated in the diagram below which is drawn to scale. Calculate the time it took the marble to travel from L to N.
Relevant Equations:: p(t) = p0 +v0 * t +1/2*a*t^2
a = -g = -9.81m/s^2 = -981cm/s^2

Vertical position (x component):
y(t) = y0 +v0 * t -1/2*g*t^2
Position yx(t) = 0cm = 40cm + 0 *t -1/2 * 981cm/s/s * t^2
edit: I replaced v0 = 0 and t = 0.286s, which is incorrect according to the submission.

This didn't work so I thought maybe by finding the angle of the throw would help with the following equation but there are still not enough parts to it:
yx(t) = y0 +v0 * sintheta * t -1/2 *g * t^2
yx(t) = 40cm + v0 * sin(36.84) * t -1/2 *981cm/s/s *t^2

Theta = angle of throw where
horizontal = 30cm
vertical = 40cm
hypotenuse = 50cm

I found https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/rolling-marble-on-table.469634/ which is similar to this problem but I still don't understand how to solve this. Please help!
Hello @Undeterred247 .
:welcome:

You correctly calculated the time to go from M to N .

You're not finished.
 
  • Like
Likes Undeterred247
Undeterred247 said:
edit: I replaced v0 = 0 and t = 0.286s, which is incorrect according to the submission.
(I assume you meant "I replaced v0 = 0 and got t = 0.286s".)
Maybe you did not read the question correctly. It says "Calculate the time it took the marble to travel from L to N.", not M to N.
 
SammyS said:
Hello @Undeterred247 .
:welcome:

You correctly calculated the time to go from M to N .

You're not finished.
Thank you! How would I use this time from M to N to calculate for the time from L to N?
 
Undeterred247 said:
Thank you! How would I use this time from M to N to calculate for the time from L to N?
Do you know how far the ball rolls horizontally from L to N?
Do you know how fast it rolls?
 
jbriggs444 said:
Do you know how far the ball rolls horizontally from L to N?
Do you know how fast it rolls?
I calculated
Vy = Voy +ay *t
Vy = 0 -981 * (0.286)^2
Vy = -80.24

Then took the total distance 60cm/-80.24 = t = -0.748
But when checked this answer is incorrect.
 
Undeterred247 said:
I calculated
Vy = Voy +ay *t
Vy = 0 -981 * (0.286)^2
Vy = -80.24

Then took the total distance 60cm/-80.24 = t = -0.748
But when checked this answer is incorrect.
Well, yes, that calculation seems to be an incorrect calculation of the wrong thing and does not make any use of the suggestion that was offered.

As nearly as I can determine, it is a garbled calculation of twice the vertical displacement from M to N using cgs units. This is a rather backwards way to proceed since the I believe that the 0.286 s input to the calculation was originally found by using the actual displacement of -40.0 cm as the input.

The factor of two error seems to be from misquoting the SUVAT equation and the 0.24 error is likely from rounding 0.285568... to 0.286. Once that gets fixed, there is the problem of having calculated the wrong thing.
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Undeterred247 said:
Thank you! How would I use this time from M to N to calculate for the time from L to N?
Consider the ##x## component of displacement, velocity, and acceleration for both L to M as well as
from M to N .
 
  • #11
Thank you for your help! I figured it out!
The answer is t = 0.572s
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and Lnewqban
Back
Top