Calculus Problem: Blowing Up a Spherical Balloon

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Idan9988
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
.
Relevant Equations
.
Printed textbook problem 35 about air blown into a spherical balloon: radius 6.50 cm increasing at 0.900 cm/s, with parts (a) to (c) asking for volume rate, radius rate at 13.0 cm, and an explanation.

I'm struggling with section a. This is my calculation:
Handwritten derivation on grid paper: r0 = 6.50 cm, dr/dt = 0.900 cm/s, r(t) = r0 + (dr/dt)t, V = (4/3)π(r0 + (dr/dt)t)^3, and dV/dt = (4/3)π·3(r0 + (dr/dt)t)^2·(dr/dt).

The expression remains depend on the variable t, while in the answer is a concrete number:
Worked solution P1.35: dV/dt = d/dt(4/3 πr^3) = 4/3 π(3r^2)dr/dt = (4πr^2)dr/dt. Part (a): dV/dt = 4π(6.5 cm)^2(0.9 cm/s) = 478 cm^3/s, final value boxed.
 
[itex]r = r_0 + 0.9t[/itex] is only valid if [itex]dr/dt[/itex] is constant.

Why did you assume that [itex]dr/dt[/itex] was constant? The question only tells you that [itex]dr/dt = 0.900\,\mathrm{cm}/\mathrm{s}[/itex] when [itex]r = 6.50\,\mathrm{cm}[/itex].
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Idan9988, malawi_glenn and erobz
Agree,

The answer (a) has all the information. Since the volume flow rate is constant, then ##\frac {dV}{dt}## is a constant.

##\frac {dr}{dt}## is variable.

If you rearrange the expression to solve for ##\frac {dr}{dt}## and you get the answer to (b) and the behavior that explains (c).