Calculus of Variations: First Variation Definition?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter rdt2
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Variation
2 replies · 3K views · last reply
rdt2
Messages
124
Reaction score
2
I put this question in the 'Calculus' forum but didn't really get a response. Maybe it's a silly question but I thought I'd try here anyway:

Older textbooks on the Calculus of Variations seem to define the first variation of a functional [tex]\Pi[/tex] as:

[tex]\delta \Pi = \Pi(f + \delta f) - \Pi (f)[/tex]

which looks analogous to:

[tex]\delta f = \frac {df} {dx} \delta x = lim_{\delta x \rightarrow 0} (f(x+ \delta x) -f(x))[/tex]

from differential calculus. However, newer books seem to define the first variation as the Gateaux derivative:

[tex]\left[ \frac {d} {d \epsilon} \Pi (f+ \epsilon h) \right]_{\epsilon = 0 }[/tex]

which looks more like the gradient [tex]\frac {df} {dx}[/tex] than the difference [tex]\delta x[/tex]. Which is the better 'basic' definition?
 
If you know vector calculus, of course you should go on with Gateaux derivative.
 
I've never seen anyone call the first one called the first variation. Everyone calls the Gateaux derivative the first variation.